Did you prefer "Alice" or "One Day at a Time"?

[TMC]

I'm dying to know which will win in a head-to-head battle.

• Second Banana:
  
  Mel vs Schneider
  
  Teenage Kid:
  
  Alex vs Tommy
  
  Old Famous People:
  
  Nanette Fabray vs Martha Ray
  
  Best Friend:
  
  Jenny vs Flo
  
  Young Women:
  
  Barbara & Julie vs Vera & Jolene
  
  Supporting cast:
  
  Leading Lady:
  
  Ann vs Alice

[MiracleHand]

As a kid I liked ODAAT better but as an adult I laugh harder at Alice. Love both though and have all of ODAAT on DVD and seasons 1-7 (waiting for 8-9) of Alice.

[Bonniegirl]

Younger, first run I'd say Alice. Now as an adult I still love Alice but I love ODAAT too. And ODAAT has the love of my life Max!!

I like Mel a bit more than Schneider, Tommy way better than Alex, Nanette and Martha undecided ?, Flo better than Ginny, Barbara & Julie equal to Vera & Jolene, Alice better than Ann.

[tlc38tlc38]

I like Alice more but I still enjoy ODAAT.

My winners are in bold...

Second Banana:

Mel vs Schneider

Teenage Kid:

Alex vs Tommy

Old Famous People:

Nanette Fabray vs Martha Ray

Best Friend:

Jenny vs Flo

Young Women:

Barbara & Julie vs Vera & Jolene

Leading Lady:

Ann vs Alice....actually neither.

[Alex Cooper]

Originally Posted by Bonniegirl

Younger, first run I'd say Alice. Now as an adult I still love Alice but I love ODAAT too. And ODAAT has the love of my life Max!!

Tommy way better than Alex.

I'm crying!

[Svenfan1234]

Originally Posted by Alex Cooper

I'm crying!

Hi, Alex.

[Sonny Carson]

Originally Posted by MiracleHand

As a kid I liked ODAAT better but as an adult I laugh harder at Alice. Love both though and have all of ODAAT on DVD and seasons 1-7 (waiting for 8-9) of Alice.

This!

[Alex Cooper]

Originally Posted by Svenfan1234

Hi, Alex.

Sven!

[Bonniegirl]

Wouldn't it have been cool if they did a Alice/ ODAAT crossover episode? The ODAAT gang could be taking a road trip to California in Schneider's camper. They stop for a bite to eat in Phoenix at Mel's diner !!! Couldn't you totally see Flo and Schneider flirting with each other?!

[Alex Cooper]

Originally Posted by Bonniegirl

Wouldn't it have been cool if they did a Alice/ ODAAT crossover episode? The ODAAT gang could be taking a road trip to California in Schneider's camper. They stop for a bite to eat in Phoenix at Mel's diner !!! Couldn't you totally see Flo and Schneider flirting with each other?!

That would have been cool! I think Tommy would have gotten a crush on Barbara too.. Ann and Alice would likely have butted heads. Or maybe Ann and Mel after Ms. Romano sees how he treats his waitresses.

[Bonniegirl]

Originally Posted by Alex Cooper

That would have been cool! I think Tommy would have gotten a crush on Barbara too.. Ann and Alice would likely have butted heads. Or maybe Ann and Mel after Ms. Romano sees how he treats his waitresses.

Yeah I was thinking of Tommy having a crush on Barbara! And I thought Mel would maybe have the hots for Ann, but your scenario is better , he would like her but she wouldn't reciprocate his advances feeling he was too much a male chauvinist because like you say the way he treats his waitresses. How about if Ann convinced them to go on strike?

[opus]

Originally Posted by TMC

I'm dying to know which will win in a head-to-head battle.



Young Women:

Barbara & Julie vs Vera & Jolene

I'm no Alice expert, but they weren't close to same age, were they?

[Alex Cooper]

Originally Posted by Bonniegirl

Yeah I was thinking of Tommy having a crush on Barbara! And I thought Mel would maybe have the hots for Ann, but your scenario is better , he would like her but she wouldn't reciprocate his advances feeling he was too much a male chauvinist because like you say the way he treats his waitresses. How about if Ann convinced them to go on strike?

Yes! There'd definitely be some civil unrest, a battle of the network stars!

[Bonniegirl]

Originally Posted by opus

I'm no Alice expert, but they weren't close to same age, were they?

Yeah ! Barbara and Julie were much younger than Vera and Jolene ! They weren't young women! Esp. by those days standards. They were probably supposed to be like mid 30's ?

[Svenfan1234]

Originally Posted by Bonniegirl

Yeah I was thinking of Tommy having a crush on Barbara! And I thought Mel would maybe have the hots for Ann, but your scenario is better , he would like her but she wouldn't reciprocate his advances feeling he was too much a male chauvinist because like you say the way he treats his waitresses. How about if Ann convinced them to go on strike?

I could totally see Mel telling Ann to "stow it"! ...among other things.

Ann and Alice would totally have butted heads, and maybe Ann would've been disappointed with the way Flo handles herself. Ann would've probably given Flo a women's lib speech.