Amy Mihaljevic's killer also murdered Jonbenet

[neognosis]

over at Topix there's a thread

"Amy Mihaljevic and Jonbenet Ramsey were both killed by the same killer"

I click on it and it takes me to this thread which lays out the theory

http://jbrwdi.forumotion.com/t557-am...bjections#7351

[LooksLikeCRicci]

Sigh.

[DanCart]

Its funny you bring up Amy Mihaljevic because one thing that has always stuck with me is that the kidnappers MO has never been seen anywhere in the US.

I wouldnt advise swallowing redpill`s theories wholeheartedly because there are lots of things that dont add up , Amy`s killer was confident enough to try and lure young girls out into public places while JonBenet`s killer had to use stealth and force to get her ....

There is the difference in geography , there was some kind of DNA evidence found on Amy IIRC and nothing has matched any offender or crime scene anywere in the US , so its highly unlikely its the same man

One thing I found interesting while watching the video in the link about Amy is what the detective said he was told by the FBI- which I mentioned when we talked about Eloise`s abduction ........when girls that age are kidnapped they are usually raped & killed within hours .....

The Amy killer was clearly about kidnap ,rape and murder (and left no communication to Amy`s family) while JonBenet`s killer wanted to extract some kind of ransom in addition to the communication attempt via the ransom note - these are clearly the hallmarks of two different offenders , they are similar in that they are sexual predators after the same general age range of females but many things differ and the DNA kills any likelhood of a connection , beware of redpill`s theories

[88keys]

Originally Posted by neognosis

over at Topix there's a thread

"Amy Mihaljevic and Jonbenet Ramsey were both killed by the same killer"

I click on it and it takes me to this thread which lays out the theory

http://jbrwdi.forumotion.com/t557-am...bjections#7351

If you want to post or talk about a theory to a case, then do it. Make an actual post using your own brain and your own words. Don't just link to someone else's post on a completely different board. I mean, seriously, what is the point?

[wiseguy182]

I predict that in the following weeks, neognosis (assuming he still has posting privileges) will grace us with the following threads:

-Rob Schaffer killed JonBenet
-Dorothy Wacker killed JonBenet
-Bill Wacker raised from the dead and killed JonBenet
-Mothman killed JonBenet
-Ogopogo killed JonBenet
-Lee Harvey Oswald time traveled from 1962 and killed JonBenet
-Phillilp Garrido created a teleporter and killed JonBenet
-JonBenet killed JonBenet

well shoot, I may have just given him some ideas.

[Awsi Dooger]

That doesn't fit the evidence. JonBenet was killed by a small foreign faction, although it certainly could have grown by now.

[James T]

I thought her death was supernatural?

[neognosis]

Originally Posted by DanCart

Its funny you bring up Amy Mihaljevic because one thing that has always stuck with me is that the kidnappers MO has never been seen anywhere in the US.

I wouldnt advise swallowing redpill`s theories wholeheartedly because there are lots of things that dont add up , Amy`s killer was confident enough to try and lure young girls out into public places while JonBenet`s killer had to use stealth and force to get her ....

There is the difference in geography , there was some kind of DNA evidence found on Amy IIRC and nothing has matched any offender or crime scene anywere in the US , so its highly unlikely its the same man

One thing I found interesting while watching the video in the link about Amy is what the detective said he was told by the FBI- which I mentioned when we talked about Eloise`s abduction ........when girls that age are kidnapped they are usually raped & killed within hours .....

The Amy killer was clearly about kidnap ,rape and murder (and left no communication to Amy`s family) while JonBenet`s killer wanted to extract some kind of ransom in addition to the communication attempt via the ransom note - these are clearly the hallmarks of two different offenders , they are similar in that they are sexual predators after the same general age range of females but many things differ and the DNA kills any likelhood of a connection , beware of redpill`s theories

what struck me about his theory is that it explains why Jonbenet said she's having a secret visit from Santa.

you know of amy? ru from ohio?

[neognosis]

Originally Posted by 88keys

If you want to post or talk about a theory to a case, then do it. Make an actual post using your own brain and your own words. Don't just link to someone else's post on a completely different board. I mean, seriously, what is the point?

well i did say jonbenet and other children who vanished in their homes were taken by the boogeyman

[neognosis]

Originally Posted by wiseguy182

I predict that in the following weeks, neognosis (assuming he still has posting privileges) will grace us with the following threads:

-Rob Schaffer killed JonBenet
-Dorothy Wacker killed JonBenet
-Bill Wacker raised from the dead and killed JonBenet
-Mothman killed JonBenet
-Ogopogo killed JonBenet
-Lee Harvey Oswald time traveled from 1962 and killed JonBenet
-Phillilp Garrido created a teleporter and killed JonBenet
-JonBenet killed JonBenet

well shoot, I may have just given him some ideas.

what do u think of crop circles and UFO? UM had an episode on that.

[neognosis]

Originally Posted by Awsi Dooger

That doesn't fit the evidence. JonBenet was killed by a small foreign faction, although it certainly could have grown by now.

from another dimension

[neognosis]

Originally Posted by James T

I thought her death was supernatural?

depends on whether santa is a real person or an imaginary friend. if u watch ghost stories on tv, children say they have an imaginary friend that turns out to be a ghost. ive provided links.

i do think some crop circles are done by ufos and some people missing in woods were abducted by bigfoot so...

[DanCart]

Originally Posted by neognosis

what struck me about his theory is that it explains why Jonbenet said she's having a secret visit from Santa.

you know of amy? ru from ohio?

The offender in the Amy Mihaljevic case was all about sweet talking young girls into meeting him outside their homes and taking them away voluntarilly while the offender in the JonBenet case was into burglarizing the residence to get the young girl and taking her by force ......these are two clearly distinct approaches which suggest different offenders ......and in both cases they have DNA profiles which have never matched .......

[neognosis]

Originally Posted by DanCart

The offender in the Amy Mihaljevic case was all about sweet talking young girls into meeting him outside their homes and taking them away voluntarilly while the offender in the JonBenet case was into burglarizing the residence to get the young girl and taking her by force ......these are two clearly distinct approaches which suggest different offenders ......and in both cases they have DNA profiles which have never matched .......

did u read his thread?

how do you explain this ?

Secret Santa Visit

Carnes Account. "On December 25, 1996, while playing at the home of a neighborhood friend, JonBenet told her friend's mother that "Santa Claus" was going to pay her a "special" visit after Christmas and that it was a secret. (SMF P 124; PSMF P 124.) The person who may have said this to JonBenet has never been identified. (SMF P 125; PSMF P 125.)" (Carnes 2003:101).
PMPT Account. "Barbara Kostanick was the mother of a playmate of JBR's. She asserted: "The day before Christmas, JonBenet was at our house playing with Megan. The kids were talking about Santa, getting all excited. I asked JonBenet if she had visited Santa Claus yet. She said, “Oh, Santa was at our Christmas party the other night.” Megan had seen Santa at the Pearl Street Mall, so we talked about that. Then JonBenet said, “Santa Claus promised that he would make a secret visit after Christmas.” I thought she was confused. “Christmas is tonight,” I told her. “And Santa will be coming tonight.” “No, no” JonBenet insisted. “He said this would be after Christmas. And it’s a secret” (Schiller 1999:38-39)

that guy has a thread on DNA as well. apparently the dna of amy is mitochondrial, dna in jonbenet is nuclear.

[DanCart]

Originally Posted by neognosis

did u read his thread?

how do you explain this ?

Secret Santa Visit

Carnes Account. "On December 25, 1996, while playing at the home of a neighborhood friend, JonBenet told her friend's mother that "Santa Claus" was going to pay her a "special" visit after Christmas and that it was a secret. (SMF P 124; PSMF P 124.) The person who may have said this to JonBenet has never been identified. (SMF P 125; PSMF P 125.)" (Carnes 2003:101).
PMPT Account. "Barbara Kostanick was the mother of a playmate of JBR's. She asserted: "The day before Christmas, JonBenet was at our house playing with Megan. The kids were talking about Santa, getting all excited. I asked JonBenet if she had visited Santa Claus yet. She said, “Oh, Santa was at our Christmas party the other night.” Megan had seen Santa at the Pearl Street Mall, so we talked about that. Then JonBenet said, “Santa Claus promised that he would make a secret visit after Christmas.” I thought she was confused. “Christmas is tonight,” I told her. “And Santa will be coming tonight.” “No, no” JonBenet insisted. “He said this would be after Christmas. And it’s a secret” (Schiller 1999:38-39)

that guy has a thread on DNA as well. apparently the dna of amy is mitochondrial, dna in jonbenet is nuclear.

That is correct about the type of DNA from Amy and JonBenet

The santa claus thing is open to various interpretations , do you have further details about how JonBenet was told this by this mysterious santa ?