I'm dying to know which will win in a head-to-head battle.

Second Banana:

Mel vs Schneider

Teenage Kid:

Alex vs Tommy

Old Famous People:

Nanette Fabray vs Martha Ray

Best Friend:

Jenny vs Flo

Young Women:

Barbara & Julie vs Vera & Jolene

Supporting cast:

Leading Lady:

Ann vs Alice

As a kid I liked ODAAT better but as an adult I laugh harder at Alice. Love both though and have all of ODAAT on DVD and seasons 1-7 (waiting for 8-9) of Alice.

Younger, first run I'd say Alice. Now as an adult I still love Alice but I love ODAAT too. And ODAAT has the love of my life Max!!:):love:

I like Mel a bit more than Schneider, Tommy way better than Alex, Nanette and Martha undecided ?, Flo better than Ginny, Barbara & Julie equal to Vera & Jolene, Alice better than Ann.

I like Alice more but I still enjoy ODAAT.

My winners are in bold...

Second Banana:

Mel vs Schneider

Teenage Kid:

Alex vs Tommy

Old Famous People:

Nanette Fabray vs Martha Ray

Best Friend:

Jenny vs Flo

Young Women:

Barbara & Julie vs Vera & Jolene

Leading Lady:

Ann vs Alice....actually neither.

Younger, first run I'd say Alice. Now as an adult I still love Alice but I love ODAAT too. And ODAAT has the love of my life Max!!:):love:

Tommy way better than Alex.

I'm crying!:eek::)

I'm crying!:eek::)

Hi, Alex.:wave:

As a kid I liked ODAAT better but as an adult I laugh harder at Alice. Love both though and have all of ODAAT on DVD and seasons 1-7 (waiting for 8-9) of Alice.

This!

Hi, Alex.:wave:

Sven!:wave::)

Wouldn't it have been cool if they did a Alice/ ODAAT crossover episode?:cool: The ODAAT gang could be taking a road trip to California in Schneider's camper. They stop for a bite to eat in Phoenix at Mel's diner !!!:);) Couldn't you totally see Flo and Schneider flirting with each other?! ;)

Wouldn't it have been cool if they did a Alice/ ODAAT crossover episode?:cool: The ODAAT gang could be taking a road trip to California in Schneider's camper. They stop for a bite to eat in Phoenix at Mel's diner !!!:);) Couldn't you totally see Flo and Schneider flirting with each other?! ;)

That would have been cool! I think Tommy would have gotten a crush on Barbara too.:). Ann and Alice would likely have butted heads. Or maybe Ann and Mel after Ms. Romano sees how he treats his waitresses.

That would have been cool! I think Tommy would have gotten a crush on Barbara too.:). Ann and Alice would likely have butted heads. Or maybe Ann and Mel after Ms. Romano sees how he treats his waitresses.


Yeah I was thinking of Tommy having a crush on Barbara!:) And I thought Mel would maybe have the hots for Ann, but your scenario is better , he would like her but she wouldn't reciprocate his advances feeling he was too much a male chauvinist because like you say the way he treats his waitresses.:confused: How about if Ann convinced them to go on strike? :eek::D

I'm dying to know which will win in a head-to-head battle.



Young Women:

Barbara & Julie vs Vera & Jolene



I'm no Alice expert, but they weren't close to same age, were they?

Yeah I was thinking of Tommy having a crush on Barbara!:) And I thought Mel would maybe have the hots for Ann, but your scenario is better , he would like her but she wouldn't reciprocate his advances feeling he was too much a male chauvinist because like you say the way he treats his waitresses.:confused: How about if Ann convinced them to go on strike? :eek::D

Yes! There'd definitely be some civil unrest, a battle of the network stars!:)

I'm no Alice expert, but they weren't close to same age, were they?

Yeah ! Barbara and Julie were much younger than Vera and Jolene !;) They weren't young women! Esp. by those days standards. They were probably supposed to be like mid 30's ? ;)

Yeah I was thinking of Tommy having a crush on Barbara!:) And I thought Mel would maybe have the hots for Ann, but your scenario is better , he would like her but she wouldn't reciprocate his advances feeling he was too much a male chauvinist because like you say the way he treats his waitresses.:confused: How about if Ann convinced them to go on strike? :eek::D

I could totally see Mel telling Ann to "stow it"! :D ...among other things. :eek:

Ann and Alice would totally have butted heads, and maybe Ann would've been disappointed with the way Flo handles herself. Ann would've probably given Flo a women's lib speech.

Yeah ! Barbara and Julie were much younger than Vera and Jolene !;) They weren't young women! Esp. by those days standards. They were probably supposed to be like mid 30's ? ;)

I thought so. I’m familiar with Vera, but have no idea who Jolene is, except for the fact that she could take Dolly Parton’s man if she wanted to.

I could totally see Mel telling Ann to "stow it"! :D ...among other things. :eek:

Ann and Alice would totally have butted heads, and maybe Ann would've been disappointed with the way Flo handles herself. Ann would've probably given Flo a women's lib speech.

And we all know what Flo would've told Ann she could do....

I realized I never answered the original poll idea. So, for the record, with no offense to Alice fans, I'd go all the way with One Day, except I would pick Flo over Ginny. And not to sound equivocal, but I could be persuaded to switch to Alice over Ann and Mel over Scheinder.:)

I realized I never answered the original poll idea. So, for the record, with no offense to Alice fans, I'd go all the way with One Day, except I would pick Flo over Ginny. And not to sound equivocal, but I could be persuaded to switch to Alice over Ann and Mel over Scheinder.:)

One Day at a Time for me too. Alice is a great show, though.

All the ODAAT choices, except: I’ll go with the Flo (just loved her sass!)

ODAAT had a much better cast, wish Flo would have defected to Indianapolis!!!!

All the ODAAT choices, except: I’ll go with the Flo (just loved her sass!)

ODAAT had a much better cast, wish Flo would have defected to Indianapolis!!!!

What if Ann and Flo had become good friends and both being redheads if Ann started wearing a big old beehive hairdo like Flo's and they went out together to the Honky Tonk bars picking up Good ol' boys!!?? :lol::D

I enjoyed Alice more especially in the early years.

One Day At A Time is OK.

Which guy is more handsome?

A- Henry

https://pmcdeadline2.files.wordpress.com/2016/08/marvin-kaplan-on-alice.jpg?w=446&h=299&crop=1

Or


B- Max

http://forums.previously.tv/applications/core/interface/imageproxy/imageproxy.php?img=https://i.ytimg.com/vi/ynfrufjqPhA/hqdefault.jpg&key=ecc03d86b98018eadbe2721ee64b6c756b0900ebf37f8f9988ec24ddfe960398


:lol::D