Charlotte Pollis - any updates?

[Clockwork]

Originally Posted by TheCars1986

Paul panicking after killing Charlotte; intentional or accidental and then having help (most likely from his family members) clean up is the most likely scenario. But I cannot shake the feeling that when Paul and the kids were gone, someone known to them went inside the house not realizing that Charlotte was home, she sees them and recognizes them, and they have to remove her from the house at gunpoint.

Despite the fact that Paul is often one of the husbands people assume is involved, I too have always had that nagging feeling about it. Paul runs errands, the kids go with him. The perpetrator does not know Charlotte is sick and in bed from the previous night. And yes, he's startled, but manages to subtly bring her out of the house to dispose her. I agree this is as likely of a scenario. Paul getting harassed by people, including his in-laws, would drive anyone to be bitter and standoffish. The question is, what kind of argument would have transpired at 130am when she just comes home from the hospital and is on her way to bed? If it was a life insurance pay out her body would have easily been found. Yeah, too many unanwered things here.

[Clockwork]

There isn't a ton of things to look up on this one. No new updates really. We all know Paul had issues with the next woman he married and had domestic charges or whatever it was. But a couple of other things to note that I picked up while watching other videos on it. Paul's dad was a coroner in the local area. Does that mean anything? Maybe, maybe not. I would think someone like him would know what to do with a dead body as good as anyone. Just saying, it lends to the theory that his parents helped him.

A neighbor apparently said that Paul's parents vehicle had been there all night and all day the next day. Hmmm. Not sure. If you looked across the street and saw a car you didn't recognize at 12am it is easy to assume it would be there overnight. But they could have left by 130am. And eyewitness testimonies are not terribly reliable. I couldn't tell you the car my next door neighbor drives right off the top of my head at the moment, let alone one of their relatives cars.

[sharonite]

Whether intentional (premeditated murder) or not (fight that got out of hand, etc.), I ABSOLUTELY believe that Paul is responsible for Charlotte's death. The idea that Charlotte left voluntarily—without her kids!—is absurd.

I grew up near Girard. It's a dying mill town very much like nearby, more-infamous Youngstown (the two cities are in different counties, but share a border). Local law enforcement was/is incompetent, corrupt, or both—and in any event, exhaustively investigating the disappearance of an obese woman on public assistance was never going to be a top priority.

Add to that the fact that Paul's father (Dr. Steven Pollis, who died in 2017) was both a deputy county coroner and a physician, meaning that he almost certainly had knowledge and connections that would come in handy when making a problem like a deceased Charlotte go away.

[Clockwork]

Originally Posted by sharonite

Whether intentional (premeditated murder) or not (fight that got out of hand, etc.), I ABSOLUTELY believe that Paul is responsible for Charlotte's death. The idea that Charlotte left voluntarily—without her kids!—is absurd.

I grew up near Girard. It's a dying mill town very much like nearby, more-infamous Youngstown (the two cities are in different counties, but share a border). Local law enforcement was/is incompetent, corrupt, or both—and in any event, exhaustively investigating the disappearance of an obese woman on public assistance was never going to be a top priority.

Add to that the fact that Paul's father (Dr. Steven Pollis, who died in 2017) was both a deputy county coroner and a physician, meaning that he almost certainly had knowledge and connections that would come in handy when making a problem like a deceased Charlotte go away.

Oh I agree, but that timeline is so thin. And for no one to see anything. Not just that, what kind of fight is started after your sick wife comes home from the hospital and calls her mother before heading to bed? She's tired, probably goes right to bed. How does a fight that ends up even accidentally in her death ensue? And why at that time? That is my nagging issue with this case. Obviously Paul is not like any other husband, he is a suspect, but where is the evidence of a fight or a struggle? How do you transport a 300lbs. body into a trunk without anyone seeing? Even in the middle of the night. Why not tie up the loose ends as well. If Paul saw the purse why admit she didn't take her purse? At least make it look like a robbery/runaway.

I wish there was more to this case than just circumstantial stuff.

[HendersonLeigh]

I apologize if this has already been brought up, but were Paul and Charlotte's children ever interviewed? They're adults now and can speak freely. I know that the little girl was only maybe four at the time Charlotte went missing, but kids remember trauma for the rest of their lives.

[Clockwork]

Originally Posted by HendersonLeigh

I apologize if this has already been brought up, but were Paul and Charlotte's children ever interviewed? They're adults now and can speak freely. I know that the little girl was only maybe four at the time Charlotte went missing, but kids remember trauma for the rest of their lives.

According to social media, the daughter, Layla Nagi I believe (she uses her mom's maiden name if that tells you anything) sides on the idea that her father is responsible.

[HendersonLeigh]

I also couldn't help but notice how much Paul Pollis resembled Vincent Price in his interview... if THAT tells us anything...

[Hot Jock]

So I’m sitting in my parked car in a grocery store parking lot and decide to read this thread from the beginning for whatever reason. And then it hit me. Twenty years after the original article was posted on here and I laughed like freaking hyena when I saw that Paul’s hometown newspaper referred to him as a “local character” in a legitimate news article! That is absolutely fantastic in so many ways! This dude couldn’t even go pick up a pizza without getting arrested at one point. And people think he’s not guilty?

[Clockwork]

Originally Posted by Hot Jock

So I’m sitting in my parked car in a grocery store parking lot and decide to read this thread from the beginning for whatever reason. And then it hit me. Twenty years after the original article was posted on here and I laughed like freaking hyena when I saw that Paul’s hometown newspaper referred to him as a “local character” in a legitimate news article! That is absolutely fantastic in so many ways! This dude couldn’t even go pick up a pizza without getting arrested at one point. And people think he’s not guilty?

He did get into some trouble after the disappearance. Not sure what to make of it. If we notice this then we can acknowledge that he wasn't in trouble with the law prior to it either.

[mwcarolina]

Originally Posted by Hot Jock

And people think he’s not guilty?

Who doesn’t think Paul is guilty!!?? Now I don’t believe for a ONE second that Paul’s daughter witnessed it or as Charlotte’s mom said, “saw mommy put in a dark trash bag”. BUT i definitely think he killed her (he was likely having a girl on the side). Then he called for help (likely his dad and mom) to help move her (dad) and watch the kids (mom)