Something else that didn't make sense - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

JL82 · 03-06-2010, 05:04 PM

"Yokel Hero" - Rose is nominated for St. Olaf Woman of the Year
"Girls Just Wanna..." - Rose is celibate for a while, per St. Olaf's request that all citizens be so to help them out.

What doesn't make sense: SHE HASN'T LIVED IN ST. OLAF FOR FOUR YEARS IN THE FIRST CASE, SIX IN THE SECOND. Well more, actually, because they've actually lived together a little while already when the Pilot of the show opens.

There's a lot of comment about how strange St. Olaf is, but everyone takes that for granted.

It's as if the St. Olaf natives are an ethnic race, not just a geographic community. And on that note, we meet many relatives of Rose's - Lilly, Holly, her biological father - who aren't very St. Olaf-ian, the way she is.

JR1 · 03-12-2010, 09:46 PM

The show had a number of inconsistencies, but when it was that great a show, they can be overlooked (just like with "I Love Lucy").

03-06-2010, 05:04 PM	#1
JL82 Member Frequent Poster Join Date: Aug 14, 2009 Location: Toledo, Ohio Posts: 189	Something else that didn't make sense "Yokel Hero" - Rose is nominated for St. Olaf Woman of the Year "Girls Just Wanna..." - Rose is celibate for a while, per St. Olaf's request that all citizens be so to help them out. What doesn't make sense: SHE HASN'T LIVED IN ST. OLAF FOR FOUR YEARS IN THE FIRST CASE, SIX IN THE SECOND. Well more, actually, because they've actually lived together a little while already when the Pilot of the show opens. There's a lot of comment about how strange St. Olaf is, but everyone takes that for granted. It's as if the St. Olaf natives are an ethnic race, not just a geographic community. And on that note, we meet many relatives of Rose's - Lilly, Holly, her biological father - who aren't very St. Olaf-ian, the way she is.

03-12-2010, 09:46 PM	#2
JR1 Member Forum Regular Join Date: Mar 07, 2009 Location: USA Posts: 742	The show had a number of inconsistencies, but when it was that great a show, they can be overlooked (just like with "I Love Lucy").