AJ Breaux

[DALLASTEXAN!!]

I take it for what it is. the investigators think that someone local knows what happened to him. not sure that it means that they have a suspect. all we had to go by in his disappearance were eye witness accounts that were somewhat credible according to his daughters.

there have been a lot of theories thrown around regarding AJ's disappearance. I've always had a feeling that someone from the easy does it club was involved.

[TheCars1986]

Originally Posted by DALLASTEXAN!!

I've always had a feeling that someone from the easy does it club was involved.

If you believe the two eyewitness sightings of AJ being driven around by 3 unidentified men, and I do, then it's almost impossible to come up with a plausible motive as to who was responsible for his disappearance and why. Outside of owing someone money (of which there is no evidence), I can't think of anything that would involve multiple men abducting him that night, keeping him alive, and then killing him at a later date.

I've always thought the Easy Does It Club was a red herring and that whoever dumped his car dumped it there to make it look like it was a clue.

[DALLASTEXAN!!]

Originally Posted by TheCars1986

If you believe the two eyewitness sightings of AJ being driven around by 3 unidentified men, and I do, then it's almost impossible to come up with a plausible motive as to who was responsible for his disappearance and why. Outside of owing someone money (of which there is no evidence), I can't think of anything that would involve multiple men abducting him that night, keeping him alive, and then killing him at a later date.

I've always thought the Easy Does It Club was a red herring and that whoever dumped his car dumped it there to make it look like it was a clue.

there are a lot of red herrings in the UM segment and the club very well could be one. I do trust the eye witness account in this segment and it seems like the best lead, but also not 100% sure.

If we dismiss the idea that AJ disappeared on his own accord, my reasoning for suspecting the easy does it club: AJ could have come across someone that he didn't know well, like a family/friend of a friend. sometimes people that run in those circles are not always the type of people that can be trusted. Unfortunately there are people out there who are manipulators and prey on good people like AJ. Perhaps AJ was forced against his will or tried to back out of a dangerous situation that escalated and it led to his disappearance. That's just a theory of mine and it is possible that these were the people that the eyewitnesses saw.

[TheCars1986]

Originally Posted by DALLASTEXAN!!

If we dismiss the idea that AJ disappeared on his own accord, my reasoning for suspecting the easy does it club: AJ could have come across someone that he didn't know well, like a family/friend of a friend. sometimes people that run in those circles are not always the type of people that can be trusted. Unfortunately there are people out there who are manipulators and prey on good people like AJ. Perhaps AJ was forced against his will or tried to back out of a dangerous situation that escalated and it led to his disappearance. That's just a theory of mine and it is possible that these were the people that the eyewitnesses saw.

The problem that I have with this theory is that if he did find out too much about someone within the club, why did this person or persons parade him around town in a disheveled state? Why force him to make phone calls and to whom? I just can't come up with a reasonable motive as to why someone from the club (and others) would go through all of this trouble if it was simply AJ finding out too much from the wrong person.

[DALLASTEXAN!!]

Originally Posted by TheCars1986

The problem that I have with this theory is that if he did find out too much about someone within the club, why did this person or persons parade him around town in a disheveled state? Why force him to make phone calls and to whom? I just can't come up with a reasonable motive as to why someone from the club (and others) would go through all of this trouble if it was simply AJ finding out too much from the wrong person.

true, especially if we take the eye witness accounts at face value and the timelines were correct. my thoughts are that someone that AJ didn't know well could have been the one that AJ got into trouble with. maybe it was something that AJ thought was innocuous at first and was trying to help out a friend of a friend. and then it escalated into perhaps a scam or perhaps just behavior that AJ did not want to be associated with. AJ then has a fight or flight moment and it leads to his murder.

AJ's disappearance is one of the most mysterious and AJ's case has had so many theories of what could have happened.

[mphs95]

Originally Posted by RobinW

The milk is the main reason why I suspected A.J. was headed straight home and had no intention of going anywhere else that night. Milk is an item that will go bad within an hour or two if you don't refrigerate it, so it just seems weird that he would purchase it in Houma if he was planning to drive a long distance to see someone (did he really to buy milk THAT badly if he was going to meet a secret lover?).

But since A.J. lived with one of his daughters at the time and apparently went to the Easy Does It Club virtually every night, it would be interesting to hear if he had a tendency to stay out really late or it was his normal routine to come home sometime after 10:00 PM. If it's the latter, then this lends credence to the idea that something unexpected happened to him after he left the convenience store.

Something that popped in my head was maybe he was heading home, but passed the Easy Does It Club on his way. Perhaps he saw a light on, or maybe he realized he forgot something. He stops there and maybe catches someone doing something they shouldn't, and he gets killed for it.

[Labonte18]

Originally Posted by mphs95

Something that popped in my head was maybe he was heading home, but passed the Easy Does It Club on his way. Perhaps he saw a light on, or maybe he realized he forgot something. He stops there and maybe catches someone doing something they shouldn't, and he gets killed for it.

Just as good a theory as any other one brought up here.

We don't know.. We have NOTHING to go off of, really.. A few POSSIBLE sightings, which may or may not be accurate.. Some historical knowledge so far as his alcoholism.. And.. That's about it.

With this one.. The problem is.. You have no evidence to eliminate ANYTHING. This particular case, you can't even discount "Abducted by aliens".. Ok.. Exaggerating just a touch there, but.. You get the poiint?

[cvdixon29]

It wasn't him, It's 2026 and he still hasn't been found. His daughters finally got a judge to declare him dead.

[TheCars1986]

A local news station did a twenty minute segment about AJ back in January (HTV 10 - it's on the "AJ Breaux - Project W I S H What If Something Happened" Facebook page), and the detective interviewed says that they are investigating this case as a homicide, and says this interesting quote:

We know that the person that did this, the persons responsible for this, they know information that they can come out and tell us. We understand that sometimes things happen and sometimes things get carried away and if that's the situation that they got carried away and just went too far, I mean here's the time to tell your story.

They also interview AJ's daughters, and they actually have persons of interest in the case. They know who they are. There isn't enough evidence to convict them. They believe there were three of them involved. All three of the persons of interest knew AJ's daughters and two of them went to the same high school with them. One of them is deceased. It's starting to sound like a Tara Calico type of situation, where they know who is responsible but lack the evidence to charge them. But the daughters definitely know who they believe is responsible for AJ's disappearance.

Reading between the lines from what law enforcment and the daughters have said, I think three guys set up AJ in some sort of mock hookup (the park where AJ's car was located was an area for gay men to "cruise") and eventually murdered him.

[Labonte18]

Originally Posted by TheCars1986

A local news station did a twenty minute segment about AJ back in January (HTV 10 - it's on the "AJ Breaux - Project W I S H What If Something Happened" Facebook page), and the detective interviewed says that they are investigating this case as a homicide, and says this interesting quote:



They also interview AJ's daughters, and they actually have persons of interest in the case. They know who they are. There isn't enough evidence to convict them. They believe there were three of them involved. All three of the persons of interest knew AJ's daughters and two of them went to the same high school with them. One of them is deceased. It's starting to sound like a Tara Calico type of situation, where they know who is responsible but lack the evidence to charge them. But the daughters definitely know who they believe is responsible for AJ's disappearance.

Reading between the lines from what law enforcment and the daughters have said, I think three guys set up AJ in some sort of mock hookup (the park where AJ's car was located was an area for gay men to "cruise") and eventually murdered him.

Law Enforcement was certain they had their guy with Richard Jewell as well.

This could go either way.. They could be right.. They could be on the right track.. Or.. They could just be totally wrong.