Who do you like talking about cases with or hearing from on cases on UM forum?

[melskie007]

I was wondering who do you all like talking about cases with on here or hearing from on cases because of thier mind set? I know sometimes we debate against each other on here, so who to you would also be a good debater on unsolved mysteries cases?

I personally so far like how the following people think:

Cocytus- good points of view many times.
Crystaldawn-intellgent approach to so many topics and wow updates are tremendous!
Tracylynns- When I wake up in the morning and have my coffee, I see you always have fresh posts on here. I read them. I think wow, your thought process on some of these and the info you bring to the UM forum, great!

I know I'm new here so this is really more for just seeing how you all view each other and what you all think about others posts and feedback.

[TracyLynnS]

Thank you, Melskie, that's so sweet.

Among others, I like reading posts from Mastermind, Mozart, and a guy who recently left the group (again lol).
They often have interesting points of view, sometimes different from mine, and make solid arguments for their
subject. Their info has encouraged me to study a case or a subject in more detail, outside of the forums here.
Their posts have educated me and in some cases, caused me to change my opinion on certain UM cases and
even some other topics.

[melskie007]

Originally Posted by TracyLynnS

Thank you, Melskie, that's so sweet.

Among others, I like reading posts from Mastermind, Mozart, and a guy who recently left the group (again lol).
They often have interesting points of view, sometimes different from mine, and make solid arguments for their
subject. Their info has encouraged me to study a case or a subject in more detail, outside of the forums here.
Their posts have educated me and in some cases, caused me to change my opinion on certain UM cases and
even some other topics.

yes, I didn't think of Mastermind but he offers very interesting details about cases. I like his theories, they always seem to make sense to what I'm thinking. I too also like to study cases off the UM forum, I'm currently attending school for law and always have interest in these unsolved cases. I come up with the best plausible theory I gather from the info given but I can be totally off and it really could be towards a different direction. I love reading others views on each case and what details they have to add. And i always encourage solid arguments for the subject matter as long as it sticks close to what is being discussed and you have ample examples or relevent fact or other cases to compare to.

[Hambone2421]

I appreciate and like everyone's opinions on here. However, Mastermind and Smokescreen are my two favorite posters to discuss cases with. Mastermind, Smoke and I have gone back and forth on the Eric Tamiyasu case and could probably continually discuss it until we pass out, lol.

[Smokescreen]

Originally posted by Hambone2421 Mastermind and Smokescreen are my two favorite posters to discuss cases with.

Hey thanks brother!

I appreciate and like everyone's opinions on here.

I agree! It's really interesting to read different perspectives and see how others think. There's times I'll read a post a gain a new insight, which is really cool. And sure, there are some opinions I can't/ won't agree with but I nonetheless appreciate the input.


But who are my favorite posters, you ask? Why, there the ones I'm friends with on FB (And y'all know who you are!)

[nohwheregirl]

Can we talk about who we DON'T like to hear from? I think that thread would be much more fun.

Maybe we should have a UM message board Homecoming court. I nominate Crystaldawn for Homecoming Queen and Robert Stack (posthumously) for Homecoming King.

Seriously, tho, my peeps know who they are. Holla! Do we need another Mastermind-stroking thread/popularity contest?

[Oooga Chucka]

Mastermind was definitely smart and insightful, but I think that Mozart and Meg are my favorites. Just smart and funny people.

[wiseguy182]

I have been posting on here for almost 5 years, and I can honestly say this is the most absurd thread I have ever seen, hands down. The only thing this thread accomplishes is to give the notion that some people's input is more valuable than others, and that is simply not the case. I sinecerely hope this entire thread gets deleted. And the suggestion of a thread regarding "who we don't like to hear from" is even more absurd, although I am entirely not surprised the person who mentioned it would suggest such a thing.

[nohwheregirl]

Originally Posted by wiseguy182

I have been posting on here for almost 5 years, and I can honestly say this is the most absurd thread I have ever seen, hands down. The only thing this thread accomplishes is to give the notion that some people's input is more valuable than others, and that is simply not the case. I sinecerely hope this entire thread gets deleted. And the suggestion of a thread regarding "who we don't like to hear from" is even more absurd, although I am entirely not surprised the person who mentioned it would suggest such a thing.

Actually, I 100% agree with you. I like to think that this message board is a pretty democratic place. I really like most of you guys, but I don't think we need to have a popularity contest.

I know the suggestion to list who we don't like was absurd, which is why I made it. Jokes!

Merry Christmas, wiseguy!

[TheCars1986]

I like wiseguy.

[Apostapler]

I like [insert random name of person to stroke ego] and their posts.

However [insert annoying person with crappy opinions] really bugs me.

[melskie007]

I also mentioned good debater? This isnt a contest of who's who...and quite honestly if you write on any forum back and forth, you notice this already... I agree with the opinions that i feel are very close if not right on the case as also i disagree with opinions i feel are way off..wether i liked the above peoples views, i may or may not agree with them depending on the case.

I don't really feel this places emphasis on anyone as you may argue with the same person tomorrow on different views. It's just interesting on who you feel is someone you feel has much information to add or you feel you like arguing opinions with? Some of the above i mentioned as they always seem to have the info they pull and some event provide links to sources, which is helpful with any case.

[wiseguy182]

Starting a thread about who you think are the "best" posters on here is incredibly tacky, and reeks of clique-ish friend rewarding. And this all comes after reading enough pro-Dislimb (banned member) and pro-Awsi Dooger comments to last me 10 lifetimes. I'm sure most of us like some members posts more than others, but these things are best kept to one's self. Talking about your favorite posters will only seek to alienate yourself from everyone else, probably not something you want to do.

As far as thoughts on cases go, we are all just speculating here. I don't believe my thoughts are better than anyone elses because it is all purely speculation. Heck, for all I know, Tim McClure could be completely innocent and I would have to eat a large order of crow. Well, it is possible.

And I say all this not because I feel my name should have been included. Heck, I wouldn't even count myself in the top 5 here. But I was very disappointed that there was very little to no respect for the long time posters (some of whom have been here since day one)/those with an almost encylcopediac knowledge of cases and updates/those who have went to enormous lengths to provide for this community (whether it be articles, or whatever). I'm talking about people like crystaldawn, justins5256, Kane, dynoguy88 and DarkDante. I think you guys should have mentioned those people, and not people like some recently retired (again) poster who's sole mission on here was to fling crap at everyone and defend criminals

[melskie007]

Originally Posted by wiseguy182

Starting a thread about who you think are the "best" posters on here is incredibly tacky, and reeks of clique-ish friend rewarding. And this all comes after reading enough pro-Dislimb (banned member) and pro-Awsi Dooger comments to last me 10 lifetimes. I'm sure most of us like some members posts more than others, but these things are best kept to one's self. Talking about your favorite posters will only seek to alienate yourself from everyone else, probably not something you want to do.

As far as thoughts on cases go, we are all just speculating here. I don't believe my thoughts are better than anyone elses because it is all purely speculation. Heck, for all I know, Tim McClure could be completely innocent and I would have to eat a large order of crow. Well, it is possible.

And I say all this not because I feel my name should have been included. Heck, I wouldn't even count myself in the top 5 here. But I was very disappointed that there was very little to no respect for the long time posters (some of whom have been here since day one)/those with an almost encylcopediac knowledge of cases and updates/those who have went to enormous lengths to provide for this community (whether it be articles, or whatever). I'm talking about people like crystaldawn, justins5256, Kane, dynoguy88 and DarkDante. I think you guys should have mentioned those people, and not people like some recently retired (again) poster who's sole mission on here was to fling crap at everyone and defend criminals

I did mention crystaldawn. And there is nothing synical of what im posting. We are all adults here and love talking about mystery. Your input is appreciated here as well, no-one is above anyone on here, we are all different thinkers in the end and it is fun to come on here and talk about varias subjects. I don't believe any one person is being singled out on this thread, everyone is welcomed. But i see your upset by this because you feel you should have been included on a top list of some sort? I mentioned a few here but this is an open thread so several can be listed. I will say this- I do like your passion for things you believe in, your not afraid to state your opinion and that is a valuable gift to have, great asset to bring aboard most deffinately!

[burbqueen]

thank you melskie. I dont mind this thread and if some are offended then don't post, but I didnt think it was a popularity contest just who has contributed opinions and views that you really appreciate or in my case encourgaged me to jump on in! I also appreaciate Darkdante and tracylynn.

This board, unlike some of the others I frequent, really have some old timers on here! LOL!