Critiquing This Season

[Chain Gang Member]

I liked that they had Jake come back and made him and Peyton a couple

Also I liked that they got rid of the cocky Felix when Ana or Anna found out that he was the one who spray painted "Dyke" on Peyton's locker.To tell you the truth,like Brooke,Felix had me fooled that he was a changed guy in a way

I didn't like that they had Haley choose music over Nate and making him believe that she doesn't care about him anymore.I think they did that to make Nate become a jerk and make people wonder if Haley will ever come back to Nate so that they'll keep watching.

I didn't like in the end that Nicky found Jenny and took her away from Jake so that when he got out of jail that he would have to leave Peyton behind to go get Jenny back

But I did like that in the end that Haley came back to Nate

It was funny that after Lucas had that dream about Brooke that she found him taking a cold shower and getting disgusted

I think where they had Dan being poisoned and they had the person light his office on fire to have people watch the season premire of One Tree Hill in the fall(I think Deb did it because it was the pills turned into powder in the drink that she took out from the plant and also the hand in the black glove looked like a woman's hand)

So in conclusion,It was a great season

[MsOrange]

where did the Starlet chick go?

[WilCap]

Great season overall... well, episodes I saw. I missed alot durin the year. But from what I have seen, better than Season 1 and I cant wait for the premier

[Wings#1ShowPeriod]

I bought Season 2 yesterday, and watched the Season Finale today and it was simply amazing. The whole Lucas and Brooke storyline... Peyton finds out it was her mom stalking her.. Haley coming back to Nathan... and of course Dan getting posioned and someone seting the place on fire. I liked how after Nathan accident that him and his mom got closer.. Debs is HOT and tough so hopefully in Season 3.. she has a great year. The whole Nathan and Lucas not on speaking terms anymore eventually had to happen.. overall a great season. I thought Season 1 was tough to beat... but Season 2 defiently did it..

[jmoney48]

who killed dan?!?!

Deb – At the river court she tells Nathan that they are getting out, and “Dan can BURN in hell for all I care.” She said the same thing when Nathan came home with the rest of his things from his apartment. She said “I’ve been alone here all night.” She had some pills stowed away, but they didn’t show what she did with them. Could those pills be the white dust that Dan found on the rim of the bottle? Alibi: She was home all alone the night Dan was murdered.

Nathan – When he came home, he was confident that they (he and his mother) were going to get out. When asked where he had been, he said “I had to go do something.” Nathan keeps telling Lucas to stop digging even though he knows he is trying to help. Does Nathan have his own plan to get rid of Dan and doesn’t want anyone else to get hurt? He has always been the bad boy of the story.

Keith (Dan’s brother) – He has a good alibi, he was leaving town because of the break up between he and Emily aka Jewels. Dan ruined what seemed to be a happy marriage from the start by hiring Jewels to make Keith fall in love with her.

Whitey – He might be the one who dun it. He cares a lot about Nathan, and has seen how much he has grown outside of the Scott house (without Dan), maybe that’s enough… but there is more. Dan threatened to take away his job, the one thing that whitey has going for him (he getting old and all doesn’t really help). They also talked about “playing with fire” and how Dan was going to get “burned.”

Lucas – Could he really be the “killer?” Right now he is the tragic hero of the story, dying from HCM, losing Nathan, losing in the war against Dan and not getting Brooke to tell him if she wants him back (which means no practically). Dan is cutting off his heart medication, so does lucas have anything to lose? I mean, at least the ones he cares about will be safe from Dan Scott. Tragic hero turned villain?

Andy – He is rich, he could have hired a hit man to do the job. Andy lost his teaching job because of Dan and said that Karma would come back to get him. He left early for new Zealand, without telling Karen, he says “I think its best for mom, and for you.” For you??? What does that mean? When Karen calls the hotel, she finds out that he hasn’t checked in yet, where is he? Motive: not being able to come back to the states and Karen because of Dan.

[Chain Gang Member]

You have to take Nathan off your suspect list because he was home when Haley came back.So it's not him.It'll probably be someone that you wouldn't expect

Karen-Same reason for why Andy is a suspect

[jmoney48]

it showed Dan getting killed, then it showed Nathan entering the house, and deb was there.
oh nathan im so glad ur home, ive been here alone all night
i had something to do
we're getting out yada
yada
yada


then halley came

[Chain Gang Member]

Oh,I forgot

[Chain Gang Member]

This reminds me of The Simpsons episode "Who SHot Mr.Burns?" I have to say that had to be someone that you wouldn't suspect.Like in the episode,viewers suspected people that had it in for Mr.Burns.Smithers,Moe,Skinner,Willie,etc.No one ever suspected Maggie since she was a baby.So who would be the one who you would least suspect to do something so eeeevil?

[jmoney48]

haley? lol.... no....... peyton... brooke...jake.... peytons mom.... JENNY!

[Chain Gang Member]

Jenny?I wouldn't believe a baby would do that,especially when her mom steals her away from Jake

[DukeDevils9192]

Originally Posted by Chain Gang Member

This reminds me of The Simpsons episode "Who SHot Mr.Burns?" I have to say that had to be someone that you wouldn't suspect.Like in the episode,viewers suspected people that had it in for Mr.Burns.Smithers,Moe,Skinner,Willie,etc.No one ever suspected Maggie since she was a baby.So who would be the one who you would least suspect to do something so eeeevil?

It should remind you of that episode because that was lifted from the most famous cliffhanger ever: Who Shot JR? from Dallas.

When the finale was upon us last spring, Mark Schwan gave interviews where he said that the finale was going to be of the "Who Shot JR?" type. While Turkish parliament probably won't suspend a meeting to go watch the season premiere like they did for Dallas, the situations are incredibly similar so it's good that you thought of the Simpsons episode.

[jmoney48]

have u seen the new preview? they make it seem like lucas killed dan

[Wings#1ShowPeriod]

yea in the preview, Lucas is talking to Peyton when he says ," I've done something tonight, I'm not proud of" I thought he was talking about Dan.. but after thinking about it some I doubt he did that... 10 Days, 10 Days away until Season 3.. One Tree Hill, 26 episodes... fewer repeats, oh.. Im loving it

[jmoney48]

yeah he could have been talking about anything.... maybe ruining his relationship with nathan, or BROOKE .... or killing dan... i wonder how they are going to keep lucas in the story when he is supposed to be dieing...