View Full Version : Would It Have Been Better or Worse to Kill Off the Julie Character?


Brian Damage
12-09-2010, 05:51 PM
Considering her poor attitude and drug abuse problems, would it have been better or worse if they decided to kill off her character? Remember, they wrote her off the show by having her leave her husband and daughter...Thoughts?

Marvo301
12-09-2010, 06:34 PM
I'm glad they didn't kill the Julie character since it left the door open for her to return either later in the series or in any potential reunion movies. That being said I wish they had come up with a better back story for the character leaving the show. Her up and leaving her husband and daughter never sat right with me.

Retro4Life
12-09-2010, 09:45 PM
Agree with Marv. To kill her off would have left no room whatsoever for her to return, and even though this was a show with serious overtones, it was, ultimately, a sitcom where you want everything to end up positively.

I also agree it's a shame that they had to pretty much blaspheme the character in order to find a way to write her out. They could have done much better by her. :(

70s show watcher
02-13-2011, 05:13 AM
Agree with Marv. To kill her off would have left no room whatsoever for her to return, and even though this was a show with serious overtones, it was, ultimately, a sitcom where you want everything to end up positively.

I also agree it's a shame that they had to pretty much blaspheme the character in order to find a way to write her out. They could have done much better by her. :(i agree

biffbronson
02-13-2011, 10:37 AM
I also think that generally, for a sitcom it's inappropriate to kill off a character -- especially a young one. Tough call as far as how to handle Julie though -- I'm sure at least a lot of thought went into it, which I can appreciate.

glickmam
06-25-2011, 07:09 PM
Considering her poor attitude and drug abuse problems, would it have been better or worse if they decided to kill off her character? Remember, they wrote her off the show by having her leave her husband and daughter...Thoughts?

Given the negative backlash that occurred when James Evans, Sr. was killed off on Good Times when John Amos was fired, I really don't think the producers would have considered such a move. Keep in mind, no matter how uncooperative an actor or actress may be, if you fire him or her and then kill off his or her character, rather than having them die a painless death, you're most likely to receive an awful lot of unwanted bad publicity.