The Best and Worst episodes this Season?!?! - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

*GoodMorningCalgary* · 05-07-2004, 07:08 PM

Post your Top 5 and your bottom 5 episodes here!

TOP 5

5. "My Fifteen Seconds"

Probably one of the only Tara Reid episodes that I really liked. I loved J.D's chicken dance and the whole Carnival scene

4. "My Porcelain God"

The better of the Michael J. Fox episodes, I didn't really like the first one. But this one was one of the best. It even has one of my favorite quotes from Dr. Cox too...."AIR, goes in the Lungs!"

3. "My Best Friend's Wedding"

Such a sweet episode. I was looking forward to this episode since Turk proposed to Carla. It was also great to see Ted's band this season. My only complaint was that this episode Should have been supersized or Hour long instead of regular length.

2. "My Butterfly"

I loved this one was because it was unique and different. One of the best this season.......plus J.D's impression of Cox was priceless

1. "My American Girl"

The Music, the Writing, the everything was just perfect. One of the best ones EVER!

Bottom 5

5. "My Friend the Doctor"

Blah....except for the Shaft thing, nothing really stands out about this episode. I almost forgot it even existed. Plus the Janitors storyline was the worst one by far.

4. "My Tormented Mentor"

Dr. Cox was just unbarebale to watch in this episode. I know he was upset because of Ben, But I hate that Raspiness in his voice that drives me crazy. There was also WAAAYYY too much Todd in this episode.

3. "My Fault"

Hate the whole J.D, Sean and Elliot thing. so this episode majorly sucked. Plus him turning Elliot down after us listening to him Bitching and Whining for a friggin year really pissed me off

2. "My Choosiest Choice of all"

Same as above....what makes it worse though is that Stupid Polyphonic Spree band. I can't stand that song

1. "His Story II"

This is the episode that Started all that Sean, Elliot and J.D bull****. I use to love Elliot. she was my favorite Character But her cheating on Sean like that was so out of character for her. I have lost any Sympathy or anything for her. same goes with J.D. I wish they could just redo the last 3 episodes.

Overall: This season had alotta ups and Downs.....the episodes were really good or really bad. I miss those Crazy sound effects they use to use. and I wish we could see more of J.D's Daydreams. I hope next season will be better

Season 3: 6/10
Season 2: 8/10
Season 1: 10/10

*GoodMorningCalgary* · 05-11-2004, 05:24 PM

Come on people! tell me what you think.....don't ignore me

bozasm · 05-19-2004, 01:07 AM

My Fifteen seconds = best Cox line

Jordan: I asked you to do me a favor invovling my mother. What was it?
Cox: (long pause) Well, I can only hope that it had something to do with hiring people to kill her...(crosses fingers)

maybe its funnier cuz of his expression...

sk8rboiiii · 05-19-2004, 05:34 PM

I am still looking for one of the episodes that I havent seen, and you guys said it wasn't very good, hence it might make it on my 5 worst list, but I promise I will compile a list very soon.

evilskanevil · 05-24-2004, 08:26 PM

I loved the one where Ben died. Not cause he died, but when Brendan Fraser did the marionette thing, that was awesome! The Michael J. Fox ones were cool too.

I hate Tara Reid, so I'm not a big fan of those. The midget Janitor has to go too. Like now.

bozasm · 05-28-2004, 01:33 PM

The episode I liked the best was the one were Ben died. I watched the closing so many times, and I dl'd that song. It was really well done.

His Story 2 -- I was really excited because I really enjoyed Dr. Cox's Story episode last season. It seems like Turk played the JD character a little too often with the "look-off-to-one-side and say some random nonsense thing." I enjoyed it for that idea, but upon further inspection, it wasn't exactly a great episode, and I agree with your point on Eliot

I really think the whole JD-Eliot romance never did it for me, but I did like the "eating a pizza watching a crappy tv show" line he used.

I love randal! He's a hilarious sidekick/rival for Janitor. I saw more Janitor stuff the better (like the arrival of the janitors, the janitors locking up cox in the morgue, and of course, more janitor/jd&turk stuff like the twin brother thing).

Tara Reid ones were really good right at the start, when they just showed that she's Jordan's sister. that was awesome.

I am really disliking Dr. Miller though.

05-07-2004, 07:08 PM	#1
GoodMorningCalgary Banana Hammock! Senior Member Join Date: Dec 02, 2002 Location: Sacred Heart Hospital Posts: 1,225	The Best and Worst episodes this Season?!?! Post your Top 5 and your bottom 5 episodes here! TOP 5 5. "My Fifteen Seconds" Probably one of the only Tara Reid episodes that I really liked. I loved J.D's chicken dance and the whole Carnival scene 4. "My Porcelain God" The better of the Michael J. Fox episodes, I didn't really like the first one. But this one was one of the best. It even has one of my favorite quotes from Dr. Cox too...."AIR, goes in the Lungs!" 3. "My Best Friend's Wedding" Such a sweet episode. I was looking forward to this episode since Turk proposed to Carla. It was also great to see Ted's band this season. My only complaint was that this episode Should have been supersized or Hour long instead of regular length. 2. "My Butterfly" I loved this one was because it was unique and different. One of the best this season.......plus J.D's impression of Cox was priceless 1. "My American Girl" The Music, the Writing, the everything was just perfect. One of the best ones EVER! Bottom 5 5. "My Friend the Doctor" Blah....except for the Shaft thing, nothing really stands out about this episode. I almost forgot it even existed. Plus the Janitors storyline was the worst one by far. 4. "My Tormented Mentor" Dr. Cox was just unbarebale to watch in this episode. I know he was upset because of Ben, But I hate that Raspiness in his voice that drives me crazy. There was also WAAAYYY too much Todd in this episode. 3. "My Fault" Hate the whole J.D, Sean and Elliot thing. so this episode majorly sucked. Plus him turning Elliot down after us listening to him Bitching and Whining for a friggin year really pissed me off 2. "My Choosiest Choice of all" Same as above....what makes it worse though is that Stupid Polyphonic Spree band. I can't stand that song 1. "His Story II" This is the episode that Started all that Sean, Elliot and J.D bull****. I use to love Elliot. she was my favorite Character But her cheating on Sean like that was so out of character for her. I have lost any Sympathy or anything for her. same goes with J.D. I wish they could just redo the last 3 episodes. Overall: This season had alotta ups and Downs.....the episodes were really good or really bad. I miss those Crazy sound effects they use to use. and I wish we could see more of J.D's Daydreams. I hope next season will be better Season 3: 6/10 Season 2: 8/10 Season 1: 10/10
	__________________ RIP JOHN RITTER 1948-2003 Watch Scrubs on NBC! Tuesdays at 9:00

05-24-2004, 08:26 PM	#5
evilskanevil Member First Time Poster Join Date: May 24, 2004 Location: MA Posts: 1	I loved the one where Ben died. Not cause he died, but when Brendan Fraser did the marionette thing, that was awesome! The Michael J. Fox ones were cool too. I hate Tara Reid, so I'm not a big fan of those. The midget Janitor has to go too. Like now.
	__________________ Music is life. Live a fun one. Listen to ska.

05-11-2004, 05:24 PM	#2
GoodMorningCalgary Banana Hammock! Senior Member Join Date: Dec 02, 2002 Location: Sacred Heart Hospital Posts: 1,225	Come on people! tell me what you think.....don't ignore me

05-19-2004, 01:07 AM	#3
bozasm Member Occasional Poster Join Date: Apr 10, 2004 Posts: 23	My Fifteen seconds = best Cox line Jordan: I asked you to do me a favor invovling my mother. What was it? Cox: (long pause) Well, I can only hope that it had something to do with hiring people to kill her...(crosses fingers) maybe its funnier cuz of his expression...

05-19-2004, 05:34 PM	#4
sk8rboiiii Member Occasional Poster Join Date: Feb 24, 2004 Location: Toronto Posts: 27	I am still looking for one of the episodes that I havent seen, and you guys said it wasn't very good, hence it might make it on my 5 worst list, but I promise I will compile a list very soon.

05-28-2004, 01:33 PM	#6
bozasm Member Occasional Poster Join Date: Apr 10, 2004 Posts: 23	The episode I liked the best was the one were Ben died. I watched the closing so many times, and I dl'd that song. It was really well done. His Story 2 -- I was really excited because I really enjoyed Dr. Cox's Story episode last season. It seems like Turk played the JD character a little too often with the "look-off-to-one-side and say some random nonsense thing." I enjoyed it for that idea, but upon further inspection, it wasn't exactly a great episode, and I agree with your point on Eliot I really think the whole JD-Eliot romance never did it for me, but I did like the "eating a pizza watching a crappy tv show" line he used. I love randal! He's a hilarious sidekick/rival for Janitor. I saw more Janitor stuff the better (like the arrival of the janitors, the janitors locking up cox in the morgue, and of course, more janitor/jd&turk stuff like the twin brother thing). Tara Reid ones were really good right at the start, when they just showed that she's Jordan's sister. that was awesome. I am really disliking Dr. Miller though.