American Idol - Final 10 - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

GrapeJelly · 03-25-2003, 10:10 PM

Step right up people! Place your bets! Who do you think will be the next to go?

David · 03-25-2003, 10:21 PM

I will do my weekly review, lol, and then state who I think are the bottom 3.

Joshua Gracin- I thought he was good, he had a nice energy going. A good starter uper for the show.

Trenyce- Not the best performance, i saw nothing special at all. She did okay though. She just didnt shine.

Kimberly Locke- Last week's was better, but this week's was fine. Along with Trenyce, Kimberly C, and everyone else, I kinda felt that the contestants looked tired

. It was maybe just the country atmosphere, I was kinda looking forward to disco, so I was a little upset.

Ruben Studdard- I thought he was good, he was very alive. I can tell that he's Simon's favorite. Last week, when judging Kimberly Locke, he mentioned "that's why I like Ruben, cuz he dresses his age". Today, when he was judging Julia DeMato he mentioned "See unlike Ruben, you try too hard". Or something like that.

Carmen Rasmusen- Happy Birthday! lol, i thought she was excellent. She looked very nice tonight, and I think she has a great future on the show

Kimberly Caldwell- She got some of the best comments, which is good. I really liked her, she was my favorite performance of the night. But, even with that said, I really prefer her with straighter hair, and more upbeat songs. But she took the theme, and she did an excellent excellent excellent job. She actually impressed Simon! But Simon did say "I wasnt impressed until now", but in the top 12 performances, she performed "Nowhere To Run", and Simon said something like "Best performance so far tonight.." so i dunno...

Clay Aiken- He was good. That's really all I have to say!

(thinking) who am i missing?

Cory Clark- I personally didnt like his performance. His top was horrible, and he didnt shine. I think he will be in the bottom 3.

Julia DeMato- She did WAY better, but she has some TOUGH competition, and I kinda feel sad for her. I won't be too surprised if she'll be in the bottom 3, but she did shine, and she did an excellent job.

Ricky Smith- He's funny, lol. He did okay, it was very similar to last weeks, and I'm not sure, for some reason, when compared to the others, he just doesnt stand out.

So in conclusion: My top 3 of the night
1. Kimberly Caldwell
2. Joshua Gracin
3. Carmen Rasmussen

My bottom 3 of the night
1. Cory Clark - one that's gonna go
2. Julia DeMato
3. Ricky Smith OR Trenyce

Sitcomwriter · 03-26-2003, 12:24 AM

Corey,Julia and Trenyce are going to be the bottom 3.I wasn't really impressed with anyone tonight actually.Well Ruben and Joshua were great but even Clay dissapointed me tonight.

03-25-2003, 10:10 PM	#1
GrapeJelly Member Forum 3000 Club Member Join Date: Mar 18, 2003 Posts: 3,542	American Idol - Final 10 Step right up people! Place your bets! Who do you think will be the next to go?

03-25-2003, 10:21 PM	#2
David mcphee. Forum Superstar Join Date: Jan 30, 2003 Location: jacksonville, FL. Posts: 28,115	I will do my weekly review, lol, and then state who I think are the bottom 3. Joshua Gracin- I thought he was good, he had a nice energy going. A good starter uper for the show. Trenyce- Not the best performance, i saw nothing special at all. She did okay though. She just didnt shine. Kimberly Locke- Last week's was better, but this week's was fine. Along with Trenyce, Kimberly C, and everyone else, I kinda felt that the contestants looked tired . It was maybe just the country atmosphere, I was kinda looking forward to disco, so I was a little upset. Ruben Studdard- I thought he was good, he was very alive. I can tell that he's Simon's favorite. Last week, when judging Kimberly Locke, he mentioned "that's why I like Ruben, cuz he dresses his age". Today, when he was judging Julia DeMato he mentioned "See unlike Ruben, you try too hard". Or something like that. Carmen Rasmusen- Happy Birthday! lol, i thought she was excellent. She looked very nice tonight, and I think she has a great future on the show Kimberly Caldwell- She got some of the best comments, which is good. I really liked her, she was my favorite performance of the night. But, even with that said, I really prefer her with straighter hair, and more upbeat songs. But she took the theme, and she did an excellent excellent excellent job. She actually impressed Simon! But Simon did say "I wasnt impressed until now", but in the top 12 performances, she performed "Nowhere To Run", and Simon said something like "Best performance so far tonight.." so i dunno... Clay Aiken- He was good. That's really all I have to say! (thinking) who am i missing? Cory Clark- I personally didnt like his performance. His top was horrible, and he didnt shine. I think he will be in the bottom 3. Julia DeMato- She did WAY better, but she has some TOUGH competition, and I kinda feel sad for her. I won't be too surprised if she'll be in the bottom 3, but she did shine, and she did an excellent job. Ricky Smith- He's funny, lol. He did okay, it was very similar to last weeks, and I'm not sure, for some reason, when compared to the others, he just doesnt stand out. So in conclusion: My top 3 of the night 1. Kimberly Caldwell 2. Joshua Gracin 3. Carmen Rasmussen My bottom 3 of the night 1. Cory Clark - one that's gonna go 2. Julia DeMato 3. Ricky Smith OR Trenyce
	__________________ v. 39 - katharine and chris elliott, you rock.

03-26-2003, 12:24 AM	#3
Sitcomwriter Member Forum Veteran Join Date: Feb 27, 2001 Posts: 7,356	Corey,Julia and Trenyce are going to be the bottom 3.I wasn't really impressed with anyone tonight actually.Well Ruben and Joshua were great but even Clay dissapointed me tonight.