‘Total Request Taped’? MTV icon must cut back

[Brian Damage]

NEW YORK - MTV’s “Total Request Live” is no longer totally live.

It’s another sign of how both the audience and cultural juice have faded for “TRL,” once the most influential program on television for music superstars from the Backstreet Boys to Beyonce — even if they just dropped by to push an ice cream cart.

Two weeks ago, MTV began taping “Total Request Live” two days a week in an effort to save money. After live shows air Monday and Wednesday afternoons, shows are then taped for the following day.


“Total Request Taped”? No, the show’s title won’t be adjusted for the less-than-live days, spokeswoman Marnie Black said Tuesday.

“We’re not editing anything,” she said. “We’re not changing anything. The spirit of the show is going to be exactly the same.”

The television term is live-to-tape, which is how late-night programs hosted by David Letterman, Jay Leno and Jon Stewart are done. For “TRL,” it’s still a significant change for a show that touts its interactivity with the audience, who vote online for their favorite videos.

“TRL” is one of MTV’s landmarks, the third-longest-running program in the network’s history. It nailed the cultural zeitgeist upon its September 1998 debut, becoming the epicenter of the teen pop scene with Britney Spears, *NSYNC and the Backstreet Boys. So many fans crowded the streets outside MTV’s studio for an October 1998 appearance by the Backstreet Boys that police briefly shut down Times Square.


Artists go to “drop” new music, movie stars to tout new films and celebrities just to stay celebrities — sometimes to disastrous effect. Mariah Carey’s surprise appearance in 2001 pushing an ice cream cart filled with popsicles was so odd, she checked into a hospital for “exhaustion” a week later.

At its peak in 1999, “TRL” had 757,000 viewers a day, with 346,000 of them aged 12 to 17, according to Nielsen Media Research.

So far this year, the show — now seen at 3:30 p.m. ET — averages 351,000 viewers a day, Nielsen said. The 12-to-17-year-old audience is only 113,000, half what it was only two years ago.

“TRL” still has cachet, but is now only one of many places that music executives try to break a new artist. The most prominent destinations are now online, said Jon Caramanica, music editor at Vibe magazine. Pop music is also much more fragmented these days, he said, lessening the desire of fans to congregate at a central place.

Original host Carson Daly left in 2003. A rotating group of MTV VJs are hosts now: Damien Fahey, Vanessa Minnillo, Susie Castillo, Cipha Sounds, La La (Alani Vazquez) and Stephen Colletti.


The “TRL” change comes at a time of retrenchment at MTV Networks, a division of Viacom Inc. MTV Networks said last month it was cutting 250 jobs and shutting down MTV World, a package of digital channels geared to Americans of Asian descent. Black said MTV is trying to consolidate resources at its Times Square studio, where “TRL” is filmed.

“We’re still committed to the show and it’s the cornerstone of the afternoon schedule,” she said. “ ‘TRL’ is not the same show as it was when Carson Daly hosted it. The show has evolved and will continue to evolve.”

[friendsfan77]

I was so disappointed when I saw this show for the first time. I had finally gotten cable again, and I heard about this show and I really loved the idea of seeing music videos when I got home from school. Only to find out they only show 30 second clips of the music videos with people cheering in the background and with crap all over the screen. And even worse sometimes someone making a shout-out over the video in some box on the corner of the screen. I just couldn't take it.

[PrettyinPink55]

I stopped watching the show in like 2001. It really was at its peak in 1999. I don't think it was ever the same after that. Now when I tune in from time to time, it sucks!!!!! Damien Fahey is great, but it's not the same.