Hey kids! It's your Uncle TJL here.

A while back I started a good idea/bad idea thread about TV, which at the risk of exageration, was the greatest thread ever!

Anyway, I thought we'd turn our attention to the world of movies.

Give me a good idea and then a bad one about a movie.

Example:

Star Wars - The Special Edition
Good Idea - Adding the Jabba The Hutt/Han Solo hanger scene that was never used in the 1977 original.
Bad Idea - Making Greedo shoot first.

Star Trek Nemesis
Good Idea - Riker and Troi getting married
Bad Idea - Data's death.

Get it? Got it? Good.

;)

Fellowship of the Ring

good idea - making a close to the book movie
bad idea - leaving out Tom Bombadil and replacing Gilgalad with Arewyn:mad:
Gilgalad was cool why was he not in the movie!!

Originally posted by brownsocks
Fellowship of the Ring

good idea - making a close to the book movie
bad idea - leaving out Tom Bombadil and replacing Gilgalad with Arewyn:mad:
Gilgalad was cool why was he not in the movie!!
Yeah, Tom Bombadil would have been a good scene to add to that movie.