American Idol: Same Song, Different Contestant - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

Krisalicious · 04-19-2004, 11:10 PM

During the three seasons of American Idol, people from different seasons or sometimes even the same season have performed the same song, so I'm going to start off with a few and just post which you think was better, and feel free to post some of your own too.

Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/ George Huff (AI3)

My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/ Diana DeGarmo (AI3)

To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/ Clay Aiken (AI2)

Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2) / Jennifer Hudson (AI3)

Krisalicious · 04-19-2004, 11:11 PM

Oh yeah btw, out of the ones I just posted, this is who I prefer for each:

Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard

My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke

To Love Somebody- Clay Aiken

Heatwave- Jennifer Hudson

vienna waits · 04-19-2004, 11:26 PM

EVERY song that Jasmine has sang this season has been sung on AI before.. this week will be the first when she isn't doing something from a former Idol.

Jasmine Songs...

Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) [didnt hear angela's]
Inseparabe - Kim Locke (season 2) [prefer KLo while it was Jas at her best]
Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) [both bad!]
You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1) [kelly]
Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2) [clay, of cource]
When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) [didn't hear Jim's but she couldn't have been worse than him]

some others...

I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia [KLo]
Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya [La Toya!]
Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson [Kim C... my ears are still getting over Lisa's horredous version]
Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams [Amy]
I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H. [Trenyce]
Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff [George]

¤I Love Clay Aiken¤ · 04-20-2004, 03:13 PM

MY PREFERENCES:

[b]Jasmine songs:
Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) [didnt hear angela's]
Inseparabe - Kim Locke (season 2)
Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) [both bad!]
You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1)
Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2)
When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) Jasmine
=
I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia
Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya
Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson
Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams
I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H.
Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff
Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/George Huff (AI3)
My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Diana DeGarmo (AI3)
To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/Clay Aiken (AI2) Theres like.. no comparison on that one.
Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Jennifer Hudson (AI3)

vienna waits · 04-20-2004, 05:21 PM

a trillion more i came up with last night:

Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman [Tamyra]
It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke [haven't heard Kelly's.. id say theyre equally great]
Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay [Clay]
Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben [Josh]
Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott [Clay]
For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille [Justin (one of the rare times i like him)]
Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille [Jeffrey]
Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille [Julia]
Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away [Corey Clark]
Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens [RJ]
Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia [Fantasia]
Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah [TRENYCE]
You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah [Vanessa]

okidokie thats all for now.

¤I Love Clay Aiken¤ · 04-20-2004, 06:36 PM

Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray (though I dont know the song -.-/Ashley Hartman
It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke
Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay
Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben
Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott
For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille
Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille
Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille
Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away.. Jeff.. who was the other one??!

No wait.. JPL -.- So yes.. JPL
Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens
Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia
Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah
You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leahp

Krisalicious · 04-22-2004, 12:46 AM

Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman [Tamyra]
It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke [haven't heard either]
Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay [CLAY]
Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben [Ruben]
Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott [Clay]
For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille [ehh...I was actually listening to Justin's earlier on my old season 1 American Idol greatest moments CD and he sings that song, but I don't really like it so..Camile]
Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille [Camile]
Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille [I haven't heard Julias, but Camile's was pretty bad...]
Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away [...JPL

]
Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens [RJ. John's was really, really boring]
Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia [I like both]
Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah [Trenyce]
You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah [Vanessa]

¤I Love Clay Aiken¤ · 04-29-2004, 01:19 PM

One Voice: Kelly, Clay & Ruben OR Diana DeGarmo

Turn The Beat Around: Carmen Rasmusen OR Diana DeGarmo

Im going with Kelly, Clay and Ruben, and then Diana for TTBA.

David · 04-29-2004, 07:03 PM

Jasmines performances
Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) JASMINE
Inseparabe - [b]Kim Locke (season 2) JASMINE
Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) JULIA
You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1) KELLY
Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2) CLAY
When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) JASMINE
=
I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia KIM
Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya LATOYA
Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson KIM
Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams TRENYCE
I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H. TRENYCE
Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff GEORGE
Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/George Huff (AI3) GEORGE
My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Diana DeGarmo (AI3) KIMBERLEY
To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/Clay Aiken (AI2) CLAY
Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Jennifer Hudson (AI3) THE GROUP SONG lol
Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman TAMYRA
It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke KELLY
Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay CLAY
Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben RUBEN
Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott CLAY
For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille JUSTIN
Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille CAMILE
Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille JULIA
Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away COREY
Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens RJ
Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia FANTASIA
Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah TRENYCE
You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah LEAH

David · 04-29-2004, 07:04 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by ¤MsConanOBrien¤
One Voice: Kelly, Clay & Ruben OR Diana DeGarmo

Turn The Beat Around: Carmen Rasmusen OR Diana DeGarmo

Im going with Kelly, Clay and Ruben, and then Diana for TTBA.

One Voice- Kelly (but Dianas was almost as good)

Turn the Beat Around- Diana DeGarmo!!!

04-19-2004, 11:10 PM	#1
Krisalicious Archie FTW! Forum Veteran Join Date: Jun 27, 2001 Location: NJ Posts: 5,775	American Idol: Same Song, Different Contestant During the three seasons of American Idol, people from different seasons or sometimes even the same season have performed the same song, so I'm going to start off with a few and just post which you think was better, and feel free to post some of your own too. Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/ George Huff (AI3) My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/ Diana DeGarmo (AI3) To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/ Clay Aiken (AI2) Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2) / Jennifer Hudson (AI3)

04-19-2004, 11:26 PM	#3
vienna waits avatars are stupid. Forum Superstar Join Date: May 18, 2001 Location: Ravenclaw Common Room Posts: 29,859	EVERY song that Jasmine has sang this season has been sung on AI before.. this week will be the first when she isn't doing something from a former Idol. Jasmine Songs... Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) [didnt hear angela's] Inseparabe - Kim Locke (season 2) [prefer KLo while it was Jas at her best] Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) [both bad!] You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1) [kelly] Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2) [clay, of cource] When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) [didn't hear Jim's but she couldn't have been worse than him] some others... I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia [KLo] Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya [La Toya!] Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson [Kim C... my ears are still getting over Lisa's horredous version] Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams [Amy] I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H. [Trenyce] Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff [George]
	__________________ Me: Did you see Dunkleman in the audience at the finale? Crystal: No! Me: Yeah, that's because he wasn't invited.

04-20-2004, 03:13 PM	#4
¤I Love Clay Aiken¤ MISS APRIL Forum Addict Join Date: Jul 19, 2001 Location: Parsonsfield ME Shaws - Screwing my way up the employment ladder! Posts: 68,780	MY PREFERENCES: [b]Jasmine songs: Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) [didnt hear angela's] Inseparabe - Kim Locke (season 2) Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) [both bad!] You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1) Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2) When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) Jasmine = I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H. Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/George Huff (AI3) My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Diana DeGarmo (AI3) To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/Clay Aiken (AI2) Theres like.. no comparison on that one. Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Jennifer Hudson (AI3)
	__________________ DAVID COOK FOR AMERICAN IDOL

04-29-2004, 07:03 PM	#9
David mcphee. Forum Superstar Join Date: Jan 30, 2003 Location: jacksonville, FL. Posts: 28,115	Jasmines performances Run to You - Angela Peel (season 1) JASMINE Inseparabe - [b]Kim Locke (season 2) JASMINE Breathe - Julia Demato (season 2) JULIA You're All I Need - Kelly Clarkson (season 1) KELLY Don't Let the Sun Go Down On Me - Clay Aiken (season 2) CLAY When I Fall In Love - Jim Verraros (season 1) JASMINE = I heard it through the grapevine - Kim Locke/Fantasia KIM Aint Going Down... - Josh Gracin/La Toya LATOYA Come to my Window - Kim Caldwell/Lisa Wilson KIM Power of Love - Trenyce/Amy Adams TRENYCE I Have Nothing - Trenyce/Leah/Jennifer H. TRENYCE Against the Odds - Corey Clark/George Huff GEORGE Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard (AI2)/George Huff (AI3) GEORGE My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Diana DeGarmo (AI3) KIMBERLEY To Love Somebody- Josh Gracin (AI2)/Clay Aiken (AI2) CLAY Heatwave- Kimberley Locke (AI2)/Jennifer Hudson (AI3) THE GROUP SONG lol Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman TAMYRA It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke KELLY Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay CLAY Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben RUBEN Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott CLAY For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille JUSTIN Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille CAMILE Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille JULIA Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away COREY Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens RJ Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia FANTASIA Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah TRENYCE You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah LEAH
	__________________ v. 39 - katharine and chris elliott, you rock.

04-19-2004, 11:11 PM	#2
Krisalicious Archie FTW! Forum Veteran Join Date: Jun 27, 2001 Location: NJ Posts: 5,775	Oh yeah btw, out of the ones I just posted, this is who I prefer for each: Ain't Too Proud to Beg- Ruben Studdard My Heart Will Go On- Kimberley Locke To Love Somebody- Clay Aiken Heatwave- Jennifer Hudson

04-20-2004, 05:21 PM	#5
vienna waits avatars are stupid. Forum Superstar Join Date: May 18, 2001 Location: Ravenclaw Common Room Posts: 29,859	a trillion more i came up with last night: Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman [Tamyra] It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke [haven't heard Kelly's.. id say theyre equally great] Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay [Clay] Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben [Josh] Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott [Clay] For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille [Justin (one of the rare times i like him)] Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille [Jeffrey] Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille [Julia] Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away [Corey Clark] Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens [RJ] Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia [Fantasia] Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah [TRENYCE] You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah [Vanessa] okidokie thats all for now.

04-20-2004, 06:36 PM	#6
¤I Love Clay Aiken¤ MISS APRIL Forum Addict Join Date: Jul 19, 2001 Location: Parsonsfield ME Shaws - Screwing my way up the employment ladder! Posts: 68,780	Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray (though I dont know the song -.-/Ashley Hartman It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away.. Jeff.. who was the other one??! No wait.. JPL -.- So yes.. JPL Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leahp

04-22-2004, 12:46 AM	#7
Krisalicious Archie FTW! Forum Veteran Join Date: Jun 27, 2001 Location: NJ Posts: 5,775	Touch Me in the Morning - Tamyra Gray/Ashley Hartman [Tamyra] It's Raining Men - Kelly/Kim Locke [haven't heard either] Don't Let the sun go down on me - Justin/Clay [CLAY] Baby I need your Lovin - Josh/Ruben [Ruben] Open Arms - Clay/Erskine Walcott [Clay] For Once in my life - Justin Guarini/Camille [ehh...I was actually listening to Justin's earlier on my old season 1 American Idol greatest moments CD and he sings that song, but I don't really like it so..Camile] Desperado - Jeffrey Dingle/Camille [Camile] Son of a Preacher Man - Julia/Camille [I haven't heard Julias, but Camile's was pretty bad...] Drift Away - Corey Clark/Drift Away [...JPL ] Lately - RJ Helton/John Stevens [RJ. John's was really, really boring] Signed Sealed Delivered - Ruben/Fantasia [I like both] Let's Stay Together - Trenyce/Leah [Trenyce] You Keep me hanging on - Vanessa/Leah [Vanessa]

04-29-2004, 01:19 PM	#8
¤I Love Clay Aiken¤ MISS APRIL Forum Addict Join Date: Jul 19, 2001 Location: Parsonsfield ME Shaws - Screwing my way up the employment ladder! Posts: 68,780	One Voice: Kelly, Clay & Ruben OR Diana DeGarmo Turn The Beat Around: Carmen Rasmusen OR Diana DeGarmo Im going with Kelly, Clay and Ruben, and then Diana for TTBA.