Rank the Top 12...again.

[EmoJoe]

now that we're down to 3, i thought itd be cool to compare our rankings from the beginning of the finals, when there were SO MANY PEOPLE, to our rankings towards the end of the season.

Original Rankings:

1. David Archuleta
2. Brooke White
3. Ramiele Malubay
4. David Cook
5. Carly Smithson
6. Michael Johns
7. Jason Castro
8. Syesha Mercado
9. David Hernandez
10. Kristy Lee Cook
11. Amanda Overmyer
12. Chikezie Eze

Rankings now:

1. David Archuleta
2. Kristy Lee Cook (YOU READ THAT RIGHT. Kristy rules.)
3. Carly Smithson
4. Brooke White
5. Michael Johns
6. Syesha Mercado
7. David Cook
8. Chikezie Eze
9. Jason Castro
10. Ramiele Malubay
11. David Hernandez
12. Amanda Overmyer

wow, mine really changed

Went up
Kristy Lee Cook, Carly Smithson, Michael Johns, Syesha Mercado, Chikezie Eze

Went down
Brooke White, Ramiele Malubay, David Cook, Jason Castro, David Hernandez, Amanda Overmyer

Stayed the same
David Archuleta

[Krisalicious]

BEFORE:
1. David Arch
2. Michael
3. Ramiele
4. Carly
5. Brooke
6. Jason
7. David C.
8. Syesha
9. Amanda
10. David H.
11. Kristy
12. Chikezie

NOW:
1. David A.
2. Carly
3. Syesha
4. Michael
5. David C.
6. Jason
7. Ramiele
8. Chikezie
9. Brooke
10. Kristy
11. David H.
12. Amanda

I take it back. My rankings have changed DRASTICALLY.

[Karen*]

NOW
1. David Cook
2. David Archuleta
3. Michael Johns
4. Carly Smithson
5. Syesha Mercado
6. Ramiele Malubay
7. David Hernandez
8. Jason Castro
9. Chikezie
10. Amanda Overmyer
11. Brooke White
12. Kristy Lee Cook

BEFORE
1. Michael Johns
2. David Cook
3. Ramiele Malubay
4. Carly Smithson
5. David Archuleta
6. Jason Castro
7. David Hernandez
8. Chikezie
9. Syesha Mercado
10. Brooke White
11. Amanda Overmyer
12. Kristy Lee Cook

Who went up for me:
David Cook, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, Amanda Overmyer

Went down:
Michael Johns, Ramiele Malubay, Chikezie, Jason Castro, Brooke White

Stayed the same:
Carly Smithson (Though the spot for my favorite girl throughout the season often fluctuated between her and Rami), David Hernandez, Kristy Lee Cook

[Buffyboy323]

BEFORE
1. David Archuleta
2. Brooke White
3. Jason Castro
4. Ramiele Malubay
5. Carly Smithson
6. Michael Johns
7. Syesha Mercado
8. Kristy Lee Cook
9. Amanda Overmyer
10. David Hernandez
11. David Cook
12. Chikezie

NOW
1. Brooke White
2. David Archuleta
3. Syesha Mercado
4. Carly Smithson
5. Michael Johns
6. Kristy Lee Cook
7. David Cook
8. Jason Castro
9. Ramiele Malubay
10. Amanda Overmyer
11. Chikezie
12. David Hernandez

[*InThisMoment*]

Lynn has taken alot of time to think about the rankings of the contestants, now that the season is nearly over. Not only based on voice, but based on the overall quality of the human being.

ORIGINAL top 12 rankings:
1. David Archuleta
2. Jason Castro
3. David Hernandez
4. Michael Johns
5. Chikeze
6. David Cook
7. Brooke White
8. Amanda Overmyer
9. Syesha Mercado
10. Kristy Lee Cook
11. Ramiele Malubay
12. Carly Smithson

Now:

1. David Archuleta (Um, who else? LOL)
2. Kristy - Because she was the only person I really cared about being safe each week. She was fun, and robbed.
3. Phat Kracka - I DON'T CARE FOR HIS SINGING, BUT I LIKE HIM AS A PERSON. DON'T ASK WHY HE'S ABOVE SYESHA IN THIS THREAD AND NOT IN ''RANK THE TOP 3'' BECAUSE QUITE FRANKLY I HAVE NO IDEA. I GUESS THIS ONE ISN'T SO MUCH ABOUT THE VOICE BUT THE OVERALL CARE FOR THE PERSON. SO YEAH, I JUST LIKE HIM AS A PERSON, AND I LIKE TYPING IN CAPS WHEN TALKING ABOUT HIM. JOE KNOWS WHY.
4. Syesha - I love her voice, but that's it.
5. Carly - Again, I don't care for her voice but she seems like a sweet person so here she is.
6. Michael - He never wowed me, but again, likeable person and he really COULD sing when he picked good songs, just not my thing.
7. Chikezie - Good voice, for some reason I just enjoyed him.
8. Jason - Oh, Jason, what happened? In my original rankings, your name was 2nd on my list and in BOLD, along with Davey. My sexy luv..
9. Ramiele - Umm, not sure why I'm putting her here. I kinda liked some of her performances, actually, so that's why.
10. David Hernandez - UNDERRATED, but he picked a bad song and was eliminated. But he could SANG. Still, dropped so signficantly cause he had so few performances.
11. Brooke - LAWD HAMMERCY your run was anti-climatic. *falls asleep thinking about Brooke, then wakes up to finish this post*
12. Amanda - Ummmmmmmm you were just kinda there, looking back..

[Karen*]

LOL, I have no idea why, but Phat Kracka sounds so endearing to me.

[*InThisMoment*]

Originally Posted by Karen*

LOL, I have no idea why, but Phat Kracka sounds so endearing to me.

He may be a fat cracker to some, but he's PHAT KRACKA to us.

[howierules86]

My original rankings:

1. David Archuleta
2. Kristy Lee Cook
3. Michael Johns
4. Ramiele Malubay
5. Amanda Overmyer
6. Carly Smithson
7. Syesha Mercado
8. Jason Castro
9. David Cook
10. Brooke White
11. Chikezie
12. David Hernandez

My rankings now:

1. David Archuleta
2. Kristy Lee Cook
3. Carly Smithson
4. Michael Johns
5. Ramiele Malubay
6. Amanda Overmyer
7. David Cook
8. Syesha Mercado
9. Brooke White
10. Jason Castro
11. Chikezie
12. David Hernandez

Up 3 spots: Carly Smithson

Up 2 spots: David Cook

Up 1 spot: Brooke White

Down 1 spot: Michael Johns, Ramiele Malubay, Amanda Overmyer, Syesha Mercado

Down 2 spots: Jason Castro

Who stayed the same: David Archuleta, Kristy Lee Cook, Chikezie, David Hernandez

[David]

I'm glad to see Carly rising up on most everyone's rankings.

My original rankings:
1. Archuleta
2. Carly
3. Michael J.
4. Brooke
5. David C.
6. Jason
7. Kristy Lee
8. David H.
9. Chikeze
10. Ramiele
11. Syesha
12. Amanda

NOW :-D
1. Carly
1. David A.
3. David C.
4. Kristy Lee
5. Michael Johns
6. Brooke
7. Jason
8. Syesha
9. Ramiele
10. David H.
11. Chikeze
12. Amanda

[EmoJoe]

im bumping this since the season is over now. and im gonna do an IN-DEPTH RANKING!@ of everyone. i doubt anyone will read it cause its gonna be long as hayle but its fun to write anyway.

1. David Archuleta - OBVIOUSLY. i think he definitely had the best voice this season, and is one of the most talented male contestants ever. plus he is a hilarious, awesome person, and has a great personality. and everyone tells me i look and act like him lol. but yes. David Archuleta is awesome, and also better then you, and your crappy Season 7 favorite. he should've won. but i'm okay with him not winning, to be honest. he'll get more creative control, and i think he'll do fine. i hope he does too. i wish him the BEST. he's an awesome, hugely talented person and deserves success. if i were to make a list of the top 20 performances of the season, like...half of them would be from him. lol. and IMO, "Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me" = BEST.PERFORMANCE.OF.THE.SEASON. so yes. DAVID RULES. the only contestant who REALLY mattered this season in my eyes.

2. Kristy Lee Cook - during the semi-finals and early finals, i hated Kristy as much as everyone else did. admittedly, aside from "Faithfully", she was pretty bad in the semis, and "Eight Days a Week" also sucked. but after the mess that was "Eight Days a Week", Kristy started to improve greatly, and i started to like her a LOT more. it got to the point where she was my "secret second favorite" and aside from David, she was the only one who i actually cared about making it to the next week. "God Bless the USA" and "Anyway" definitely rank as two of the best performances of the season for me, and overall, Kristy is just awesome, no matter what your biased little mind may think.

3. Carly Smithson - i thought Carly was really overrated at first, back when they were calling her the next Kelly Clarkson and crap in the beginning of the season. her first two performances were just okay, but after "I Drove All Night" i started to think she was pretty good. then with "Come Together", IMO her best performance, i started to really like her, and that continued until she was eliminated. she has an awesome voice, and has a really nice, caring personality. she had a couple of bad performances ("Total Eclipse of the Heart", "The Show Must Go On") but overall i think she was really consistent and i think the judges underrated most of her performances. she was also robbed, and deserved to make top 4 at least. so yeah...i like Carly.

4. Brooke White - Brooke is mostly this high for 2 reasons - 1) i think her first four performances were excellent. "Love is a Battlefield" and "Let it Be" are in my top 20 performances of the season. and 2) i really like her personality, she seems like a sweet, caring person. having said that, after "Let it Be", she went on a downhill slide that she never really recovered from. she gave a few good/okay performances after that, like "You've Got a Friend" and "I Am, I Said", but nothing that matched her earlier performances. in fact, i would go as far as saying she lasted about a week too long, and if this was a totally unbiased list, she'd be 2 or 3 spots lower. but i can't help but really like Brooke for her personality and for the performances she gave early in the season, so she's fourth for me.

5. Syesha Mercado - Syesha definitely gets the award for biggest jump on my list, lol. i was indifferent on her in the semis, and didn't care for her at all during the finals until top 6 week, when she sang "One Rock and Roll Too Many". after weeks of bland performances that were vocally good but lacking in everything else, Syesha picked up her game that week and showed she COULD give an exciting performance. Syesha's upswing didn't end there - the next week (Neil Diamond week) she gave two great performances, and being unbiased, was probably the best that night overall. top 4 week, she gave two great performances yet again, one of which was IMO her best of the season - "A Change Is Gonna Come". so Syesha really grew on me - towards the end of her run, she really picked her game and became a contender, and i have to say, after it all, i like Syesha.

6. Michael Johns - Michael started off the season well, but he randomly started sucking at the end of the semis and during the beginning of the finals. he was originally in my top 4, but after those performances he fell to like...7th or 8th. lol. but then, top 10 week, he made the comeback of the season with "We Are the Champions", one of the best performances this season IMO, and was good again Dolly Parton week. unfortunately the next week, he went first, was just alright, and was wrongly eliminated. he'd probably be higher then 6th if he had lasted longer, but...he didn't. so sixth it is.

7. David Cook - to be honest i don't really care for his singing/performances at all. there were a few performances of his i liked, like "Billie Jean" and "Music of the Night", but for the most part i thought he was really overrated and his voice always sounds off-key to me lol. but the reason he's not lower then this is because of his personality...his interviews are always entertaining and he just seems like a nice, cool, down-to-earth guy. i think he's disgustingly overrated, but i think his personality is awesome, so here he is, at #7.

8. Jason Castro - i was kinda "meh" on Jason the entire season...and i still am. he had a few performances i really liked (like "Hallelujah" and "Travelin' Through") but for the most part, his performances all sounded the same for me, and he's just not really my "thing". i think he lasted 2-3 weeks too long, too. so...i don't really care for him that much, to be honest. i don't HATE him, but i don't like him either.

9. Chikezie - i didn't like Chikezie in the semis, but his two Beatles performances were great - very unique and entertaining. he seems like he has a fun personality too, and his mom is fricken AWESOME. if he had lasted longer and given more performances like his Beatles performances he probably would be higher, but again, he didn't, so i can't place him any higher then 9.

10. Ramiele Malubay - just like Syesha took the biggest jump on my list, Ramiele took the biggest fall. going into the top 12, she was my 3rd favorite. her first semi-final performance was really good...but that was it. her other two semi-final performances were okay, but all 4 of her performances in the finals (except for her last one which was okay) were mediocre. she had a lot of potential, but she chose horrible songs, and in the end wound up being a pretty weak contestant. definitely the most disappointing contestant this season.

11. David Hernandez - the biggest reason he's this low on my list is because compared to everyone else in the top 12, we saw very little from him. but i never really liked him that much either. he has a decent voice, but nothing about him stands out. aside from his *cough* past careers-LOL. so..yeah. whatever. here he is. dont care about him too much : o

12. Amanda Overmyer - im just gonna say shes an acquired taste. one that i will never aquire. lol. she's just not my thing, and she seemed like she didn't wanna be there, so she's last on my list.

WELL THAT TOOK A LONG TIME.

[Cactus Jack]

1. David Arch ( and yeah Joe, I also think you look like him LOL )
2. Carly Smithson
3. David Cook ( sorry haters jk LOL)
4. Michael Johns
5. Brooke White
( if this was the actual top 5, it mightve been the best ever, no it wouldve)
6. Syesha Mercado
7. Kristy Lee Cook ( though I will say I liked her performances from top 10 to when she was eliminated)
8. Jason Castro- made it TOO FAR, but yeah like Joe I was meh with him
9. Ramiele Malubay- Great in the semis, in the finals, not so great at all
10. Chikeze- Wasnt so great in the semis, but his Beatles songs were great
11. David Hernandez-Had one good performance, he was alright, we didnt know much about him except that he was once a stripper
12/ Creulla DeVil I mean Amanda Overmyer- Had one good performance that was in...top 16 week? Yeah nuff saiid, sh wasnt that great, and her hair looked like she killed a skunk and glued it to her head , with a little Creulla DeVil mixed in, it was the only thing interesting about her

[EmoJoe]

Originally Posted by Cactus Jack

3. David Cook ( sorry haters jk LOL)

CLOSET DAVID COOK FANBOI ALERT :OOOOOOOOOOO

[Cactus Jack]

Originally Posted by EmoJoe

CLOSET DAVID COOK FANBOI ALERT :OOOOOOOOOOO

*sigh* Its true, I still think Archuleta shouldve won though, and Carly shouldve been runner up

[EmoJoe]

Originally Posted by Cactus Jack

*sigh* Its true, I still think Archuleta shouldve won though, and Carly shouldve been runner up

lies. i know you were voting for Cook all those times you told me you were voting for David. YOU CANT HIDE THE TRUTH JACK WILSON.

[Cactus Jack]

Originally Posted by EmoJoe

lies. i know you were voting for Cook all those times you told me you were voting for David. YOU CANT HIDE THE TRUTH JACK WILSON.

NO I REALLY VOTED FOR ARCHULETA