Stunned All in the Family was not on the list LOL


http://nypost.com/2014/06/07/the-top-10-greatest-nyc-sitcoms-ever/

Poor list. Not having "All In The Family" instantly disqualifies it. For that matter where are "The Goldbergs" (fifties version), "Car 54", "That Girl", "Odd Couple", "Barney Miller", "Night Court" and others? Those shows could have been only set in NYC. "Friends" would have been exactly the same if it was in LA or another big city.

Poor list. Not having "All In The Family" instantly disqualifies it. For that matter where are "The Goldbergs" (fifties version), "Car 54", "That Girl", "Odd Couple", "Barney Miller", "Night Court" and others? Those shows could have been only set in NYC. "Friends" would have been exactly the same if it was in LA or another big city.


you had to have AITF if the Jeffersons was on the list because there would have been no Jeffersons if it wasn't for all in the family

Where did The Post get this so called top 10 list? Who did they survey for it, if anyone. This may just be the writer's opinion of what the top 10 should be.

I never have much faith in The Post anyways ; it's a half a rung above the National Inquirer.

It's hard to take any top ten list like this seriously, when it omits one of the GREATEST SHOWS ever. (IMO anyways.)

Where did The Post get this so called top 10 list? Who did they survey for it, if anyone. This may just be the writer's opinion of what the top 10 should be.

I never have much faith in The Post anyways ; it's a half a rung above the National Inquirer.

It's hard to take any top ten list like this seriously, when it omits one of the GREATEST SHOWS ever. (IMO anyways.)


4 of my favorite shows made the list

Cosby Show
Honeymooners
Jeffersons
Seinfeld

I think a lot of people don't traditionally think of All in the Family as a NYC-set sitcom, for whatever reason. I guess because none of the action is really set in Manhattan, which is what people traditionally think of as "NYC".

Then again, The Cosby Show is on the list so who knows?

I think a lot of people don't traditionally think of All in the Family as a NYC-set sitcom, for whatever reason. I guess because none of the action is really set in Manhattan, which is what people traditionally think of as "NYC".

Then again, The Cosby Show is on the list so who knows?


Honeymooners was on the list and it was set in Brooklyn

I would have included "Taxi" on the list

I would have included "Taxi" on the list


Taxi is on the list, #9

Taxi is on the list, #9

My bad. I googled the NY Post list and the one I saw had "Diff'rent Strokes" as #9, but all the other shows on the current one were on there, just in different spots. I must have saw a list they did a few years ago because it mentions 30 Rock as still in production.

It should have been longer. Maybe 25.

I would have put 'Mad About You'.
It's the most 'newyork-ese' of all.

I would have put RHODA on there for sure.

These lists tend to be written by people who grew up watching TV in the Seinfeld/Friends/SATC era and don't really have a deeper appreciation for much beyond that, Lucy and The Honeymooners being the exception.

I would have put RHODA on there for sure.

These lists tend to be written by people who grew up watching TV in the Seinfeld/Friends/SATC era and don't really have a deeper appreciation for much beyond that, Lucy and The Honeymooners being the exception.


Rhoda was cancelled so it could not be on the list

4 of my favorite shows made the list:

I Love Lucy
The Honeymooners
The Jeffersons
Friends

"All In The Family" should've been on there as well as "Diffr'nt Strokes".

That list sucked!

Here's how I rank their list:

1. The Honeymooners
2. Friends
3. Seinfeld
4. 30 Rock
5. I Love Lucy
6. Girls
7. Sex and the City
8. The Cosby Show
9. The Jeffersons
10. Taxi

I would add All In The Family and Diff'rent Strokes to the list.

That's also why I have a Top-16 list...there's sooooo much to add in a top-# list.

Top 10 Sitcoms SHOT in New York:

The Goldbergs

Mr. Peepers

Mama

Car 54

Stanley

Calucci's Department

The Patty Duke Show

The Cosby Show

Cosby

Kate and Allie

1. I Love Lucy
2. The Odd Couple
3. The Honeymooners
4. All in the Family
5. The Dick Van Dyke Show
6. Happy Days
7. Sanford and Son
8. Get Smart
9. The Addams Family
10. The Mary Tyler Moore Show

1. I Love Lucy
2. The Odd Couple
3. The Honeymooners
4. All in the Family
5. The Dick Van Dyke Show
6. Happy Days
7. Sanford and Son
8. Get Smart
9. The Addams Family
10. The Mary Tyler Moore Show



Do your list over, it's NYC sitcoms