LOL, not sure if that was a good move. He is not even a top 10 QB

He has a Super Bowl ring and has been playing very well the last five years.

BTW, if you claim he's not top 10, who IS?

He has a Super Bowl ring and has been playing very well the last five years.

BTW, if you claim he's not top 10, who IS?

Brady
Manning
Mcnabb
Big Ben
Rivers
Brees
Flacco
Ryan
Warner
Rosenfels

What if Eli gets hurt? The Giants won't have any money left to get another QB!

Brady
Manning
Mcnabb
Big Ben
Rivers
Brees
Flacco
Ryan
Warner
Rosenfels

Brees and Rivers don't have a ring, Flacco and Ryan have played just one season (and also don't have a ring).

Rosenfels? :lol: :eek: I'm sorry, but to say that a guy who WON A SUPERBOWL should be ranked lowere than a guy who HAS NEVER PLAYED A PLAYOFF GAME?

Eli beat a Patriots team going for a perfect record; Rosenfels has more losses than wins.

Does. Not. Compute.

The giants will regret this contract... ELI without Plaxico = DEER IN HEADLIGHTS.... BTW LOTS OF EAGLES TALK COMING SOON ;)

I already posted about this!! :mad:

We don't need another thread.. :confused:

I already posted about this!! :mad:

We don't need another thread.. :confused:


Your thread has no replies and this one is active so just post in this one

Your thread has no replies and this one is active so just post in this one

Fine. I'll just delete that one then.

They gave him 97 million dollars? holy sh*t. he is not top ten.

big ben won two superbowls, and is a better QB, but doesn't make him number one, if we're going by superbowl appearences and wins. Brady is probably one of the exceptions, but superbowl wins are team related. I don't think any NFL player is worth 97 million. that is absolutely ridiculous money. you couldn't pay me, to spend $97 million.

Brady
Manning
Mcnabb
Big Ben
Rivers
Brees
Flacco
Ryan
Warner
Rosenfels

Flacco and Rosenfels in your top 10 LOL LOL?

that is the stupidest **** I've ever heard Solomon. my top 10 in order, best to worst.

Brady
Manning
Roethlisberger
McNabb
Warner
Brees
Rivers
Hasselbeck
Jeff Garcia
Rodgers

we're going with the best in the league....hasselbeck was injured last year but is a great QB

11. Jay Cutler
12. Eli Manning
13. Romo
14. Matt Ryan
15. Pennington

I just noticed something. It was a GREAT day to be a "Eli", on a team with the name "Giants." Eli Whiteside of the San Francisco Giants hit a Grand Slam, for his first home run of the season, in a 10-6 win over Houston. Eli Manning of the New York Giants, earned a $97 million, $30 million guarenteed contract. :rofl: :rofl:

Craziness

I'll take any of McNabb's backups over Rosenfels.

I'll take any of McNabb's backups over Rosenfels.

AJ Feely >>>>>> Rosenfels

Yeah, I was real surprised when I read about his contract. Not saying he don't deserve it, but that's a little too much for a QB of his calibre. I am not calling him a bad QB, just a very good QB. Maybe a top 15 QB, but definitely not a top 10 QB.

Yeah, I was real surprised when I read about his contract. Not saying he don't deserve it, but that's a little too much for a QB of his calibre. I am not calling him a bad QB, just a very good QB. Maybe a top 15 QB, but definitely not a top 10 QB.


I agree a 100%, He is TOO SCARY to be a 97 million dollar QB