American Idol 2 Do Over - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

Bella_KitKat · 09-03-2005, 06:20 PM

hey y'all..again. Since the season 4 redo was such a smash hit - LOL I'm a dork - I thought I'd try my luck again. In all seriousness, I'm really really glad you liked season 4 redo. Makes me feel loved.

So, season 2 was arguably the most controversial win. Let's do the year again, shall we? Here's your chance to make it right. Will Ruben win again? Will Clay pull it out? And what about Carmen, Josh, and Corey Clark? You decide!!

Like before, whoever got voted off the previous week, that song will go to another contestant. Unless, of course, the song doesn't mesh with the person's personality - then I'll do my best to pick one that will.

okay, here we go with another season.

Group 1

Bettis Richardson – Thank You
Charles Grigsby - Overjoyed
J.D. Adams – All Is Fair In Love
Julia DeMato – Son Of A Preacher Man
Kimberly Caldwell – Come To My Window
Meosha Denton – How Do I Live?
Patrick Fortson – Unbreak My Heart
Trenyce – That’s Just Love Sneaking Up On You

Group 2

Clay Aiken – Open Arms
Candice Coleman – Piece Of My Heart
Hadas – You Light Up My Life
Jacob John – Anytime
Jennifer Fuentes – I Wanna Dance With Somebody
Kimberley Locke – Somewhere Over The Rainbow
Rebecca Bond – Rapture
Rueben Studdard – Superstar

Group 3

Equoia Coleman – Memories
George Trice – Unchained Melody
Jordan Segundo – For Your Love
Kimberly Kelsey – It’s All Coming Back To Me Now
Louis Gazarra – How Am I Supposed To Live Without You?
Rickey Smith – One Last Cry
Samantha Cohen – Something He Can Feel
Vanessa Olivarez – Out Here On My Own

Group 4

Ashley Hartman – Touch Me In The Morning
Chip Days – Song For You
Corey Clark – Foolish Heart
Joshua Gracin – I’ll Be
Juanita Barber – What About The Children?
Nasheka Siddal – Open My Heart
Patrick Lake – When I See You Smile
Sylvia Chilbiliti – Didn’t We Almost Have It All?

Rank the performances in order - most favorite to least favorite. To make things easier on me, would you please just write the names and put + 8 or whatever - your # 1 gets 8 pts. Oh...please PM. Just like before.

I will post results for all 4 rounds at the same time.

Thanks!

(David will you sticky this?)

Tibbs · 09-03-2005, 11:48 PM

I voted

David · 09-04-2005, 09:11 AM

Voted

EmoJoe · 09-05-2005, 05:52 PM

I think ill vote once we get to the finals, I know the finalists more than the semi-finalists.

Bella_KitKat · 09-10-2005, 01:32 PM

All right, America, what have you done? Here we find out those lucky contestants who have made it to the top 12. Who will it be? It's all up to you - if you don't like the results, vote in the next rounds!

Let's start with Group 1. Bettis, Charles, JD, Julia, Kimberly, Meosha, Patrick, and Trenyce, will you all please come onstage?

J.D. Adams, you sang All Is Fair In Love. J.D.......you are not in the top 3.

Meosha Denton, you sang How Do I Live?. Meosha, you...................did not get enough votes to make the top 3.

Trenyce, you sang That’s Just Love Sneaking Up On You. Trenyce, tonight...............................you are in the top 3!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Bettis Richardson, you sang Thank You. Bettis.....unfortunately.....you are not in the top 3 tonight.

Julia DeMato, you sang Son Of A Preacher Man. Julia......you are in the top 3!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Patrick Fortson, you sang Unbreak My Heart. Patrick.........you have not made the top 3.

This leaves us with Charles Grigsby and Kimberly Caldwell One has made the top 3. Kimberly, you sang Come To My Window. Charles, you sang Overjoyed. Kimberly............you may join Julia and Trenyce in the top 3!

Three ladies - Julia, Trenyce, and Kimberly. Only two will make this top 12 now, and the other may have another chance in wildcard. The first woman to make the top 12 is..................................................

KIMBERLY CALDWELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Between Julia DeMato and Trenyce, one will advance. That lucky lady is...........................

JULIA DeMATO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Next, Group 2 will hear their results!

Bella_KitKat · 09-10-2005, 01:43 PM

Out of group 1, Kimberly Caldwell and Julia DeMato have advanced to the top 12. Who will join them? Let's find out!

Group 2, please join me onstage.

Hadas, you sang You Light Up My Life. Hadas, you.............have not made top 3 tonight.

Jennifer Fuentes, you sang I Wanna Dance With Somebody. Jennifer, you have......not recieved enough votes to make top 3.

Kimberley Locke, you sang Somewhere Over The Rainbow. Kimberley, tonight you.......are in the top 3!

Jacob John, you sang Anytime. Jacob, you are............not in the top 3 tonight.

Candice Coleman, you sang Piece Of My Heart. Candice, you.......have made the top 3!

Rebecca Bond, you sang Rapture. Rebecca, you.......did not make top 3.

We are down to Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard. Clay, you sang Open Arms. Ruben, you sang Superstar. The man in the top 3 tonight is..........Clay Aiken. Please join Kimberley and Candice.

Clay, Kimberley, and Candice. However, only two will make the top 12. And the first one to go on is.........................

KIMBERELY LOCKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Between Clay and Candice, the one to advance will be........................

CLAY AIKEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Next time, Group 3 will hear the results.

Bella_KitKat · 09-10-2005, 01:53 PM

Kimberley and Clay were the winners of last round, but tonight it is Group 3's turn. Who have you chosen to move on? Let's find out!

Group 3, please join me onstage.

Jordan Segundo, you sang For Your Love. Jordan, I'm sorry to say.......you did not make top 3 tonight.

Samantha Cohen, you sang Something He Can Feel. However.......you did not make the top 3.

Kimberly Kelsey, you sang It’s All Coming Back To Me Now. Kimberly......you have made the top 3!!!!!!!

Equoia Coleman, you sang Memories. You......did not make top 3.

Rickey Smith, you sang One Last Cry. You......got enough votes to make the top 3!

George Trice, you sang Unchained Melody. You.....did not make top 3.

Two contestants are left: Louis Gazarra and Vanessa Olivarez. Louis, you sang How Am I Supposed To Live Without You?. Vanessa, you sang Out Here On My Own. The one making the top 3 tonight is...........Vanessa Olivarez. Go join Rickey and Kimberly.

Rickey, Kimberly, and Vanessa. Two will advance, and one will not. One that will move ion to the top 12 is................

VANESSA OLIVAREZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

We are down to Rickey and Kimberly. Rickey.................

there is a spot for you.....................

in the top 12!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Next time, the final group hears their results.

Bella_KitKat · 09-10-2005, 02:02 PM

FGrom Group 3, Rickey and Vanessa made the top 12. Now, however, it is Group 4's turn to hear their results.

Please join me onstage.

Patrick Lake, you sang When I See You Smile. You...........are not in the top 3 this time.

Nasheka Siddal, you sang Open My Heart .. I'm sorry that.............you are not in the top 3.

Ashley Hartman, you sang Touch Me In The Morning. Ashley.....you are in the top 3!

Sylvia Chilbiliti, you sang Didn’t We Almost Have It All?. You are..........not in the top 3.

Chip Days, you sang Song For You. You are.........................in the top 3!

Juanita Barber, you sang What About The Children? You are.......................not in the top 3.

Leaving us with Corey Clark and Joshua Gracin. Corey, you sang Foolish Heart. Joshua, you sang I’ll Be. Josh......you may join Chip and Ashley in the top 3.

Joshua, Ashley, and Chip. One of these may have another chance in wilcards, and the other two move on right now. One person making top 12 now is................................

JOSHUA GRACIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Between Ashley and Chip, the one advancing is..........................

ASHLEY HARTMAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Bella_KitKat · 09-10-2005, 02:13 PM

Singing for us tonight are 9 hopeful contestants who hope to make it into the competition as a wilcard.

Wilcards

Aliceyn Cooney – Angel
Carmen Rasmusen – Can’t Fight The Moonlight
Charles Grigsby – Ribbon In The Sky
Chip Days – Rock With You
Corey Clark – Heaven
Janine Falsone – We Belong
Rueben Studdard – For All We Know
Samantha Cohen – A Real Fine Place To Start
Trenyce – Let’s Stay Together

Attention! DO NOT rank these. Simply PM to me who you believe would be Randy's choice, Paula's choice, Simon's choice, and America's choice. The top 4 vote-getters will move on.

David · 09-15-2005, 08:46 PM

Yaaaay Season 2.

Bella_KitKat · 09-16-2005, 06:23 PM

not many people are voting....this may get cancelled.

David · 09-16-2005, 08:54 PM

^aww.

it's probably because school is starting. this board isn't getting much action in general either. either that or maybe people cant remember ai2 well.

EmoJoe · 09-16-2005, 10:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by David

^aww.

it's probably because school is starting. this board isn't getting much action in general either. either that or maybe people cant remember ai2 well.

You should do what you did for the AI4 do over (post it on IDF)

But yeah, this board isnt really active around this time, it starts to heat up around December-January when the new seasons comes closer.

Bella_KitKat · 09-16-2005, 10:37 PM

I did - maybe I'll redo it around Christmas break.

David, can you close this?

David · 09-17-2005, 11:08 AM

^Sure

09-03-2005, 06:20 PM	#1
Bella_KitKat Checotah Princess Senior Member Join Date: Apr 26, 2003 Posts: 1,396	American Idol 2 Do Over hey y'all..again. Since the season 4 redo was such a smash hit - LOL I'm a dork - I thought I'd try my luck again. In all seriousness, I'm really really glad you liked season 4 redo. Makes me feel loved. So, season 2 was arguably the most controversial win. Let's do the year again, shall we? Here's your chance to make it right. Will Ruben win again? Will Clay pull it out? And what about Carmen, Josh, and Corey Clark? You decide!! Like before, whoever got voted off the previous week, that song will go to another contestant. Unless, of course, the song doesn't mesh with the person's personality - then I'll do my best to pick one that will. okay, here we go with another season. Group 1 Bettis Richardson – Thank You Charles Grigsby - Overjoyed J.D. Adams – All Is Fair In Love Julia DeMato – Son Of A Preacher Man Kimberly Caldwell – Come To My Window Meosha Denton – How Do I Live? Patrick Fortson – Unbreak My Heart Trenyce – That’s Just Love Sneaking Up On You Group 2 Clay Aiken – Open Arms Candice Coleman – Piece Of My Heart Hadas – You Light Up My Life Jacob John – Anytime Jennifer Fuentes – I Wanna Dance With Somebody Kimberley Locke – Somewhere Over The Rainbow Rebecca Bond – Rapture Rueben Studdard – Superstar Group 3 Equoia Coleman – Memories George Trice – Unchained Melody Jordan Segundo – For Your Love Kimberly Kelsey – It’s All Coming Back To Me Now Louis Gazarra – How Am I Supposed To Live Without You? Rickey Smith – One Last Cry Samantha Cohen – Something He Can Feel Vanessa Olivarez – Out Here On My Own Group 4 Ashley Hartman – Touch Me In The Morning Chip Days – Song For You Corey Clark – Foolish Heart Joshua Gracin – I’ll Be Juanita Barber – What About The Children? Nasheka Siddal – Open My Heart Patrick Lake – When I See You Smile Sylvia Chilbiliti – Didn’t We Almost Have It All? Rank the performances in order - most favorite to least favorite. To make things easier on me, would you please just write the names and put + 8 or whatever - your # 1 gets 8 pts. Oh...please PM. Just like before. I will post results for all 4 rounds at the same time. Thanks! (David will you sticky this?)
	Last edited by Bella_KitKat; 09-03-2005 at 08:45 PM.

09-03-2005, 11:48 PM	#2
Tibbs Aww! Frequent Poster Join Date: Dec 28, 2004 Location: --Stranded on the other side of the island Posts: 380	I voted
	__________________ Skipper: Gilligan, why don't you stop that. You don't know anything about space. Gilligan: I know one thing about it. You take up more of it than I do. Skipper: (Talking about Gilligan) I don't dislike him. I mean, it's just that I'd like to kill him every now and then. Gilligan: Mrs. Howell, I might blow up. Lovey: Oh, don't you dare get angry with me! Tibby

09-04-2005, 09:11 AM	#3
David mcphee. Forum Superstar Join Date: Jan 30, 2003 Location: jacksonville, FL. Posts: 28,115	Voted
	__________________ v. 39 - katharine and chris elliott, you rock.

09-05-2005, 05:52 PM	#4
EmoJoe Cool cool cool Forum Addict Join Date: Apr 23, 2004 Location: New Jersey Posts: 71,478	I think ill vote once we get to the finals, I know the finalists more than the semi-finalists.
	__________________ "I know the difference between TV and reality, Jeff. TV has structure, it makes sense, there are likable leading men. In real life, we have this. We have you." - Abed Nadir, Community www.sitcomsarestupid.blogspot.com

09-10-2005, 02:13 PM	#9
Bella_KitKat Checotah Princess Senior Member Join Date: Apr 26, 2003 Posts: 1,396	Singing for us tonight are 9 hopeful contestants who hope to make it into the competition as a wilcard. Wilcards Aliceyn Cooney – Angel Carmen Rasmusen – Can’t Fight The Moonlight Charles Grigsby – Ribbon In The Sky Chip Days – Rock With You Corey Clark – Heaven Janine Falsone – We Belong Rueben Studdard – For All We Know Samantha Cohen – A Real Fine Place To Start Trenyce – Let’s Stay Together Attention! DO NOT rank these. Simply PM to me who you believe would be Randy's choice, Paula's choice, Simon's choice, and America's choice. The top 4 vote-getters will move on.
	Last edited by Bella_KitKat; 09-10-2005 at 04:31 PM.

09-10-2005, 01:32 PM	#5
Bella_KitKat Checotah Princess Senior Member Join Date: Apr 26, 2003 Posts: 1,396	All right, America, what have you done? Here we find out those lucky contestants who have made it to the top 12. Who will it be? It's all up to you - if you don't like the results, vote in the next rounds! Let's start with Group 1. Bettis, Charles, JD, Julia, Kimberly, Meosha, Patrick, and Trenyce, will you all please come onstage? J.D. Adams, you sang All Is Fair In Love. J.D.......you are not in the top 3. Meosha Denton, you sang How Do I Live?. Meosha, you...................did not get enough votes to make the top 3. Trenyce, you sang That’s Just Love Sneaking Up On You. Trenyce, tonight...............................you are in the top 3!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Bettis Richardson, you sang Thank You. Bettis.....unfortunately.....you are not in the top 3 tonight. Julia DeMato, you sang Son Of A Preacher Man. Julia......you are in the top 3!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Patrick Fortson, you sang Unbreak My Heart. Patrick.........you have not made the top 3. This leaves us with Charles Grigsby and Kimberly Caldwell One has made the top 3. Kimberly, you sang Come To My Window. Charles, you sang Overjoyed. Kimberly............you may join Julia and Trenyce in the top 3! Three ladies - Julia, Trenyce, and Kimberly. Only two will make this top 12 now, and the other may have another chance in wildcard. The first woman to make the top 12 is.................................................. KIMBERLY CALDWELL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Between Julia DeMato and Trenyce, one will advance. That lucky lady is........................... JULIA DeMATO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Next, Group 2 will hear their results!

09-10-2005, 01:43 PM	#6
Bella_KitKat Checotah Princess Senior Member Join Date: Apr 26, 2003 Posts: 1,396	Out of group 1, Kimberly Caldwell and Julia DeMato have advanced to the top 12. Who will join them? Let's find out! Group 2, please join me onstage. Hadas, you sang You Light Up My Life. Hadas, you.............have not made top 3 tonight. Jennifer Fuentes, you sang I Wanna Dance With Somebody. Jennifer, you have......not recieved enough votes to make top 3. Kimberley Locke, you sang Somewhere Over The Rainbow. Kimberley, tonight you.......are in the top 3! Jacob John, you sang Anytime. Jacob, you are............not in the top 3 tonight. Candice Coleman, you sang Piece Of My Heart. Candice, you.......have made the top 3! Rebecca Bond, you sang Rapture. Rebecca, you.......did not make top 3. We are down to Clay Aiken and Ruben Studdard. Clay, you sang Open Arms. Ruben, you sang Superstar. The man in the top 3 tonight is..........Clay Aiken. Please join Kimberley and Candice. Clay, Kimberley, and Candice. However, only two will make the top 12. And the first one to go on is......................... KIMBERELY LOCKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Between Clay and Candice, the one to advance will be........................ CLAY AIKEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Next time, Group 3 will hear the results.

09-10-2005, 01:53 PM	#7
Bella_KitKat Checotah Princess Senior Member Join Date: Apr 26, 2003 Posts: 1,396	Kimberley and Clay were the winners of last round, but tonight it is Group 3's turn. Who have you chosen to move on? Let's find out! Group 3, please join me onstage. Jordan Segundo, you sang For Your Love. Jordan, I'm sorry to say.......you did not make top 3 tonight. Samantha Cohen, you sang Something He Can Feel. However.......you did not make the top 3. Kimberly Kelsey, you sang It’s All Coming Back To Me Now. Kimberly......you have made the top 3!!!!!!! Equoia Coleman, you sang Memories. You......did not make top 3. Rickey Smith, you sang One Last Cry. You......got enough votes to make the top 3! George Trice, you sang Unchained Melody. You.....did not make top 3. Two contestants are left: Louis Gazarra and Vanessa Olivarez. Louis, you sang How Am I Supposed To Live Without You?. Vanessa, you sang Out Here On My Own. The one making the top 3 tonight is...........Vanessa Olivarez. Go join Rickey and Kimberly. Rickey, Kimberly, and Vanessa. Two will advance, and one will not. One that will move ion to the top 12 is................ VANESSA OLIVAREZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! We are down to Rickey and Kimberly. Rickey................. there is a spot for you..................... in the top 12!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Next time, the final group hears their results.

09-10-2005, 02:02 PM	#8
Bella_KitKat Checotah Princess Senior Member Join Date: Apr 26, 2003 Posts: 1,396	FGrom Group 3, Rickey and Vanessa made the top 12. Now, however, it is Group 4's turn to hear their results. Please join me onstage. Patrick Lake, you sang When I See You Smile. You...........are not in the top 3 this time. Nasheka Siddal, you sang Open My Heart .. I'm sorry that.............you are not in the top 3. Ashley Hartman, you sang Touch Me In The Morning. Ashley.....you are in the top 3! Sylvia Chilbiliti, you sang Didn’t We Almost Have It All?. You are..........not in the top 3. Chip Days, you sang Song For You. You are.........................in the top 3! Juanita Barber, you sang What About The Children? You are.......................not in the top 3. Leaving us with Corey Clark and Joshua Gracin. Corey, you sang Foolish Heart. Joshua, you sang I’ll Be. Josh......you may join Chip and Ashley in the top 3. Joshua, Ashley, and Chip. One of these may have another chance in wilcards, and the other two move on right now. One person making top 12 now is................................ JOSHUA GRACIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Between Ashley and Chip, the one advancing is.......................... ASHLEY HARTMAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

09-15-2005, 08:46 PM	#10
David mcphee. Forum Superstar Join Date: Jan 30, 2003 Location: jacksonville, FL. Posts: 28,115	Yaaaay Season 2.

09-16-2005, 06:23 PM	#11
Bella_KitKat Checotah Princess Senior Member Join Date: Apr 26, 2003 Posts: 1,396	not many people are voting....this may get cancelled.

09-16-2005, 08:54 PM	#12
David mcphee. Forum Superstar Join Date: Jan 30, 2003 Location: jacksonville, FL. Posts: 28,115	^aww. it's probably because school is starting. this board isn't getting much action in general either. either that or maybe people cant remember ai2 well.

09-16-2005, 10:37 PM	#14
Bella_KitKat Checotah Princess Senior Member Join Date: Apr 26, 2003 Posts: 1,396	I did - maybe I'll redo it around Christmas break. David, can you close this?

09-17-2005, 11:08 AM	#15
David mcphee. Forum Superstar Join Date: Jan 30, 2003 Location: jacksonville, FL. Posts: 28,115	^Sure