Actors who played multiple roles in re-enactments

[schmave]

Originally Posted by khanartist79

North appeared on the show one other time as Harley Price, an abusive alcoholic, who often left his kids in the car for hours while he frequented the bars in town. IIRC, Harley's wife eventually left him, but when she was told she would have to return to him in order to get custody of their kids, she refused; so, the kids ended up being taken by the courts and placed in foster homes.

Kind of follows the trend of actors being used for segments that appear in the same region. The Harley Price and (most of the) Strickland cases took place in Michigan, and the Miller/English case was set in my hometown of Columbus, Ohio. Whether it was filmed here, I don't know.
The lady who played Wendy Camp also played Lela Stallings. Both of those were in Oklahoma.
And Jaycee, yes, the man who played Ernest Acosta also portrayed Carl Austin Weiss' father. Both in Louisiana, of course.

[Or So It Seems]

I don't know if it's been mentioned before, but I noticed tonight that one of the thugs in the CW Roddy segment was none other than Todd Mueller (wearing his trademark baseball hat).

https://youtu.be/opOW9pkokME?t=2560

This segment also has the overly dramatic FBI Agent, William E. Smith, who we also see prominently in the Dark Dante segment.

[TheCars1986]

Originally Posted by Or So It Seems

I don't know if it's been mentioned before, but I noticed tonight that one of the thugs in the CW Roddy segment was none other than Todd Mueller (wearing his trademark baseball hat).

He also played Larry Monroe in the Don Smith segment.

[Janel "Jaycee" Miller]

Hi.

The girl who plays a young Barbara Smith Reed (the girl who runs down the street crying after being told she was adopted in the 1940s and later finds out her best friend is her sister) looks a lot like the girl who played a young Aideen Murphy (the girl who was placed in a London orphanage and makes friends with Eve Meisel who was placed at the same orphanage after her family fled the Nazis)?

Anyone else think the actress is the same?

[The Gov]

I'm almost certain the doctor who delivered Alberta Elaine Schambier was the also Erik Kessler.

[schmave]

Just rewatched the segment and it could be him, but his appearance is so brief that it's hard to tell. Lighting did not favor him either, as in not getting a great look.

[WishfulDreamer]

The non-custodial husbands in the Craig Walker and David Estright cases were played by the same actor.

[Usmysteriesmaniac]

Originally Posted by PortoMarco

A bit off tangent, to me the best acting job is done by the Jim Burnside guy. Man, what great casting that was. He looked, sounded, and acted like a brazen psychopath.

The same actor who played Jim Burnside also played him when that case was featured in America's Most Wanted at the time. It would be interesting to see how that segment was featured in that show, provided there's someone, anyone out there who may happen to have it someway, somehow.

[DALLASTEXAN!!]

not an actor, but I was reminded recently when I watched the dwayne mccorkendale segment that the detective Paul Renfrow appeared in multiple segments. He was in the aileen conway and michael st. clair segments as well.

[TheCars1986]

The guy who played Don Smith also played William L. Toomey.

[brianh333]

Originally Posted by TheCars1986

He also played Larry Monroe in the Don Smith segment.

I don't suppose you've ever found the name of this actor, have you? I posed the question back in 2017 earlier in this thread, and after stumbling into the CW Roddy segment recently and seeing him pop up again, this mystery crossed my mind once again.

I've tried IMDB, Google, Fandom, multiple searches throughout this forum, and I keep coming up completely empty.

[TheCars1986]

Originally Posted by brianh333

I don't suppose you've ever found the name of this actor, have you? I posed the question back in 2017 earlier in this thread, and after stumbling into the CW Roddy segment recently and seeing him pop up again, this mystery crossed my mind once again.

I've tried IMDB, Google, Fandom, multiple searches throughout this forum, and I keep coming up completely empty.

No I do not know his name unfortunately.

The actor who played Brad Bishop was also in the Frank Olson segment as one of the other agents at the retreat where Olson was given a spiked drink.

[ghosthouse]

Originally Posted by brianh333

I don't suppose you've ever found the name of this actor, have you? I posed the question back in 2017 earlier in this thread, and after stumbling into the CW Roddy segment recently and seeing him pop up again, this mystery crossed my mind once again.

I've tried IMDB, Google, Fandom, multiple searches throughout this forum, and I keep coming up completely empty.

Originally Posted by TheCars1986

No I do not know his name unfortunately.

The actor who played Brad Bishop was also in the Frank Olson segment as one of the other agents at the retreat where Olson was given a spiked drink.

I think someone has confirmed the guy playing Todd Mueller, Larry Monroe, gangster in the CW Roddy Segment, etc was an UM production assistant so I doubt he has much of an IMDB.

Also, speaking of Brad Bishop...the detective that uses the key from the neighbor to enter the Bishop house and finds all the blood also plays the detective in the hotel room in the Danny Casalero segment. Guessing since both were Washington DC area cases they used the same casting resources.

[dynoguy88]

I'm 99% sure the actor playing the Rock Creek gang member (in the Chief Hamerick segment) changing a tire and talking to a police officer is the same actor who portrayed the high school version of sweet Victor Simon...who fell asleep in class and was devastated when his birth parents weren't at his high school graduation.

Both these cases also took place in Ohio. Coincidence?

[MegtheEgg86]

Originally Posted by Or So It Seems

the overly dramatic FBI Agent, William E. Smith

I love that guy. "...his curiosity became unsatis-fiiiied.."