All right. Who did not vote for Rueben?

[ThomasE]

I cannot believe he was almost voted out tonight! Second to last. Unbeliveable. Simon was totally shocked. Treneyce being voted off was not a cool thing at all. We all know that Josh should have been the one to go. Unlike Simon, I think Josh is a good singer but I think he should have been the one to go tonight. I would have hated to see that happen but Trenyce and Rueben should have remained. Who ever did not vote for Rueben or Treneyce I will beat you up.................if my mommy let's me. LOL.

I thought it was so cool to see the other contestants come back tonight and I loved Treneyce's farewell song and I liked how the other contestants came back out on stage towards the end of the show. What are your comments?

[ks]

Ruuuuuuuuuben!

I was totally shocked he was in the bottom two. The guy is an awesome singer, not to mention he's representin'!

Anyway, I had decided if he were to go I wasn't gonna watch the show anymore. America got it wrong tonight and it better be straightened out quick like because Ruben does NOT deserve to be voted off.


I think Josh has stuck around so long because all the girls think he's hot...not fair for the others.

It should be Josh and someone else in the bottom two next week, just not Ruben! I keep waitin' for Clay to pay centerstage a visit. I agree with Simon, he does overdo those facial expressions. They're beginning to flat out bothe me actually.





RuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuBEN!







ks

[JenCas]

I love Josh I really do. I think he has a career in music, but he just doesn't compare to the rest of the competition. Trenyce is great but imo wasn't going to make it to the final four.
PLEASE PEOPLE VOTE ON VOCAL TALENT.... THIS IS A SINGING COMPETITION..... And I am as patriotic as the rest but just because he's a cute marine doesn't mean he should win a singing contest.

[vienna waits]

I'm PISSED!!! Not because Ruben was in the bottom, but because Trenyce was ROBBED! It's clear that Josh should have went home. I wanna beat him with a stick. I would have rather seen Ruben go. CLAY ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!

[vienna waits]

Originally posted by JenCas
And I am as patriotic as the rest but just because he's a cute marine doesn't mean he should win a singing contest.

yeah and he's immature and childish. The reason he's a marine is because he had nothing else going for him.

[Czas na Zywiec]

Originally posted by ks

I think Josh has stuck around so long because all the girls think he's hot...not fair for the others.

I talked to a lot of girls and they said he's not even all that attractive. It's because he's in the military, that's why. lol I wrote my whole shpeel in the other thread. Let me get the link.

Here we go.
http://www.sitcomsonline.com/boards/...9&pagenumber=2

[MidnightRose21498]

You guys are all ragging on Josh but it's not his fault that he's up there still when he probably shouldn't be. It's the voters that keep him there. It has nothing to do with him. I think you all should give the guy a break. He didn't do so good tuesday night and he knew it. You could tell when they announced that Ruben was in the bottom two. If you are going to get ticked off at someone get ticked off at the voters. I think if we've learned anything from this season it's that ANYTHING can happen. Look at Rikki and Kim C. They got voted off before they should have, in my opinion.

[vienna waits]

Originally posted by MidnightRose21498
You guys are all ragging on Josh but it's not his fault that he's up there still when he probably shouldn't be. It's the voters that keep him there. It has nothing to do with him. I think you all should give the guy a break. He didn't do so good tuesday night and he knew it. You could tell when they announced that Ruben was in the bottom two. If you are going to get ticked off at someone get ticked off at the voters. I think if we've learned anything from this season it's that ANYTHING can happen. Look at Rikki and Kim C. They got voted off before they should have, in my opinion.

Everyone treated Carmen like complete scum and no one cared then. People have said she has herpes, referred to her as goat girl, claimed she had sex with Simon and therefore got on the show.. complete bull **** stuff. When I say Josh is childish, it's actually true.

[MidnightRose21498]

Originally posted by YearbookLoser


Everyone treated Carmen like complete scum and no one cared then. People have said she has herpes, referred to her as goat girl, claimed she had sex with Simon and therefore got on the show.. complete bull **** stuff. When I say Josh is childish, it's actually true.

I totally agree with you about Carmen. Everyone did treat her horribly. They shouldn't have been so harsh and critical.

But why are you saying Josh is childish? I'm not trying to start anything here but what do you base that criticism on? I totally don't see it. He's just been up there singing and reacting to Simon's rather rude comments. I would too. I wouldn't just let someone say some of the things he's said to me in front of millions of people and not have a come back. I agree that the judges should be honest in their critiques but they don't have to be downright rude about it.

Don't get me wrong. Josh should be the next to go. I want Ruben or Clay to win. I just think that people should stop blaming the contestants who don't measure up so well for the fact that they are still there when they have nothing to do with it. (Examples... Carmen and Josh)

[callmetootie]

Treynce proved that she wanted to stay in this competition longer last night. Her rendition of "Proud Mary" was just as good as Tina Turner's, if not even better. Ruben on the other hand, was the same. Ruben is OVERRATED!!!! The other contestants are out there dancing their hearts out, and moving around, and Ruben occasionally swifts his right arm around. Ruben should've gone over Treynce.

And as for Josh not going, it's because FOX has obviously been playing with the votes. Because they're a family network, they want someone like Josh Gracin "The Marine" on their program, so they don't wanna let him go. Instead, they build tension, by putting the person with possibly the most votes last night in the runner-up place. FOX has been doing this all along. Trust me. Call up a private investigator, and ring their bells.

Kimberley Locke is going to end up winning this entire competition. Why? Because she's the only one left that really wants it, and that has improved. Josh USED to be good, but now he sounds like a rooster. Josh has been on a downhill slide for ages, and her fans have been calling in like banchees trying to save his tush. Clay is too theatrical, and he isn't determined to win this competition. He's nice, and would rather see Ruben or Kim win. Ruben, I've already stated by point on. She gives the same dreary little Barry White performance every week. Kimberley Locke is going to win this entire competition, and become a star.

Josh is going to leave next week. Why? Because there's no one else that can leave! There are too big of fan-bases for Ruben, Clay, and Kimberley to kick them out. I salute you Josh. The following week will say goodbye to Clay. And then Kimberley will be crowned Queen Of The Night.

[-*Leah*-]

imo It should have been Josh and Trenyce in the bottom 2 and Josh should have left nbot Trenyce. Ruebn definatley shouldn't have been in the bottom 2

[ThomasE]

Callmetootie, I don't think the Ruben thing is overrated at all. You don't have to move around and dance to attract people. Rueben has proven that. His voice keeps you occupied well enough. I do agree that Josh should the next to do. I felt bad for him, though. I know that he was relieved last night. He should be next. Trenyce went out with a bang last night with her rendition of "Proud Mary" . I also agree that we need to vote based on vocals and not out of sympathy. Josh should have been gone when he sang "Celebrate Good Times" and I think Ricky was dismissed a week later. I did not get a chance to vote Tuesday because I forgot to at the last minute but I can see why votes do count so I will make it my business to vote next week. Poor Trenyce.

I admire Carmen for sticking it out the way she did. God Bless her. I believe that I heard Ryan say that she is going to be on tour. Kim Caldwell was voted off before Carmen. Although she had to take mess as well, I admire her for her attitude. When Simon would bash her some days, she would say "I will keep my comments to myself" . At least both girls will have great things coming their way. I loved how Josh made a comeback at Simon with that "respect my elders" joke at him. callmetootie, if anyone is overrated, its Simon. People look at him like he's God. There are times when he really does not realize true talent on stage. I did not think Josh was bad tuesday night, but they said he was. I liked Simon's comment about Kimberly L. "you could hear that song in church somewhere" . That was too funny. I loved when she sang that song "I heard it through the grapevine" and it did sound like it was a gospel song. I loved it. callmetootie, btw, have the trade list available whenever you are ready!

[Christopher]

I didn't vote for Ruben, and I never will. I am voting for Clay. He is the one up there with the talent, he should win imo

[David]

Josh should've left!!!!

But I actually am sticking on voting on Kimberley Locke and Clay Aiken... Honestly, I'm getting a little sick of Ruben... but I still like him! But Josh NEEDS to go next week... cuz if people keep sympathizing for him, he might go in the top 2 and embarass himself deeply....

[sara]

I like Ruben, but I only vote for Clay.