Which teen sitcom did you like better?

Patty Duke

Yes!! And Patty Duke playing two characters was genius! And two very different girls too. I mean they were identical looking, but acted and talked so differently! It really was amazing that it was the same girl playing both parts! It really seemed like Patty and Cathy were two different identical twin actresses! Esp. for those days before all the technology! It really was something!!

I admire both actresses a lot, but the nod for me goes to Patty. There were some good storylines. I enjoy seeing actors who were just starting out too - Daniel J. Travanti, Kathy Garver - and the "star" guests like Troy Donahue and Frankie Avalon (although they did seem to go a little overboard with that). And William Schallert played a few roles himself - Poppo, Kenneth Lane and Uncle Jed! ;)

Definitely Patty Duke. I liked Gidget at first but it got old with so few episodes.

definitely Gidget....Patty Duke got annoying really fast....

Patty Duke for sure although Gidget had its share of good moments.

Patty Duke :)

Patty Duke

It is somewhat hard to compare for Patty was on 3 years vs Gidget only one year.

Patty Duke :)



Somehow I figured you would vote for Patty Duke!! :lol: :D ;)

Gidget I suppose.....

Patty Duke

Don't forget cousin Betsy!


Oh yeah, cousin Betsy was the Southern girl cousin that looked just like them too. Also played by Patty Duke ! :eek:

I like both, but I went with Patty Duke.

Patty Duke Show

I voted for Gidget. I liked the beach episodes the best and Martin Milner was on one of those playing Kahuna.

I prefer Gidget.

Patty !

Gidget :)

I havent seen many of her show but the few I have seen I say GIDGET all the way :)

both shows have great casts,writers.two characters played by same person.great guest stars on...the patty duke show.wasnt there a stand in actress for some scenes on duke show ? duke show film in new york city ? wasnt it going to go on..but ..die owner want to film it in los angeles area ? seems gidget maybe was cancelled and during the summer..it got high ratings,but it had been cancelled ...

Ya I think I seen Patty Duke once or twice......