If the cast of 'The Division' were on 'Survivor' who would win? - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

AlexzBonner · 01-15-2001, 11:26 PM

This just kinda occured to me cuz my mom watches 'Survivor' when ever it's on. I think, in order that
5. Kate McCafferty
4. Angela Reide
3. Magda Ramirez
2. Jinny Exstead
1. C.D. DeLorenzo

I think C.D. would win... I can't explain it. Jinny couldn't live without alcohol for 9 weeks. Magda might last... Angela? Too goody-goody. Reminds me of Blair! And Kate would definately get kicked off first. Shes too much of a take charge kinda gal. I don't know... Although, Jinny could use that million dollars to buy... whatever it is that she drinks! LOL!

What do you guys think?

------------------
J: Partners? You mean 50/50? Uh... 50/50...50?
B: Oh, good, Jo. We'll let you do the books!
.........................
B: I know a phony when I see one!
J: You should. You spend enough time looking at yourself in the mirror.
.........................
J: Blair, do you ever think of anything but yourself?
B: Like what?

lesliem14 · 01-15-2001, 11:45 PM

I would switch Magda and Jinny, but other than that I agree.

NancyMcKeonRules · 01-16-2001, 03:55 AM

I think Jinny would win and CD would come in second.

------------------
~Kristen

Jo Rules!

#1_Nancy_McKeon · 01-16-2001, 06:22 AM

5:Angela Reide
4:Kate McCafferty
3:Magda Ramirez
2:Either (CD or Jinny)
1

CD or Jinny)

I think either CD or Jinny would win. That's 'if' Jinny could live without her alcohol for that long. If she could it would probably be real close between Jinny and CD. Angela probably would be booted off first because she seems a lot like "Blair" like (AlexzBonner) said. She wouldn't be able to stay on an island for very long without getting annoying! LOL. Also Magda probably would be close behind Jinny and CD because she gets down to business In my opinion anyways. Kate wouldn't stay very long either because the others wouldn't be able to stand her always 'taking charge'and complaining! Well that's my opinion!

------------------
Jo:"Here's to those who wish me well all the rest can go to...Jersey!"

Jo: "You Promise? You Swear? I don't believe you!"

coily2 · 01-16-2001, 10:12 AM

1. First, they'd throw Kate off cuz she's a bitch anyhow. Besides, they're on an island, not at work, so they don't have to put up with her crap.
2. Angela, since nobody knows her and CD would turn them against her
3. Jinny would be next. She'd go into withdrawal due to lack of alcohol/anonymous casual sex, and would be sort of useless
4. It would be a knock-down, drag out fight, but Magda would go next, mainly because CD is a bigger "tough girl".
5. CD would be victorious, but it'd be close.

cat · 01-16-2001, 12:27 PM

first of all: Hiya I'm new!
I really like this board, and this question is a good one too. I agree that CD would probably win.
What I'm wondering now is, who'd win, if...

... the CAST was on that sland
... the characters were on Big Brother
... the cast was on BB

???

Fol_divison_rox_505 · 01-16-2001, 04:24 PM

yep i agree with everything but proabley have jinny 3 because she proabley couldnt not be away from sex or beer...lol ok this may seem nasty but on the island i can see jinny going up to a tree(animal or something) and saying "you and me baby anit nothing but mammles so lets do it like they do on the discovery channle"JK HEHEHE LOL! cuz she couldnt go very long with out sex, least my IMO!!

HOW WOULD JINNY DO ON THAT NEW THING LIKE TEMPTATION ISLAND?? hehe not very well!

------------------
Nat: Hello sailor!

Tootie: hot stuff coming through, and the pizza's are warm too!

Jinny: if you pinch my a$$ one more time, i'll kick your's

Jinny: i think i am going to give up men
Magda: you, give up sex?
Jinny: i didn't say i was giving up sex, i just said i was giving up men! to tell you the truth i kinda like the idea of becoming intamate with something that comes with a money-back gaurentee!

Blair: thunder thighs is hanging up her spikes...
Sue Ann: and you just gave me a great idea were to put them

I'm_NMK · 01-16-2001, 06:22 PM

The characters on Survivor -

5) The Captain - Who the hell wouldn't vote her off? Nobody in their right mind would KEEP their boss on the islans, right? Plus, she's SUCH a bitch!

4 and 3:Eighther CD or Angela BECAUSE you know that they would kick each other off the island. Can you really see them stuck together? Althoug, I think that Angela would go before CD b/c she doesn't seem to have what it takes.

2: Magda - She's sooo nice that she wouldn't live. Plus, she'd miss her kid (like Jenna in the real Survivor)

1. Jinny - I know, I know - the whole alcohol and sex thing, right? Well, you all seem to be forgetting her martial arts. When she feels the urge, she can meditate and do some karate stuff to get back on track. (Oh yea - I'm good! :P) Plus, she seems to be the toughest and most strong willed and determined character on the show.

Anyway, that's just my opinion.

~NMK

Ps. - I haven't seen "Temptation Island". Is it any good? I thought that it seemes a little too sleazy judging by the adds. I haven't seen it though.

As for Big Brother, wouldn't the Facts be a more likely pick than Division? Can you imaging them all stuck together (ESPECIALLY Jo and Blair!) 24/7? They'd kill each other!! I think THAT would be a good show!

------------------
*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
~JO: There were things I always wanted to say to my father........now that I'm older I know better words!
*I am aware this is not exact, but I will watch the episode again and modify it at a latter time, like tonight*

DivisionFan_Jinny · 02-04-2001, 07:13 PM

I'm_NMK: i totally agree w/ you

DivisionFan_Jinny · 02-04-2001, 07:14 PM

I'm_NMK: i totally agree w/ you

DivisionFan_Jinny · 02-04-2001, 07:14 PM

I'm_NMK: i totally agree w/ you

NancyJoJinny · 03-04-2001, 08:14 PM

1.Ok the first to go would be Angela. If i were on an island with her i think id have to ripp out my hair, shes to, you know nice, not that i dont like nice poeple lol, but she just bugs me.

2. The Next to go wold be kate, If Cd, and Madga dont vote her off, i think Jinny would take the papers out and "stuff the ballot box" I know i would

3. Next i think CD would go, shes tough, but that dosnt always help.

4. Next would be Jinny. AL that time with no sex and no beer, i think shed vote herself off.

% ANd Madga would be victorious, unless Jinny knows how to make wine, then she got some competition, but theres still the sex part...

NancyMcKeonFan8976 · 03-24-2001, 06:07 PM

5. Kate
4. Angela
3. C.D
2. Magda
1. Jinny

Exstead · 03-25-2001, 04:08 PM

I think that

5)Kate McCafferty
4)Angela Reid
3)C.D. DeLorenzo
2)Magda Remirez
1)Jinny Exstead

Kate takes too much charge...Angela is too goody goody...C.D. is real aggressive and takes quite a bit of charge...Magda would want to see Ben...Jinny would make it but just barely

stari eyes · 09-16-2001, 08:44 PM

First of all to be the moderator of this and u cursing, u need to be kicked off/out.
Who do i need to talk too to report an abusive user?

Quote:

Originally posted by coily2:
1. First, they'd throw Kate off cuz she's a bitch anyhow. Besides, they're on an island, not at work, so they don't have to put up with her crap.
2. Angela, since nobody knows her and CD would turn them against her
3. Jinny would be next. She'd go into withdrawal due to lack of alcohol/anonymous casual sex, and would be sort of useless
4. It would be a knock-down, drag out fight, but Magda would go next, mainly because CD is a bigger "tough girl".
5. CD would be victorious, but it'd be close.

------------------
Stari

01-15-2001, 11:26 PM	#1
AlexzBonner Member Frequent Poster Join Date: Jan 11, 2001 Location: Muldrow, OK (Miss America '96's home town!) Posts: 284	If the cast of 'The Division' were on 'Survivor' who would win? This just kinda occured to me cuz my mom watches 'Survivor' when ever it's on. I think, in order that 5. Kate McCafferty 4. Angela Reide 3. Magda Ramirez 2. Jinny Exstead 1. C.D. DeLorenzo I think C.D. would win... I can't explain it. Jinny couldn't live without alcohol for 9 weeks. Magda might last... Angela? Too goody-goody. Reminds me of Blair! And Kate would definately get kicked off first. Shes too much of a take charge kinda gal. I don't know... Although, Jinny could use that million dollars to buy... whatever it is that she drinks! LOL! What do you guys think? ------------------ J: Partners? You mean 50/50? Uh... 50/50...50? B: Oh, good, Jo. We'll let you do the books! ......................... B: I know a phony when I see one! J: You should. You spend enough time looking at yourself in the mirror. ......................... J: Blair, do you ever think of anything but yourself? B: Like what?

01-15-2001, 11:45 PM	#2
lesliem14 Member Forum Regular Join Date: Dec 01, 2000 Location: Frankfort, KY Posts: 650	I would switch Magda and Jinny, but other than that I agree.

01-16-2001, 03:55 AM	#3
NancyMcKeonRules Member Occasional Poster Join Date: Jan 11, 2001 Location: Buffalo,NY Posts: 54	I think Jinny would win and CD would come in second. ------------------ ~Kristen Jo Rules!

01-16-2001, 06:22 AM	#4
#1_Nancy_McKeon The One and Only Senior Member Join Date: Dec 16, 2000 Location: USA Posts: 2,656	5:Angela Reide 4:Kate McCafferty 3:Magda Ramirez 2:Either (CD or Jinny) 1 CD or Jinny) I think either CD or Jinny would win. That's 'if' Jinny could live without her alcohol for that long. If she could it would probably be real close between Jinny and CD. Angela probably would be booted off first because she seems a lot like "Blair" like (AlexzBonner) said. She wouldn't be able to stay on an island for very long without getting annoying! LOL. Also Magda probably would be close behind Jinny and CD because she gets down to business In my opinion anyways. Kate wouldn't stay very long either because the others wouldn't be able to stand her always 'taking charge'and complaining! Well that's my opinion! ------------------ Jo:"Here's to those who wish me well all the rest can go to...Jersey!" Jo: "You Promise? You Swear? I don't believe you!"

01-16-2001, 10:12 AM	#5
coily2 Member Forum Regular Join Date: Dec 28, 2000 Location: Chicago, IL Posts: 969	1. First, they'd throw Kate off cuz she's a bitch anyhow. Besides, they're on an island, not at work, so they don't have to put up with her crap. 2. Angela, since nobody knows her and CD would turn them against her 3. Jinny would be next. She'd go into withdrawal due to lack of alcohol/anonymous casual sex, and would be sort of useless 4. It would be a knock-down, drag out fight, but Magda would go next, mainly because CD is a bigger "tough girl". 5. CD would be victorious, but it'd be close.

01-16-2001, 12:27 PM	#6
cat Member Occasional Poster Join Date: Dec 02, 2001 Posts: 5	first of all: Hiya I'm new! I really like this board, and this question is a good one too. I agree that CD would probably win. What I'm wondering now is, who'd win, if... ... the CAST was on that sland ... the characters were on Big Brother ... the cast was on BB ???

01-16-2001, 04:24 PM	#7
Fol_divison_rox_505 Member Frequent Poster Join Date: Jan 09, 2001 Location: MA(same town joey mcIntyre from NKOTB was born in)also it is the wettest dry town(said so on Jay Leno) Posts: 154	yep i agree with everything but proabley have jinny 3 because she proabley couldnt not be away from sex or beer...lol ok this may seem nasty but on the island i can see jinny going up to a tree(animal or something) and saying "you and me baby anit nothing but mammles so lets do it like they do on the discovery channle"JK HEHEHE LOL! cuz she couldnt go very long with out sex, least my IMO!! HOW WOULD JINNY DO ON THAT NEW THING LIKE TEMPTATION ISLAND?? hehe not very well! ------------------ Nat: Hello sailor! Tootie: hot stuff coming through, and the pizza's are warm too! Jinny: if you pinch my a$$ one more time, i'll kick your's Jinny: i think i am going to give up men Magda: you, give up sex? Jinny: i didn't say i was giving up sex, i just said i was giving up men! to tell you the truth i kinda like the idea of becoming intamate with something that comes with a money-back gaurentee! Blair: thunder thighs is hanging up her spikes... Sue Ann: and you just gave me a great idea were to put them

01-16-2001, 06:22 PM	#8
I'm_NMK Member Frequent Poster Join Date: Dec 16, 2000 Location: NY Posts: 280	The characters on Survivor - 5) The Captain - Who the hell wouldn't vote her off? Nobody in their right mind would KEEP their boss on the islans, right? Plus, she's SUCH a bitch! 4 and 3:Eighther CD or Angela BECAUSE you know that they would kick each other off the island. Can you really see them stuck together? Althoug, I think that Angela would go before CD b/c she doesn't seem to have what it takes. 2: Magda - She's sooo nice that she wouldn't live. Plus, she'd miss her kid (like Jenna in the real Survivor) 1. Jinny - I know, I know - the whole alcohol and sex thing, right? Well, you all seem to be forgetting her martial arts. When she feels the urge, she can meditate and do some karate stuff to get back on track. (Oh yea - I'm good! :P) Plus, she seems to be the toughest and most strong willed and determined character on the show. Anyway, that's just my opinion. ~NMK Ps. - I haven't seen "Temptation Island". Is it any good? I thought that it seemes a little too sleazy judging by the adds. I haven't seen it though. As for Big Brother, wouldn't the Facts be a more likely pick than Division? Can you imaging them all stuck together (ESPECIALLY Jo and Blair!) 24/7? They'd kill each other!! I think THAT would be a good show! ------------------ ~~~~~~~~~~~~* ~JO: There were things I always wanted to say to my father........now that I'm older I know better words! I am aware this is not exact, but I will watch the episode again and modify it at a latter time, like tonight

02-04-2001, 07:13 PM	#9
DivisionFan_Jinny Member Occasional Poster Join Date: Jan 20, 2001 Location: Bristol, CT (Home of the ESPN headquarters!) Posts: 69	I'm_NMK: i totally agree w/ you

02-04-2001, 07:14 PM	#10
DivisionFan_Jinny Member Occasional Poster Join Date: Jan 20, 2001 Location: Bristol, CT (Home of the ESPN headquarters!) Posts: 69	I'm_NMK: i totally agree w/ you

03-04-2001, 08:14 PM	#12
NancyJoJinny Member Forum Regular Join Date: Mar 04, 2001 Location: Nancy Land, NJ. Posts: 989	1.Ok the first to go would be Angela. If i were on an island with her i think id have to ripp out my hair, shes to, you know nice, not that i dont like nice poeple lol, but she just bugs me. 2. The Next to go wold be kate, If Cd, and Madga dont vote her off, i think Jinny would take the papers out and "stuff the ballot box" I know i would 3. Next i think CD would go, shes tough, but that dosnt always help. 4. Next would be Jinny. AL that time with no sex and no beer, i think shed vote herself off. % ANd Madga would be victorious, unless Jinny knows how to make wine, then she got some competition, but theres still the sex part...

03-24-2001, 06:07 PM	#13
NancyMcKeonFan8976 Member Forum Regular Join Date: Mar 22, 2001 Location: New Jersey, USA Posts: 887	5. Kate 4. Angela 3. C.D 2. Magda 1. Jinny

03-25-2001, 04:08 PM	#14
Exstead Member Occasional Poster Join Date: Mar 25, 2001 Location: Lincoln,Nebraska,USA Posts: 84	I think that 5)Kate McCafferty 4)Angela Reid 3)C.D. DeLorenzo 2)Magda Remirez 1)Jinny Exstead Kate takes too much charge...Angela is too goody goody...C.D. is real aggressive and takes quite a bit of charge...Magda would want to see Ben...Jinny would make it but just barely