Fox executive denies new "American Idol" is meaner

[Brian Damage]

Days after the hugely successful return of "American Idol" to the airwaves, the Fox network's chief programmer on Saturday shrugged off complaints from viewers the hit talent show had grown too mean-spirited.

Appearing at the network's semi-annual gathering of TV critics, Peter Liguori, entertainment president for the Fox Broadcast Co., denied the show was focusing too much on the worst contestants and that the celebrity judges had become gratuitously harsh.

Simon Cowell, the British record producer known for his bitingly sharp commentary, has been criticized this season for being especially cruel toward some of the less-talented and offbeat contestants appearing on the show's popular audition segments.

Singling out one performer for his appearance, Cowell said the contestant resembled "one of those creatures that live in the jungle with those massive eyes ... what are they called? Bush babies?"

That episode even drew an outcry from TV talk-show host Rosie O'Donnell.

"I don't think America likes to watch people be ridiculed, made fun of, and called ugly monkeys," O'Donnell said on her show, "The View."

Liguori defended Cowell, saying, "I've actually had people say to me it seems Simon is somewhat toned down this year.

"More people are coming to the show ... they know what to expect. They have to appreciate the spirit in which that commentary is given," he said.

Ligouri denied asking Cowell or the other judges to rein in their remarks. "The judges know what makes the show tick," he said. "This season has just been a continuation of what has been a very successful formula."

RECORD AUDIENCE

Indeed, Tuesday's two-hour premiere of the sixth season of "American Idol" drew a record 37.3 million viewers, the most ever for a debut episode of the show, and nearly 37 million more tuned in on Wednesday for another round of auditions.

Those kinds of numbers make "Idol" the most-watched show on U.S. television, dominating the prime-time landscape for months at a time and giving Fox a powerful promotional platform for new and struggling series. Fox is a unit of News Corp.

To that end, Liguori unveiled plans to launch three new scripted shows this spring, including a drama about a family of wedding planners from acclaimed producer David E. Kelley.

Even "American Idol" rejects have basked in the show's afterglow. Several contestants thrown off this week, including Cowell's "bush baby," turned up on the talk-show circuit this week.

Liguori also dismissed questions about the recent erratic behavior of Cowell's fellow "Idol" judge, singer Paula Abdul.

"America loves her. She's successful on the show," he said of Abdul, who made headlines last week when an online video emerged of her slurring and gesticulating her way through a promotional TV appearance.

Liguori repeated Abdul's previous explanation the TV interview in question was fraught with audio problems and followed dozens of back-to-back interviews. "I would probably be a little slap-happy at that point as well," Liguori said.

[Ireneparalegal]

Oh no Rosie opens her mouth again.

Ok, if they aren't meaner, how abt under the influence?

[friendsfan77]

Simon's always been an ass, and this isn't the first time he's taken his criticisms over the line. I mean, it's ridiculous when you don't have much if not anything at all negative to say about his singing, and soon resort to talking nasty about someone's physical features (i.e. facial and body features). That's just pathetic and shows how classless someone can be. And, from that one clip in particular, I expected more from Paula. Usually, when Simon goes too far and starts talking about someone nasty like that, Paula and Randy (rightfully so) snap and go off on him. To see her laugh afterwards (if she was indeed laughing at what Simon said) would make me lose a little respect for her.

Though as for bad singing, give me a freaking break. Please, that's not exploitation in any sense of the word. Those folks sign up for that stuff. Voluntarily. And really, it seems as though 98% of the bad singers go on there to get their 15 minutes (more like 15 seconds) of fame and want attention. I wouldn't be surprised to hear if people ran/run up to either Paula, Randy, Simon, or Ryan on the street and auditioned out of the blue, like how Chuck Barris explained people did to him most everytime he went outside in public when The Gong Show was popular.

[Ireneparalegal]

That comment abt how that guy looked (the creature with the big eyes) I believe to be a low for Simon. That was uncalled for. So what if he looks that way, if he could sing would that change anything?

[Brian Damage]

Originally Posted by Ireneparalegal

That comment abt how that guy looked (the creature with the big eyes) I believe to be a low for Simon. That was uncalled for. So what if he looks that way, if he could sing would that change anything?

With Simon, yes, he not only looks for good voices, but also looks.

[Karen*]

I thought the monkey comment was really rude, but not as rude as last season when Simon made comments about Mandisa's weight. What do you expect though? It's SIMON. o_0

[friendsfan77]

Originally Posted by The Girl Next Door

I thought the monkey comment was really rude, but not as rude as last season when Simon made comments about Mandisa's weight. What do you expect though? It's SIMON. o_0

He's done that before. I remember in, I think it was season 2 where Simon said something about a girl's weight, and Randy, for a second I thought was going to give him a beatdown.