Valentine's Day Murder - Sitcoms Online Message Boards

angiefan · 02-18-2010, 05:28 PM

I remember a doctor and his wife,gave each other valentine's day cards on valentin's day,there was some kind of arguement later on in the morning,after the doctor came home from the hospital,from performing a surgery,and she was found dead.Does anybody know anything about this case? I know he killed her,Was he seeing another woman or what?

Kane · 02-18-2010, 08:30 PM

That sounds like the 2001 murder of Susan Shibley Hamilton, but it was never profiled on UM. Her husband, John Hamilton was convicted of the murder by the end of the year.

Susan was said to have been murdered after arguing with John. His cell phone bills led her to suspect that he was having an affair with an exotic dancer.

The case was the subject of a Forensic Files episode titled "Deadly Valentine."

You can find more information on the case through search engines (such as Google). Just type in either (or both) of the following names, and you'll get quicker results: "Susan Shibley Hamilton" and/or "John Baxter Hamilton."

02-18-2010, 05:28 PM	#1
angiefan happy labor day! Forum Regular Join Date: Apr 15, 2006 Location: grand blanc,michigan Posts: 618	Valentine's Day Murder I remember a doctor and his wife,gave each other valentine's day cards on valentin's day,there was some kind of arguement later on in the morning,after the doctor came home from the hospital,from performing a surgery,and she was found dead.Does anybody know anything about this case? I know he killed her,Was he seeing another woman or what?

02-18-2010, 08:30 PM	#2
Kane Member Forum 3000 Club Member Join Date: Mar 07, 2001 Location: MA, United States Posts: 3,367	That sounds like the 2001 murder of Susan Shibley Hamilton, but it was never profiled on UM. Her husband, John Hamilton was convicted of the murder by the end of the year. Susan was said to have been murdered after arguing with John. His cell phone bills led her to suspect that he was having an affair with an exotic dancer. The case was the subject of a Forensic Files episode titled "Deadly Valentine." You can find more information on the case through search engines (such as Google). Just type in either (or both) of the following names, and you'll get quicker results: "Susan Shibley Hamilton" and/or "John Baxter Hamilton."