Netflix isn't offering Seinfeld in its original 4:3 fullscreen aspect ratio - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

TMC · 10-02-2021, 01:04 AM

https://www.theverge.com/2021/10/1/2...x-streaming-hd

Seinfeld made its much-anticipated debut on Netflix early this morning with a 4K upgrade with the streamer repeating Disney+'s mistake with The Simpsons. "But while Netflix has upgraded the iconic 'show about nothing' to even crisper resolution, Netflix is hewing to the same strategy that Hulu and other HD releases of the show have used: a more modern-looking 16:9 aspect, instead of offering the original 4:3 aspect ratio in which the show originally aired," explains The Verge's Chaim Gartenberg. "The aspect ratio isn’t a new problem for Seinfeld fans, dating back to the original HD remaster that was produced in 2008 for TBS HD’s syndicated reruns, which were newly made scans of the original film (hence the ability to add back the wider frames that never made it into the initial broadcast) in widescreen to better suit modern televisions. But that 16:9 cut is the only one that’s been publicly released in HD; the best versions with the original 4:3 aspect ratio format are the DVD releases, meaning that Seinfeld fans have been forced to choose for years between visual quality and aspect ratio. When Netflix announced that it would be getting the rights to Seinfeld — and upgrading the series to 4K in the process — there was some hope that the streaming service would go back to the drawing board and create a true 4K cut, one that rescanned the film in the highest possible quality. A new 4K scan would also have offered the opportunity to restore the 4:3 aspect ratio, offering the holy grail of Seinfeld cuts: a high-definition version of the show, cropped as it was originally intended. Netflix doesn’t seem to have done that, though — something that admittedly makes some sense, given the fact that such an undertaking would cost a huge amount of money on top of the already exorbitant $500 million-plus that it spent on the rights." Still, Gartenberg says Netflix should give viewers the option of watching the original 4:3 format.

ALSO:

The widescreen Seinfeld edits out the titular pothole in the Season 8 episode "The Pothole": "What we’re left with is a version of Seinfeld that looks a bit more cramped than it originally did, with almost none of the ground visible," says Allegra Frank of Netflix showing only the widescreen version of Seinfeld. "This is honestly not a huge issue, unless you love seeing people’s shoes. (Considering how iconic Jerry’s sneakers were, however … that does kind of stink!) And there are occasional instances where characters are looking down or pointing at something on the ground that this re-cropped version of the show will not let you see anymore. Here’s an example. 'The Pothole' without the pothole? Why, I never! Still, it could absolutely be worse—the center of the image remains intact, even if it’s slightly off-center now, as there’s more image coming in from the sides. In a way, you get a little more Seinfeld … but also a little less."
Jerry Seinfeld says there's a number of Seinfeld episodes he would redo or scrap -- though he wouldn't actually do it: "There's a number of them that I would love to have a crack at, but I don't really believe, philosophically, in changing or even thinking about the past," the comedian tells People "My philosophy of life is that just happened the way it happened, and we're going to go from here. And that's the best way to ... live."
Watch a video explaining the difference between widescreen and fullscreen Seinfeld
Can Seinfeld replicate the success of The Office and Friends drawing young viewers on Netflix?
Seinfeld brushes off the Seinfeld cast doing a Friends-style reunion, saying it would "seem sad"
Here are 12 must-see Seinfeld episodes

rusty spike · 10-03-2021, 03:16 AM

It cuts out the visual sight gags, like the pothole episode.

10-02-2021, 01:04 AM	#1
TMC Member Forum Idol Join Date: Jan 09, 2001 Posts: 126,393	Netflix isn't offering Seinfeld in its original 4:3 fullscreen aspect ratio https://www.theverge.com/2021/10/1/2...x-streaming-hd Seinfeld made its much-anticipated debut on Netflix early this morning with a 4K upgrade with the streamer repeating Disney+'s mistake with The Simpsons. "But while Netflix has upgraded the iconic 'show about nothing' to even crisper resolution, Netflix is hewing to the same strategy that Hulu and other HD releases of the show have used: a more modern-looking 16:9 aspect, instead of offering the original 4:3 aspect ratio in which the show originally aired," explains The Verge's Chaim Gartenberg. "The aspect ratio isn’t a new problem for Seinfeld fans, dating back to the original HD remaster that was produced in 2008 for TBS HD’s syndicated reruns, which were newly made scans of the original film (hence the ability to add back the wider frames that never made it into the initial broadcast) in widescreen to better suit modern televisions. But that 16:9 cut is the only one that’s been publicly released in HD; the best versions with the original 4:3 aspect ratio format are the DVD releases, meaning that Seinfeld fans have been forced to choose for years between visual quality and aspect ratio. When Netflix announced that it would be getting the rights to Seinfeld — and upgrading the series to 4K in the process — there was some hope that the streaming service would go back to the drawing board and create a true 4K cut, one that rescanned the film in the highest possible quality. A new 4K scan would also have offered the opportunity to restore the 4:3 aspect ratio, offering the holy grail of Seinfeld cuts: a high-definition version of the show, cropped as it was originally intended. Netflix doesn’t seem to have done that, though — something that admittedly makes some sense, given the fact that such an undertaking would cost a huge amount of money on top of the already exorbitant $500 million-plus that it spent on the rights." Still, Gartenberg says Netflix should give viewers the option of watching the original 4:3 format. ALSO: The widescreen Seinfeld edits out the titular pothole in the Season 8 episode "The Pothole": "What we’re left with is a version of Seinfeld that looks a bit more cramped than it originally did, with almost none of the ground visible," says Allegra Frank of Netflix showing only the widescreen version of Seinfeld. "This is honestly not a huge issue, unless you love seeing people’s shoes. (Considering how iconic Jerry’s sneakers were, however … that does kind of stink!) And there are occasional instances where characters are looking down or pointing at something on the ground that this re-cropped version of the show will not let you see anymore. Here’s an example. 'The Pothole' without the pothole? Why, I never! Still, it could absolutely be worse—the center of the image remains intact, even if it’s slightly off-center now, as there’s more image coming in from the sides. In a way, you get a little more Seinfeld … but also a little less." Jerry Seinfeld says there's a number of Seinfeld episodes he would redo or scrap -- though he wouldn't actually do it: "There's a number of them that I would love to have a crack at, but I don't really believe, philosophically, in changing or even thinking about the past," the comedian tells People "My philosophy of life is that just happened the way it happened, and we're going to go from here. And that's the best way to ... live." Watch a video explaining the difference between widescreen and fullscreen Seinfeld Can Seinfeld replicate the success of The Office and Friends drawing young viewers on Netflix? Seinfeld brushes off the Seinfeld cast doing a Friends-style reunion, saying it would "seem sad" Here are 12 must-see Seinfeld episodes

10-03-2021, 03:16 AM	#2
rusty spike Member Senior Member Join Date: Mar 08, 2015 Location: Southwest Posts: 1,124	It cuts out the visual sight gags, like the pothole episode.