THR: List of Endangered Shows

[JamesG]

Bubble wrap! Endangered shows status report
February 11, 2010


This could be Jack Bauer’s final day.

Fox’s “24” is on The Hollywood Reporter’s list of endangered shows this year, along with fan faves “Heroes,” “Chuck,” “Smallville” and “FlashForward.”



With networks issuing pilot orders for next season, executives are looking at their current lineups and estimating how many time slots they’ll have to fill. Their decisions rest on a few factors, including how these “bubble shows” perform over the next few months.

THR spoke to broadcast net insiders to compile a list of TV’s most prominent shows on shaky ground — and calculated the odds they’ll stick around.



“Heroes” — The expensive NBC series has always performed well overseas, but the network needs “Heroes” to pull decent numbers in its own backyard too.

This season, “Heroes” continued its decline and is now at a level — around a 2.0 adults 18-49 rating — that would warrant cancellation under most circumstances.

The deciding factor here is NBC’s internal balance sheet for the production. Don’t be surprised if NBC announces a 12-hour “final chapter” for next fall. 60%





“FlashForward” & “V” — ABC’s attempted “Lost” replacements started strong in the ratings, dropped fast, changed showrunners (twice for “FlashForward”) and are now on a protracted winter hiatus.

Expect ABC to keep one of these, and the “V” storyline seems more readily extendable to a second season.

“FlashForward” 40%
“V” 60%





“Mercy” — Aptly titled. This hospital drama has been on life support since its debut, averaging a 1.9 in the ratings.

That “Mercy” is still on the air is mainly due to NBC having a chaotic season. 25%





“24” — Fox’s action-drama continues to perform well, with its eighth season generating numbers in the low-to-mid 3s. Yet “24” is pricey to produce and has little syndication value.

Producer Twentieth is exploring the option of spinning off “24” into a theatrical movie, signaling that this might be the Bauer’s final, real-time day-long adventure.

Another long-shot option would be shopping “24” to another network. 40%





“Friday Night Lights” — The small town drama was already renewed for another season as part of a two-year pickup.

But with actors free to pursue other deals, the chances of an extension beyond that are slim. 5%





“Life Unexpected” & “Melrose Place” — Is it too soon to spinoff “Vampire Diaries”? “The Werewolf Journals,” perhaps?

“Unexpected” struck a chord with critics, but hasn’t managed to entice a sizable number of CW viewers.

“Melrose Place” hasn’t struck a chord with critics or viewers.

“Unexpected” 55%
“Melrose” 5%





“Community” — Ratings for the NBC comedy may not be hot, averaging a 2.6 with DVR added. But it has been a solid performer on Thursdays and NBC likes the show.

With “Parks & Recreation” having received an early pickup with lower numbers, expect another semester. 90%





“Trauma” — It’s dead! It’s alive! NBC should rename this medical drama “The Twilight Zone.”

“Trauma” will get another turn at bat next month, with a stronger lead-in this time from “Chuck.” But if this show can’t grow, there’s little chance of another reprieve. 15%





“Numb3rs” & “Medium” — It’s the Case of the Missing Friday Night Viewers. CBS’ crime-drama lineup on Fridays might continue to top the ratings, but the night has weakened to the point where veteran scripted dramas are getting tougher to justify.

Of the two, “Medium” pulls the higher number;, plus “Numb3rs” got its episode order reduced and star David Krumholtz is cast in another pilot.

“Medium” 65%
“Numb3rs” 20%





“Accidentally on Purpose” — CBS excels at creating new comedies for its Monday night sitcom block with ratings that are perfectly fine for just about any time slot except the one they’re in.

“Purpose” has been a drag on the Eye’s powerhouse comedy lineup, though the network wants to see how it performs on its second-string Wednesday night bench next month before making a decision. 50%.





“The Deep End” — It’s “Grey's Anatomy” with lawyers." Ah, if only programming a network were that easy. 5%





“New Adventures of Old Christine” and “Gary Unmarried” — CBS’ other comedy block.

With ABC’s new comedies stealing the spotlight on Wednesday night, the Eye might not remain content with low 2s at 8 p.m. More than any other entry, these are too early to guess.





“Smallville” & “Supernatural” — The nine-year-old “Smallville” contains an alarming lack of texting debutantes so naturally the CW dumped it on Fridays. Like Krypton crystal thrown into the snow, it bloomed in the wasteland and gave The CW a reliable performer on TV’s toughest night.

“Supernatural” made a solid companion for “Vampire Diaries.”

Both: 85%





“Cold Case” — Cold, sure, but not dead. CBS’ stalwart didn’t much impress on Sundays in the fall but it was also paired with an even colder case — “Three Rivers.” 50%





“Human Target” — Fox’s male-targeted action drama stumbled out of the gate and its ratings were falling precariously until this week.

Remember, this is the network that gave a second chance to “Dollhouse,” so if the Mark Valley series can stabilize there’s a fair chance Fox will give “Target” another shot (especially if “24” doesn’t return). 55%





“Fringe” — Boy, this show took a beating on Thursdays this fall, yet along with “Bones” has given Fox a foothold on TV’s most competitive night and recently shown improvement. 90%





“The Forgotten” — ABC hopes “The Forgotten,” like fellow detective drama “Castle,” will gradually improve its 10 p.m. time period.

So far, the Christian Slater drama isn’t showing enough of a pulse. 35%





“Better Off Ted” and “Scrubs” — Last year, ABC gave second chances to these two comedies.

Both flopped in the fall, while the network’s new Wednesday comedy lineup proved half-hours can indeed succeed on ABC — just not these two. 5%





“Chuck” — No bubble show list is ever complete without “Chuck.” Except this time, fans might not have to gobble Subway sandwiches to get the show a renewal.

“Chuck” has recently been NBC’s highest-rated show on Monday nights. 75%

http://www.thrfeed.com/2010/02/endan...-v-fringe.html

[Chocoholic]

I love Scrubs, but IMHO it should have ended two years ago. Friday Night Lights is a good show, although I've only watched a couple of episodes. As for the other shows on that list, I could care less.