Martha Doe Roberts (Amazon Season 5)

[Todd Mueller]

I'm disappointed they edited the hell out of the Martha Doe Roberts case on Amazon season 5. The most intriguing part was the ransom calls by the guy with a fake Asian accent. But all of that was cut out.

This makes no sense...

[LakeForestPI]

Originally Posted by Todd Mueller

I'm disappointed they edited the hell out of the Martha Doe Roberts case on Amazon season 5. The most intriguing part was the ransom calls by the guy with a fake Asian accent. But all of that was cut out.

This makes no sense...

Fake Asian accent. Hmmmmm. Sounds exotic. And deranged.

[unsolved243]

Originally Posted by Todd Mueller

I'm disappointed they edited the hell out of the Martha Doe Roberts case on Amazon season 5. The most intriguing part was the ransom calls by the guy with a fake Asian accent. But all of that was cut out.

This makes no sense...

That was actually an update to the case; and it is on Amazon Prime actually. It's called "Memphis Kidnap Progress Report" in Season 5 Episode 19.

[biscuitgirl]

Perhaps they thought it might be considered offensive?

[Hops3098]

Originally Posted by biscuitgirl

Perhaps they thought it might be considered offensive?

I *really* hope you're wrong.

[drew4824]

Originally Posted by biscuitgirl

Perhaps they thought it might be considered offensive?

The lifetime segment I have made no mention of the accent either. Maybe the original airing only showed that?

[drew4824]

Originally Posted by Todd Mueller

I'm disappointed they edited the hell out of the Martha Doe Roberts case on Amazon season 5. The most intriguing part was the ransom calls by the guy with a fake Asian accent. But all of that was cut out.

This makes no sense...

Just realized what the other poster meant. That update on the case is in episode 19 of the same season on Amazon and you can still hear the actual phone call recording.

[justins5256]

I could be wrong, but I don't think this "progress report" with the fake Asian accent made it to Lifetime. Rather, they just showed the original Special Alert and the update about the arrest of the neighbor and the recovery of her body.

[Todd Mueller]

Originally Posted by unsolved243

That was actually an update to the case; and it is on Amazon Prime actually. It's called "Memphis Kidnap Progress Report" in Season 5 Episode 19.

Originally Posted by drew4824

Just realized what the other poster meant. That update on the case is in episode 19 of the same season on Amazon and you can still hear the actual phone call recording.

Thank you both, unsolved243 and drew4824!

Yes, that's what I meant. I really liked hearing the ransom call because it was so bizarre, and so obviously fake. It was among the strangest cases I ever remember on UM. I thought they edited that out, but I didn't realize that was part of an update.

Thanks for the info. I'll look for it later in Season 5!

[JM]

For what it's worth "The FBI Files" featured this story and the episode is on the official Film Rise account on YT.

The FBI Files: Season 5 - Ep 13 "Fatal Friendship"

I remember the case very well, as it happened right outside my hometown (Memphis, TN). Such a sad demise, no one deserves that.

[Todd Mueller]

Originally Posted by soundandvision

For what it's worth "The FBI Files" featured this story and the episode is on the official Film Rise account on YT.

The FBI Files: Season 5 - Ep 13 "Fatal Friendship"

I remember the case very well, as it happened right outside my hometown (Memphis, TN). Such a sad demise, no one deserves that.

I'll have to check this out. Thanks!

[Hops3098]

I'm not trying to steer this thread OT, but I think this is the first Special Alert segment to make it to Amazon. I was afraid we would lose them all.

[LooksLikeCRicci]

I think it's a totally appropriate comment. (Like I'm not guilty of running the ship off-course from time to time...)

It's great to know we haven't lost the Special Alerts. Even though they scared the crap out of me.