Refined, semi-complete list of final appealants

[justins5256]

In a past post, I was trying to get an accounting for all the "Final Appeal" segments on UM. Interestingly enough, I found this neat article TJ posted back in 2002 with information from a presskit detailing the types of segments and statistics with regard to how many cases in each category were solved.

http://www.sitcomsonline.com/boards/...t=final+appeal

His post indicates that there were 18 "Final Appeal" segments aired before May 20, 1996. Thus far, I have been able to account for 12 cases appearing exclusively on UM. Since the number is so low, I'm guessing the presskit statistics are lumping the "Final Appeal" spin-off cases in there too. So, here is the list of appealants, the dates their stories aired, and the crimes they were accused of.

1. Glen Consagra – 9/24/87 - murder.
2. Michael Scott Martin – 2/5/88 – armed robbery.
3. Dr. John Branion – 12/20/89 - murder.
4. Johnny Lee Wilson – 11/28/90 – murder, arson.
5. Patricia Stallings – 5/8/91 - infanticide.
6. Larry Race – 12/18/91 - murder.
7. Bird Road Rapist - 12/16/92 - rape.
8. Rick McCue – 1/6/93 - murder.
9. Rolando Cruz – 2/9/93 - murder.
10. Michael Lloyd Self – 5/19/93 - murder.
11. Paul Freshour – 11/11/94 – attempted murder, harassment.
12. Stuart Heaton – 12/16/94 - murder.

Final Appeal Spin-off

13. Dr. Jeffery MacDonald – Final Appeal – 9/18/92 - murder.
14. WWII group of black servicemen – Final Appeal - 9/18/92(?) - mutiny.
15. Paul W. Ferrell – Final Appeal – 9/25/92 - murder.
16. Anthony Miller – Final Appeal – 10/9/92 – armed robbery and attempted murder of a police officer.
17. John Purvis – Final Appeal - murder.

Post 1996 "Final Appeals" on Unsolved Mysteries...

1. Tommy Ziegler - 1/31/97 - murder.
2. Frederick Young - robbery.
3. Darlie Routier - 8/24/2001 - murder.

Maybe this list could become a "sticky"?

[DarkDante]

^ Not only sticky this but really CD or somebody should do an attractive 2 DVD set with all of these on them. I know many of us have most of these already on either various "Dawn DVD"s (hey I think I just named Crystaldawn's DVD "company"!) or whatnot but it would be nice to have an attractive two disc set of these

Maybe we can even put together some artwork?

Hmm JS: TJ noted there were 18 "Final Appeal" cases - even with the spinoff listings there are still only 17. What one is missing? Wasn't there a final appeal case floating around out there from NBC that we only have an update of? - Also wasn't Paul Freshour's case an "Unexplained Death" case and not an FA? - Sorry to get so technicial just trying to figure out which FA case is missing.

[justins5256]

Originally Posted by DarkDante

Hmm JS: TJ noted there were 18 "Final Appeal" cases - even with the spinoff listings there are still only 17. What one is missing? Wasn't there a final appeal case floating around out there from NBC that we only have an update of? - Also wasn't Paul Freshour's case an "Unexplained Death" case and not an FA? - Sorry to get so technicial just trying to figure out which FA case is missing.

At least two segments from the "Final Appeal" program were updated on UM on NBC: Tony Miller and John Purvis. The John Purvis update made it to Lifetime, the Tony Miller update did not (to my knowledge).

Paul Freshour's segment was indeed a "Final Appeal" on UM. An odd choice since Freshour had already been released from prison. Although he was trying to clear his name, since he was still implicated in and convicted for his involvement with the Circleville Letters. I consider Freshour's segment a hybrid between "Unexplained Death" "Final Appeal" and "Wanted". Kinda like Tim McClure in the sense that he too was trying to clear his name, but McClure's segment was still labeled an "Unexplained Death".

All that being said, there is at least one case I can't account for. If I had to guess, I would say it is another episode of the "Final Appeal" spinoff of which we are unaware.

Those episodes of the "Final Appeal" program are the ultimate holy grail. To my knowledge, no one has claimed to have them on tape, and they never resurfaced on Lifetime (with the exceptions of the Macdonald case and the black seamen).

[justins5256]

Bump. Here is a complete list of 23. All accounted for.

1. Glen Consagra – 9/24/87 - murder.
2. Michael Scott Martin – 2/5/88 – armed robbery.
3. Dr. John Branion – 12/20/89 - murder.
4. Johnny Lee Wilson – 11/28/90 – murder, arson.
5. Patricia Stallings – 5/8/91 - infanticide.
6. Larry Race – 12/18/91 - murder.
7. Dr. Jeffery MacDonald – Final Appeal – 9/18/92 - murder.
8. Port Chicago Seamen - Final Appeal - 9/18/92 - mutiny.
9. Paul W. Ferrell – Final Appeal – 9/25/92 - murder.
10. Steve Shore - Final Appeal - 10/2/92 - murder.
11. Tony Miller – Final Appeal – 10/9/92 – armed robbery and attempted murder of a police officer.
12. Dan Montecalvo -Final Appeal - 10/16/92 - murder.
13. Thomas Drake - Final Appeal - 10/23/92 - attempted murder, grand theft.
14. Luis Diaz aka "The Bird Road Rapist" - 12/16/92 - rape.
15. Rick McCue – 1/6/93 - murder.
16. Rolando Cruz – 2/9/93 - murder.
17. John Purvis - 3/10/93 - murder.
18. Michael Lloyd Self – 5/19/93 - murder.
19. Paul Freshour – 11/11/94 – attempted murder, harassment.
20. Stuart Heaton – 12/16/94 - murder.
21. Tommy Ziegler - 1/31/97 - murder.
22. Frederick Young - robbery.
23. Darlie Routier - 8/24/2001 - murder.

[MegtheEgg86]

I was completely unaware until now that Paul Freshour's case was actually a FA segment! I was always under the impression it was an "Unexplained Death", but looking back on it, it makes sense. Cool little factoid (yeah, I just used that word). The things you learn..