AI4 - Rank the Final 10

[David]

Spoiler, obviously.

And yeah, I know I post this a lot, but it's interesting to see how they fall/rise on our personal "charts" week after week.

Last week my personal ranking was:

1. Carrie Underwood
2. Anthony Fedorov
3. Mikalah Gordon
4. Jessica Sierra
5. Anwar Robinson
6. Bo Bice
7. Nadia Turner
8. Nikko Smith
9. Constantine Maroulis
10. Vonzell Solomon
11. Scott Savol

My personal ranking this week

1. Carrie Underwood
(Last week #1) - Still my favorite, she did amazing. I hope she can show more star quality however, because she has the voice, without a doubt.

2. Jessica Sierra
(Last week #4) - Man, this girl is getting good. I'm glad she's attracting fans. She has a really nice voice, and I can't wait for next week's performance. I hope she doesn't get Amy-ed like a lot of people have been saying

3. Bo Bice
(Last week #6) - I'm surprised I'm liking Bo this much, but he has great performance skills, and though I'm not into his genre of music, I still enjoy watching him. He's a good person too. Or, atleast he displays himself as a good person.

4. Anthony Fedorov
(Last week #2) - I swear, if this boy does an average job again next week, he's going to continue to drop, because these past 2 weeks have been disappointing - and bland, but he does have a remarkable voice. I still remember his semifinal performances, and he does a good job in the group songs.

5. Nadia Turner
(Last week #7) - It's weird because her recent performance has gotten bad reviews everywhere, but I didn't think it was bad at all. I actually liked it. And she continues to climb on my ranking. Much to my surprise.

6. Anwar Robinson
(Last week #5) - He's pretty much tied with Nadia. He has a great voice, but... may be just my weird taste, but I don't like it when a singer is too polished and too predictable, like LaToya and Tamyra. However, he does have an extraordinary voice. And like Nadia, though many didn't like it, I enjoyed his performance this week.

7. Nikko Smith
(Last week #8) - I'm confused by him, because at times I think he's the best guy, but when I'm ranking him, he's not even close. He delivered amazing performances thus far, but to me, he's forgetable. Good vocalist, but he's very old-fashioned, which can hurt him.

8. Vonzell Solomon
(Last week #10) - She got way better this week, and I'm glad she cracked out of being just good. She's an amazing vocalist, but I like 8 others better

9. Constantine Maroulis
(Last week #9) - Yeah, he's 9th, but this year, every freaking person is great, so even though he's low on the list, he's still good in my opinion. Like Bo, I'm not into the genre, but he's fun to watch, and he's not as... aahhhh. as he was in the semi-finals. His past 2 performances have been nothing but impressive.

10. Scott Savol
(Last week #11) - I will say this. This week, I realized how good of a voice he has. His octave changes are, most of the time, flawless, but... if we had the choice to vote off someone, it would be him. He's just not as exciting as the rest. I'm glad he grew to me though.

--------
What I think will happen (this is.. really hard):

Last week it was:

1. Carrie Underwood
2. Bo Bice
3. Anwar Robinson
4. Nadia Turner
5. Anthony Fedorov
6. Constantine Maroulis
7. Jessica Sierra
8. Mikalah Gordon
9. Nikko Smith
10. Scott Savol
11. Vonzell Solomon

And well, I was obviously off on the Mikalah prediction So let's see. This is going to be hard -- this is the hardest prediction year.

1. Carrie Underwood
(Last week - #1) - I still think she has what it takes to take her to the top. And with all the Simon pimping, she's bound to make it somewhere in the industry.

2. Bo Bice
(Last week - #2) - Another choice for the finale for me. He always delivers star quality performances, and I think he's what America wants to see.

3. Anwar Robinson
(Last week - #3) - Having such a strong voice and appeal, I have a feeling his "instrument" will take him far, but he lacks the star quality needed for the final 2.

4. Nadia Turner
(Last week - #4) - Having now been in the bottom 3, I think she'll be this year's LaToya and Tamyra.

5. Jessica Sierra
(Last week - #7) - I'm going out on a limb predicting that Jessica will go this far, but she's always delivered strong performances, and is gaining fans every week (including Simon), so at this rate, she's going far.

6. Constantine Maroulis
(Last week - #6) - He has a very dedicated fanbase, and the judges seem to love him too, but for some odd reason, I can't seem him in the top 5.

7. Anthony Fedorov
(Last week - #5) - Yeah, disappointing, but until he starts improving, I have him as 7th. He's been paling in comparison, and even getting forgettable. I wanted to see him in the top 3, but at the rate he's going, he'll be far from that. Hopefully he can get better and go far!! He has a great voice (when he picks the right song)

8. Nikko Smith
(Last week - #9) - Like I've said before, I don't think she's going to go that far either, keeping in mind that America has already eliminated him.

9. Vonzell Solomon
(Last week - #11) - She's great, but I just can't see her going that far.

10. Scott Savol
(Last week - #10) - You know what, I know it's not going to happen, but I had no idea who to put as the bottom contestant. I wanted to put a guy, because I just can't see 3 girls getting eliminated consecutively.

Wow, that was hard. I'm gonna be sad to see every single person leave, but that's American Idol for ya.

[-*Forever*-]

1. Jessica Sierra
2. Constantine Maroulis
3. Carrie Underwood
4. Nadia Turner

Do the rest matter?

[EmoJoe]

Wow...these have changed

My ranking:

1. Carrie Underwood (yep, I finally decided that I like her better than Anthony)
2. Anthony Fedorov- i still like him, he has a strong voice
3. Bo Bice- his past two performances werent GREAT in my opinion but i still think he has a strong voice
4. Constentine Maroluis- he has a pretty good voice and his performances are memorable
5. Jessica Sierra- good voice but she doesnt amaze me
6. Anwar Robinson- see jessica
7. Nikko Smith- he has an ok voice but his performances arent anything special IMO
8. Vonzell Solomon- she has improved, but i still dont think shes that good
9. Nadia Turner- for some reason i just dont like Nadia. i dont know why
10. Scott Savol- he annoys me. IMO his voice isnt great and his performances arent good. he needs to go soon

My predictions:

1. Carrie Underwood- she has enough star quality to win and she has a great voice, not to mention a pretty big fanbase
2. Bo Bice- for the most part his performances are memorable and he has a good voice, he'll go far but i dont think he'll win
3. Anwar Robinson- the judges love him and his performances are good. he'll make it far, but he doesnt have that quality to win in him
4. Nadia Turner- well if she continues to do performances like this week's she might be gone soon enough, but i don't think that will happen, as much as i want it to, and i think she'll go far
5. Anthony Fedorov- besides his last performances, his latest performances havent been excellent. he has a good voice but he needs to do something really really good for him to get further than this
6. Constentine Maroluis- he has a HUGE HUGE fanbase, but for some reason, people with huge huge huge fanbases seem to have bad luck
7. Jessica Sierra- sh's definitley gotten more fans since the beginning of the top 24 but i cant see her making it that far
8. Nikko Smith- like David said, techanically he was already voted off. plus, his performances arent anything special
9. Vonzell
10. Scott

The last 2 just dont have thw quality to go far

[Miss Golden]

10. Scott
9. Anthony
8. Nadia
7. Nikko
6. Anwar
5. Jessica
4. Vonzell
3. Bo
2. Carrie

WINNER: Constantine

[¤I Love Clay Aiken¤]

1. Nikko
2. Anthony
3. Vonzell
4. Bo
5. Carrie
6. Constantine
7. Jessica
8. Scott
9. Anwar
10. Nadia

Ugh. I dont even like my list, meangya.

[vienna waits]

1. Carrie
2. Vonzell
3. Jessica
4. Nadia

I hate everyone else.

[-*Forever*-]

Originally Posted by Idol Fanatic

1. Carrie
2. Vonzell
3. Jessica
4. Nadia

I hate everyone else.

... OMG YOU LIKE JESSICA I LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[vienna waits]

Originally Posted by -*Forever*-

... OMG YOU LIKE JESSICA I LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

hehehe

[David]

Originally Posted by -*Forever*-

... OMG YOU LIKE JESSICA I LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Jessica has gained soooo many fans this past week, I love it

[EmoJoe]

Originally Posted by Miss Golden

10. Scott
9. Anthony
8. Nadia
7. Nikko
6. Anwar
5. Jessica
4. Vonzell
3. Bo
2. Carrie

WINNER: Constantine

Was that your favorites or predictions?

[AllIWantIsYourClutch]

1. Constantine
2. Jessica
3. Bo
4. Carrie
5. Scott
6. Anthony (he's growing on me)
7. Nikko
8. Vonzell
9. Nadia
10. Anwar

[Cactus Jack]

1. Anthony Federov
2. Constatine Maroulis
3. Carrie Underwood
4. Bo Bice
5. Jessica Sierra
6. Anwar Robinson
7. Nadia Turner
9. Vonzell Solomon
10. Scott Savol

[Krisalicious]

This was mine last week:
1. Constantine Maroulis
2. Anwar Robinson
3. Nikko Smith
4. Anthony Fedorov
5. Vonzell Solomon
6. Bo Bice
7. Carrie Underwood
8. Mikalah Gordon
9. Jessica Sierra
10. Nadia Turner
11. Scott Savol

And now this week:
1. Constantine Maroulis
2. Vonzell Solomon (I've finally established that she's my favorite girl in the competition)
3. Bo Bice (I can't believe how much he's growing on me...and to think, I used to hate him)
4. Jessica Sierra
5. Anthony Fedorov
6. Anwar Robinson
7. Carrie Underwood
8. Nikko Smith (actually I like those last 4 about the same, idk can't decide)
9. Nadia Turner
10. Scott Savol

[RustyShackleford]

1. Anthony Federov
2. Carrie Underwood
3. Constantine Maroulis
4. Bo Bice
5. Nadia Turner
6. Jessica Sierra
7. Nikko Smith
8. Vonzell Solomon
9. Anwar Robinson
10. Scott Savol

[Janet McFarland]

1. Carrie Underwood
2. Constantine Maroulis
3. Jessica Sierra
4. Bo Bice
5. Vonzell Solomon
6. Scott Savol
7. Anwar Robinson
8. Anthony Federov
9. Nikko Smith
10. Nadia Turner