Aaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhh

[vienna waits]

So what did you guys think of tonight's show????? I thought Carmen was AWESOME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! She's still hot as ever. And talk about a HOT outfit. *drools*. Tight jeans and shirt. Niiiiiiice. I'm sad that she has turned 18 though . 17 is good, 18 is too old. The straight hair is nice too. Randy is a little bitch though. He just says that "pitch problems" **** whenever he doesn't know what to say. He probably doesn't even know what it means. I think the judges are harder on Carmen just because of her age. Anyhoo I voted for Carmen 25 times. For the others, I didn't enjoy Josh's song. It was mostly talking and he kept skipping words and lines... not a great song to show off your singing talent. Kimberly Locke good, Corey.. ALOT better, Julia .. much better as well. Trenyce.. ehh it was ok. Kimberly.. good, Ruben.. good. Hercules.. sucked. Clay was GREAT..but it sucked how they cut his performance short. My bottom three for tomorrow would be Corey, Julia, & Trenyce. Corey should leave.

[vienna waits]

Oops I initially forgot to clarify that I'm talking about American Idol. lol but thats like the only topic discussed here so yah. AND WHAT WAS UP WITH COREY"S SHIRT???/

[-*Leah*-]

I thought that Carmen did okay. I think that Julia should leave, NOW ! I also can't stand that Cory Clark dude. The rest are really good. I personally thought that Kimberly Caldwell looked like a slut, but thats just my opinion I guess. Kimberly Locke is doing much better, and even though I really didn't like him to start with, I am really starting to like Clay ! RUBEN is by far my favorite, and not just because he's from Alabama (the same as me) he is a really good singer. I thought that Simon was being a butt tonite as usual, and Randy is not my favorite, but he really doesn't bother me. Paula is my favorite. Anyways, there my opinion on the episode !

[Sitcomwriter]

I felt the same way about her turning 18 LOL

[Cashodeen]

Originally posted by YearBookLoser
He just says that "pitch problems" **** whenever he doesn't know what to say. He probably doesn't even know what it means. I think the judges are harder on Carmen just because of her age.

Lol, actually I think Randy knows his stuff pretty much. I think the girl does have pitch problems, although I wouldn't rag on her performance as a whole. It was decent and she fit well in the genre. And I actually think the judges are easier on Carmen because of her age. Most of the time I agree with Simon (brutal comments and all), but when it comes to Carmen, I disagree with Simon every time. I just don't see why he has flipped over this girl.

[Rob1]

Reuben's performance last night was just the best, as usual. I will be very suprised if he doesn't win. Kimberly Caldwell was also very good, and I thought she looked great, very sexy! The one person that I didn't expect to still be around so long was Julia. I'm just not impressed with her at all.

[harper]

they exploit people,Ridicule,them,put them down.undermine and adversities backstabbing and are just rather boring and sensationalistic.and it's worse.Simon whatever his last name is is a egomanic,self absorbed jackass,thoughtless,a gutless excuse for a human being.What credibility does he can stand on to tell people that they are untalented,unpolished performers without a prayer.Has he achieved indivial success that proves he has any talent or know what drive is.We live in a country of uncertainty and death we don't need shows that promote pain,rejection hurt,and hurting peoples feeling for a career choice isn't either admirable to be proud of especially the way Simon does it.Until simon wins a talent competition or a oscar,or emmy or grammy he really should keep his mouth shut.you know the saying those who cannot teach those who cannot do either criticize others who at least try.Big Brother,Survivor the my life as a sitcom are all shows that pretty much exploit and are made to laugh at the shortcoming of others for the almight buck.So those who sell out their own families and friends for fame and wealth shouldn't complain about loosing their privacy and sense of sanity that other performers and celebrities do when they become famous.The nation and general public who involved themselves to obtain wealth and the spotlight ought not to complain about their lost of privacy.The almighty buck wins so much for values and integrity.we as a nation thrive and devor the idea of fame and wealth at the expensive of other people privacy and feelings makes me sick.I hope this crap won't be on when my son gets old engough to watch these dreggs of humanity exploit and humiliate others for profit,Thank god for A&E and books,and music.I miss the Carol Burnett show and shows that represented family,wholesomeness,love,family,togetherness.To me that's what 70's programming on saturday night makes me long for right now!

[GrapeJelly]

I loved Carmen lastnight!! I think some of them really struggled with the genre. Country music is just not for everybody.

[Rob1]

Originally posted by harper
they exploit people,Ridicule,them,put them down.undermine and adversities backstabbing and are just rather boring and sensationalistic.and it's worse.Simon whatever his last name is is a egomanic,self absorbed jackass,thoughtless,a gutless excuse for a human being.What credibility does he can stand on to tell people that they are untalented,unpolished performers without a prayer.Has he achieved indivial success that proves he has any talent or know what drive is.We live in a country of uncertainty and death we don't need shows that promote pain,rejection hurt,and hurting peoples feeling for a career choice isn't either admirable to be proud of especially the way Simon does it.Until simon wins a talent competition or a oscar,or emmy or grammy he really should keep his mouth shut.you know the saying those who cannot teach those who cannot do either criticize others who at least try.Big Brother,Survivor the my life as a sitcom are all shows that pretty much exploit and are made to laugh at the shortcoming of others for the almight buck.So those who sell out their own families and friends for fame and wealth shouldn't complain about loosing their privacy and sense of sanity that other performers and celebrities do when they become famous.The nation and general public who involved themselves to obtain wealth and the spotlight ought not to complain about their lost of privacy.The almighty buck wins so much for values and integrity.we as a nation thrive and devor the idea of fame and wealth at the expensive of other people privacy and feelings makes me sick.I hope this crap won't be on when my son gets old engough to watch these dreggs of humanity exploit and humiliate others for profit,Thank god for A&E and books,and music.I miss the Carol Burnett show and shows that represented family,wholesomeness,love,family,togetherness.To me that's what 70's programming on saturday night makes me long for right now!

Whoa! Time out!:-) I don't know about everyone else, but I can't stand Survivor, Big Brother, or any other of the shows you are talking about. I agree with you. I don't put American Idol in the same catagory, though. This is a talent show, and all these contestents want to know if they have what it takes to make it. They KNOW that there's a possibility they might be criticized. Simon is very honest - if he thinks your'e great, then he tells you. If he thinks your'e bad, he tells you that too (although, I agree he can be a little less brutal about it, at times.) Did you ever notice that (usually) nobody ever agrees with him anyway?