AI5: Which 2 girls do you think will leave first? - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

EmoJoe · 02-22-2006, 04:10 PM

title says all...which 2 girls do you think will be the first to get the boot?

IMO, paris, katherine, ayla, lisa, kellie, and mandisa are basically guarenteed saftey

becky didnt give the best performance, but she still has a fanbase to save her, so she'll be safe

i think that heather, kinnik, brenna, stevie, and melissa all have the best shot at leaving.

melissa was the best performer out of all of them, so she'll be safe.

heather has somewhat of a fanbase to save her since she was shown for a littttttle bit during the audition rounds, so i think she'll be safe.

i think that the person leaving will be any combination of brenna, kinnik, and stevie. stevie COULD get the symphany vote because of what simon said, but i think she'll leave thursday. kinnik had a better performance then brenna, plus brenna's personality turns a lot of people off, so i think stevie and brenna will be going home thursday

David · 02-22-2006, 05:25 PM

i do agree that it's between Heather, Kinnik, Brenna, Stevie, and Melissa (for elimination).

I think Heather is definitely out. It was just bland and forgettable. Stevie wasn't good either, but I think she was weak enough to get some sympathy votes, so I think Stevie is like the Janay of the season. Kinnik has the advantage of that long note and the fact that she was the eleventh performer of the night, so I think she's safe too. I think the other girl out will be between Brenna and Melissa. Brenna's attitude may attract some people, but last night her performance was the total opposite, and it didn't work. Melissa did a really good job, but even with that, she's the one I keep forgetting about.

Cactus Jack · 02-22-2006, 07:21 PM

STEVIE AND BRENNA

Karen* · 02-22-2006, 08:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jack: Texas Smurftractor

STEVIE AND BRENNA

TVFanatic82 · 02-23-2006, 01:56 AM

Oh man, as long as Stevie is gone, I'll be happy. I could not stand watching her perform. It was totally boring and she has like zero personality. If she is safe, it'll ONLY be because people feel sorry for her, like you guys were saying. As for who I think will join her, I'm thinking maybe Heather Cox. Why on EARTH did she choose that American Idol song for?

EmoJoe · 02-23-2006, 08:43 PM

im gonna do the same grouping for the girls that I did for the guys

The Definite Safe
Paris- I'm not a huge fan, but she has the judges support, fanbase, and an overall good performance. She'll be 99.99999% safe.
Katherine- Basically, same as Paris. I LOVE her though

. She had a great performance and she also has the judges and fans on her side. It also didnt hurt that she went last.
Lisa- Great performance. She doesnt have quite as big of a fanbase as contestans such as Paris, Katherine, and Kellie do, but she has a good enough one and she gave a great performance. Again, she also has the judges on her side

The Probable Safe
Kellie- Although she has a lot of haters, and her performance wasnt the BEST, she still gave a decent performance and she has enough fans to last her another week. I think she'll make top 12.
Mandisa- Her performance didn't quite match up to some of the others, but it was still great. The only thing that worries me is that she doesnt have a huge fan support. She has a lot of people that think shes good, but not many OMGMGMG IM GONNA VOTE FOR HER TILL MY FINGERS FALL OFF fans. I think that could be her downfall in the future, but for now, I think she's safe.
Ayla- Great performance. She surprised a lot of people. Again, same as Mandisa, she has a lot of people that think shes good, but not many extremley dedicated fans. I also think her basketball backstory will hurt her because people now if she gets voted off, she'll have something to go back to. So I think these could hurt Ayla in the near future. But for now, I think she's safe, and I do think she'll make finals.

The Middle Group (aka can go either way)
Becky- her performance wasnt great, but she has great stage presense and really connects with the music. But she has almost no fans. Not many people even think shes good. Therefore, I think Becky will be booted before Top 12, and she has a slight chance of leaving this week.
Melissa- Melissa has a good voice and could pull a LaToya/Kelly/Jasmine/Bo (making the finals desite little to no airtime). She is very forgettable though, and needs to do step up her performance and vocals. She does have a small chance of leaving this week. If she is safe though, and if she steps up her vocals and performance so she isnt forgettable (and the 3 Bs- boring, bland, and blah) she could make top 12.

The Danger Group (aka the group with the best possibility of leaving
Stevie- her performance....was bad. that kinda goes without saying, but i think she could make it to the next round with the symphany vote...because of what simon said to her.
Brenna- her personality turns a lot of people off and her performance was boring, bland, and blah. she could very well go after that
Kinnik- she could very well go after that, it was forgettable. she also doesnt show much personality
Heather- awful song choice. the performance was kinda bad, but i didnt think it was the worst of the night. ill be shocked if she makes it to round 2

i think any combination of the danger group could work as the person leaving

02-22-2006, 04:10 PM	#1
EmoJoe Cool cool cool Forum Addict Join Date: Apr 23, 2004 Location: New Jersey Posts: 71,478	AI5: Which 2 girls do you think will leave first? title says all...which 2 girls do you think will be the first to get the boot? IMO, paris, katherine, ayla, lisa, kellie, and mandisa are basically guarenteed saftey becky didnt give the best performance, but she still has a fanbase to save her, so she'll be safe i think that heather, kinnik, brenna, stevie, and melissa all have the best shot at leaving. melissa was the best performer out of all of them, so she'll be safe. heather has somewhat of a fanbase to save her since she was shown for a littttttle bit during the audition rounds, so i think she'll be safe. i think that the person leaving will be any combination of brenna, kinnik, and stevie. stevie COULD get the symphany vote because of what simon said, but i think she'll leave thursday. kinnik had a better performance then brenna, plus brenna's personality turns a lot of people off, so i think stevie and brenna will be going home thursday
	__________________ "I know the difference between TV and reality, Jeff. TV has structure, it makes sense, there are likable leading men. In real life, we have this. We have you." - Abed Nadir, Community www.sitcomsarestupid.blogspot.com

02-22-2006, 05:25 PM	#2
David mcphee. Forum Superstar Join Date: Jan 30, 2003 Location: jacksonville, FL. Posts: 28,115	i do agree that it's between Heather, Kinnik, Brenna, Stevie, and Melissa (for elimination). I think Heather is definitely out. It was just bland and forgettable. Stevie wasn't good either, but I think she was weak enough to get some sympathy votes, so I think Stevie is like the Janay of the season. Kinnik has the advantage of that long note and the fact that she was the eleventh performer of the night, so I think she's safe too. I think the other girl out will be between Brenna and Melissa. Brenna's attitude may attract some people, but last night her performance was the total opposite, and it didn't work. Melissa did a really good job, but even with that, she's the one I keep forgetting about.
	__________________ v. 39 - katharine and chris elliott, you rock.

02-22-2006, 07:21 PM	#3
Cactus Jack RonFingSwanson Forum Idol Join Date: Dec 09, 2001 Location: Santa Rosa Beach,FL Posts: 103,099	STEVIE AND BRENNA
	__________________ Id Love to help you Tracy, but I cant have sex with a black guy, Id lose my endorsement deal with NASCAR-Jenna Maroney,30 Rock April 17,2009 9:02 PM : 100,000th post!

02-23-2006, 01:56 AM	#5
TVFanatic82 TV Freak Occasional Poster Join Date: Jan 02, 2006 Posts: 11	Oh man, as long as Stevie is gone, I'll be happy. I could not stand watching her perform. It was totally boring and she has like zero personality. If she is safe, it'll ONLY be because people feel sorry for her, like you guys were saying. As for who I think will join her, I'm thinking maybe Heather Cox. Why on EARTH did she choose that American Idol song for?
	__________________ http://groups.msn.com/TVFreaksAnonymous

02-23-2006, 08:43 PM	#6
EmoJoe Cool cool cool Forum Addict Join Date: Apr 23, 2004 Location: New Jersey Posts: 71,478	im gonna do the same grouping for the girls that I did for the guys The Definite Safe Paris- I'm not a huge fan, but she has the judges support, fanbase, and an overall good performance. She'll be 99.99999% safe. Katherine- Basically, same as Paris. I LOVE her though . She had a great performance and she also has the judges and fans on her side. It also didnt hurt that she went last. Lisa- Great performance. She doesnt have quite as big of a fanbase as contestans such as Paris, Katherine, and Kellie do, but she has a good enough one and she gave a great performance. Again, she also has the judges on her side The Probable Safe Kellie- Although she has a lot of haters, and her performance wasnt the BEST, she still gave a decent performance and she has enough fans to last her another week. I think she'll make top 12. Mandisa- Her performance didn't quite match up to some of the others, but it was still great. The only thing that worries me is that she doesnt have a huge fan support. She has a lot of people that think shes good, but not many OMGMGMG IM GONNA VOTE FOR HER TILL MY FINGERS FALL OFF fans. I think that could be her downfall in the future, but for now, I think she's safe. Ayla- Great performance. She surprised a lot of people. Again, same as Mandisa, she has a lot of people that think shes good, but not many extremley dedicated fans. I also think her basketball backstory will hurt her because people now if she gets voted off, she'll have something to go back to. So I think these could hurt Ayla in the near future. But for now, I think she's safe, and I do think she'll make finals. The Middle Group (aka can go either way) Becky- her performance wasnt great, but she has great stage presense and really connects with the music. But she has almost no fans. Not many people even think shes good. Therefore, I think Becky will be booted before Top 12, and she has a slight chance of leaving this week. Melissa- Melissa has a good voice and could pull a LaToya/Kelly/Jasmine/Bo (making the finals desite little to no airtime). She is very forgettable though, and needs to do step up her performance and vocals. She does have a small chance of leaving this week. If she is safe though, and if she steps up her vocals and performance so she isnt forgettable (and the 3 Bs- boring, bland, and blah) she could make top 12. The Danger Group (aka the group with the best possibility of leaving Stevie- her performance....was bad. that kinda goes without saying, but i think she could make it to the next round with the symphany vote...because of what simon said to her. Brenna- her personality turns a lot of people off and her performance was boring, bland, and blah. she could very well go after that Kinnik- she could very well go after that, it was forgettable. she also doesnt show much personality Heather- awful song choice. the performance was kinda bad, but i didnt think it was the worst of the night. ill be shocked if she makes it to round 2 i think any combination of the danger group could work as the person leaving