Actors who played multiple roles in re-enactments

[MegtheEgg86]

Originally Posted by ramirez412001

I can't be sure, but she also looks awfully similar to the witness in the Richard Bocklege segment who witnessed the shooting re-enactment. (She turned around quickly, then dove out of sight)

I've noticed this before, too. I think it's the same actress.

[DALLASTEXAN!!]

Originally Posted by ontarioboi

the actor who played adam hecht also played the friend who took a punch in the segment about that guy who got lost in a dessert.

bumped this because of todd mueller...finally found it again on Amazon been relooking for it for a long time. I love Todd Mueller's segment. I have enjoyed reading through the whole thread.

I never would have noticed the Adam Hecht/David Stone connection. he does look like him. some of the things that are said in that segment are beyond strange. regarding the punching scene the other friend "John Duffus" quotes that David Stone "hit him 20-25 times and didn't really hurt him but he said he felt he needed to that"

all that while saved by the bell fight scene music is playing in the background.

[yellowVWchase]

The little old fellow who plays Brushy Bill in the Billy the Kid segment is also the same actor who played the little old fellow who built the circular staircase to the choir loft for the nuns. Great casting, the guy has a great look and is a natural.

[Guardian]

Originally Posted by yellowVWchase

The little old fellow who plays Brushy Bill in the Billy the Kid segment is also the same actor who played the little old fellow who built the circular staircase to the choir loft for the nuns. Great casting, the guy has a great look and is a natural.

Was just about to mention that one lol

[WishfulDreamer]

Several of the child actors are used in multiple segments. There's a noticeable one in the first season that I can't recall right now, but one other notable case is the little girl in the Maria Hernandez and Father D'Orio cases are one and the same.

[MegtheEgg86]

Originally Posted by WishfulDreamer

Several of the child actors are used in multiple segments. There's a noticeable one in the first season that I can't recall right now, but one other notable case is the little girl in the Maria Hernandez and Father D'Orio cases are one and the same.

I feel like the little girl who played Nicole Laferte also portrayed Crystal Riemer. If not, they sure look an awful lot alike.

[WishfulDreamer]

Originally Posted by MegtheEgg86

I feel like the little girl who played Nicole Laferte also portrayed Crystal Riemer. If not, they sure look an awful lot alike.

Good eye! I'm pretty sure you're correct about this.

Also, just had my memory jogged about the first season connections. I am pretty sure the little girl in the Philip Pelletier segment also reappears in the segment about Ruby Bradford several seasons later, and is shown when the family is trying to survive a tornado. But again, this could just be that the actresses look similar.

[unsolved243]

Dennis North, the actor who played Jerry "Circlestansive Evidence" Strickland also played Robert Miller (his daughter, a deaf woman named Patty English, was searching for him).

[schmave]

Originally Posted by WishfulDreamer

He's in the Curt Borton segment, too. "What you did was reaaaaaaaaaallly stupid"

I used to think that was a young Tony Goldwyn. There's certainly a strong resemblance.

[WishfulDreamer]

Originally Posted by unsolved243

Dennis North, the actor who played Jerry "Circlestansive Evidence" Strickland also played Robert Miller (his daughter, a deaf woman named Patty English, was searching for him).

You just blew my mind. It must have been the 'stache keeping me from realizing it was the same guy.

[WishfulDreamer]

It's been a long time since I've seen it, but I feel like the actress who played Colette MacDonald also played Barbara Piotrowski in the Richard Minns segment.Maybe they just looked similar, though.

I think I mentioned this before, but the same little girl is in the Father Diorio and Rosa Hernandez segments.

[WishfulDreamer]

When Anton Kline goes to Crystal Spencer's workplace to look for her, the coworker he speaks to is none other than the same actress who played Sally Gerrity (aka the actress who goes "Sal, Sally? That's neat!")

[Jon]

Tim Barry and Paul Stamper?

[sdb4884]

The actor who played John Grundhoffer played a Doctor in the Etta Smith segment S07 E13 on the Amazon episodes.

[bell83]

Originally Posted by yellowVWchase

The little old fellow who plays Brushy Bill in the Billy the Kid segment is also the same actor who played the little old fellow who built the circular staircase to the choir loft for the nuns. Great casting, the guy has a great look and is a natural.

Hot take: Billy the Kid built the spiral staircase for the nuns.