Best AI5 Performance Game

[Bella_KitKat]

Took this straight from IDF.

Please vote based on performances and not by how much you love or hate a contestant. Try to be as fair/unbiased as possible. Once we have a winner for each round, I will post the next theme performances and we continue this same process. Once we have all the winning performances from each theme, they will battle out and we will have 1 performance named as the Best AI5 Performance.

Rules:
1. You can vote however often you like (I know IDf has time restraints, but not here, 'kay?)
2. You +1 to your favorite performance and -1 to your least favorite performance.
3. Please try to fix the scores if you notice they are wrong.


Top 12 Girls:
12. Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are"
11. Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life"
10. Kinnik Sky: "Get Here"
9. Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me"
8. Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down"
7. Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night"
6. Kellie Pickler: "How Far"
5. Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing"
4. Ayla Brown: "Reflection"
3. Mandisa: "Never"
2. Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia"
1. Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You"

Top 12 Guys:
12. Bobby Bennett: "Copacabana"
11. Kevin Covais: "One Last Cry"
10. Sway Penala: "Reasons"
9. Bucky Covington: "Simple Man"
8. Gedeon McKinney: "Shout"
7. David Radford: "Crazy Little Thing Called Love"
6. Patrick Hall: "Come To My Window"
5. Will Makar: "I Want You Back"
4. Ace Young: "Father Figure"
3. Taylor Hicks: "Levon"
2. Elliott Yamin: "If You Really Love Me"
1. Chris Daughtry: "Wanted Dead Or Alive"

Top 10 Girls:
10. Brenna Gethers: "Last Dance"
9. Heather Cox: "Hero"
8. Kinnik Sky: "Here For The Party"
7. Paris Bennett: "Wind Beneath My Wings"
6. Katharine McPhee: "All Is Fair In Love"
5. Mandisa: "Cry"
4. Melissa McGhee: "Why Haven't I Heard From You?"
3. Kellie Pickler: "Something To Talk About"
2. Lisa Tucker: "Who's Loving You?"
1. Ayla Brown: "I Want You To Need Me"

Top 10 Guys:
10. Sway Penala: "Overjoyed”
9. Kevin Covais: "I Heard It Through The Grapevine"
8. Bucky Covington: "The Thunder Rolls"
7. Taylor Hicks: "Easy"
6. David Radford: "The Way You Look Tonight"
5. Ace Young: "If You're Not The One"
4. Will Makar: "Lady"
3. Gedeon McKinney: "Change Is Gonna Come"
2. Elliott Yamin: "Moody's Mood For Love"
1. Chris Daughtry: "Hemorrhage"

Top 8 Girls:
8. Kinnik Sky: "If I Ain't Got You"
7. Paris Bennett: "Conga"
6. Ayla Brown: "Unwritten"
5. Mandisa: "I'm Every Woman"
4. Kellie Pickler: "I'm The Only One"
3. Katharine McPhee: "Think"
2. Melissa McGhee: "What About Love?"
1. Lisa Tucker: "Here's Where I Stand"

Top 8 Guys:
8. Kevin Covais: "Vincent"
7. Bucky Covington: "Wave on Wave"
6. Will Makar: "How Sweet It Is"
5. Chris Daughtry: "Broken"
4. Ace Young: "Butterflies"
3. Gedeon McKinney: "When A Man Loves A Woman"
2. Elliott Yamin: "Heaven"
1. Taylor Hicks: "Taking It To The Streets"

Top 12 - Stevie Wonder
12. Kevin Covais: "Part Time Lover"
11. Melissa McGhee: "Lately"
10. Kellie Pickler: "Blame It On The Sun"
9. Ace Young: "Do I Do"
8. Mandisa: "Don't You Worry 'Bout A Thing"
7. Lisa Tucker: "Signed, Sealed, Delivered"
6. Elliott Yamin: "Knocks Me Off My Feet"
5. Bucky Covington: "Superstition"
4. Paris Bennett: "All I Do"
3. Taylor Hicks: "Living for the City"
2. Katharine McPhee: "Until You Come Back to Me"
1. Chris Daughtry: "Higher Ground"

Top 11 - The 1950s
11. Kevin Covais: "When I Fall In Love"
10. Bucky Covington: "Oh Boy"
9. Ace Young: "In The Still Of The Night"
8. Lisa Tucker: "Why Do Fools Fall In Love?"
7. Taylor Hicks: "Not Fade Away"
6. Elliott Yamin: "Teach Me Tonight"
5. Mandisa: "I Don't Hurt Anymore"
4. Kellie Pickler: "Walkin' After Midnight"
3. Chris Daughtry: "I Walk The Line"
2. Paris Bennett: "Fever"
1. Katharine McPhee: "Come Rain Or Come Shine"

Top 10 - Songs from the 21st Century
10. Mandisa: "Shackles"
9. Kellie Pickler: "Suds In The Bucket"
8. Ace Young: "Drops Of Jupiter"
7. Lisa Tucker: "Because Of You"
6.
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 9 - Country
9.
8.
7.
6.
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 8 - Queen
8.
7.
6.
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 7 - Songs from the Great American Songbook
7.
6.
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 6 - Classic Love Songs
6.
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 5 - Birth Year
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 5 - Billboard Top 10
5.
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 4 - Elvis Round One
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 4 - Elvis Round Two
4.
3.
2.
1.

Top 3 - Clive Davis Pick
3.
2.
1.

Top 3 - Judges Pick
3.
2.
1.

Top 3 - Contestants Choice
3.
2.
1.

Finale - First Repeat
2.
1.

Finale - Second Repeat
2.
1.

Finale - Coronation Single
2.
1.

[EmoJoe]

Top 12 Girls Semi-Finals Performances
Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 11
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 10
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 10
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 10
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 10
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 10
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 9


+ Ayla
- Stevie

[I Love John Ritter]

Top 12 Girls Semi-Finals Performances
Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 11
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 10
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 9
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 10
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 10
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 11
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 9

+ Paris
- Brenna

[Cactus Jack]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 11
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 10
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 9
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 12
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 10
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 10
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 9

+ Ayla/Katahrine
- Brenna/Stevie

[Karen*]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 11
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 10
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 9
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 11
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 10
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 10
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 8

+ Katharine
- Stevie

[EmoJoe]

wait...something got messed up along the way. this is how it really wouldbe now...

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 12
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 11
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 7
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 11
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 10
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 10
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 8

now my turn....

[EmoJoe]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 12
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 11
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 7
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 12
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 10
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 11
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 7

+ Katharine (i liked Katharine and Ayla's performances about equal, so I'll just keep switching)
- Stevie

[Bella_KitKat]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 12
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 12
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 7
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 12
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 9
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 11
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 7

+ Becky
- Kinnik

[EmoJoe]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 13
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 12
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 7
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 12
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 9
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 11
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 6

+ Ayla
- Stevie

[David]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 13
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 12
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 7
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 9
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 13
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 9
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 11
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 6

+ Katharine
- Heather

[EmoJoe]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 13
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 12
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 7
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 9
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 14
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 9
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 11
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 5

+ Katharine
- Stevie

[Cactus Jack]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 13
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 10
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 5
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 13
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 10
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 10
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 5

+ Ayla/Katahrine
- Brenna/Stevie

[Karen*]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 13
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 10
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 5
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 10
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 14
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 10
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 10
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 4

+ Katharine
- Stevie

[I Love John Ritter]

Wait, something got messed up again. I think this is how it's supposed to be now.

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 14
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 12
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 6
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 9
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 17
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 9
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 10
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 11
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 2

[I Love John Ritter]

Ayla Brown: "Reflection" - 14
Becky O'Donohue: "Because The Night" - 12
Brenna Gethers: "You Are The Sunshine of My Life" - 5
Heather Cox: "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - 9
Katharine McPhee: "Since I Fell For You" - 17
Kellie Pickler: "How Far" - 10
Kinnik Sky: "Get Here" - 9
Lisa Tucker: "I Am Changing" - 10
Mandisa: "Never" - 11
Melissa McGhee: "When The Lights Go Down" - 10
Paris Bennett: "Midnight Train to Georgia" - 11
Stevie Scott: "To Where You Are" - 2

+ Mandisa
- Brenna