View Full Version : What are the most meaingless stastistics in sports?
Big C 04-19-2009, 12:17 AM In sports, there are lots of meaningful player statistics.
But I'll bet there are some that you don't think are as important as others think they are.
Here are a few of mine:
1. Strikeouts by a batter- people make too much of a deal about sluggers who have a lot of strikeouts. From 2006 to 2008, Ryan Howard struck out 181, 199, and 199 times in each season. But Philly fans didn't seem to get on his case for it- after all, he had 58, 47, and 47 homers and 149, 139, and 146 RBI's in those respective seasons.
Wreckless knows about this- there have been plenty of instances where Howard would have a 4 or 5 strikeout game one night and have a huge night the next.
EVERYBODY strike outs- Reggie Jackson struck out more times than any batter in history, and he's a Hall of Famer.
2. on-base percentage. Just because you're on base 61 percent of the time doesn't mean you'll score all the time. I think how often you get on base is not as important as scoring runs.
Wreckless 04-19-2009, 12:21 AM it's irony and backwards tp me, cause the most meaningless thing about sports in the general perspective are the statistics....
it's all about rooting for our team and becoming one with the sport.....
Darren J. 04-19-2009, 12:34 AM NBA
Blocks- most think that it makes you a great defender. It doesn't because a blocked shot doesn't always result in your team getting possession of the ball.
MLB
Slugging %- this has a minimal effect for those that are not power hitters. You don't have to be a power hitter to get runners into scoring position and driving them in.
NFL
Completions- if you're on a team with no running game, you're going to naturally throw the ball more, resulting in more completions. In addition, completions don't always result in first downs or even gains.
NHL
Plus/minus- this would be a good stat if power play goals resulted in pluses. If you're not going to count certain goals, then it is pointless.
As for strikeouts being meaningless, it is not. With Ryan Howard, he may hit 50+ home runs, but what is he doing other than that? If he is not hitting a home run or being intentionally walked, he isn't doing much of anything. Last year, he had 153 hits and 48 of them(31.4%) were home runs. That's nearly 1/3. In an average game, he probably gets to bat 4 times. His home runs/hits ratio means his hit will most likely be a home run. If he doesn't hit a home run, he does nothing else. He walked only 81 times, which is only every other game. He only had 6 sacrifice flies and 3 hit by pitches.
Bottom line is Ryan Howard striking out a ton hurts himself and the team since he does nothing else.
Wreckless 04-19-2009, 12:39 AM I'll add one- QB Rating in the NFL...if he hikes the ball to end the game, they count it as a loss in yards, which is stupid, and the qb rating doesn't define how good or bad a qb is, or what their game is whatsoever...
catlover79 04-19-2009, 12:58 AM Too many. :crazy: :lol:
littlebelle 04-19-2009, 02:21 AM I agree. Off topic a little, but I really need to come back to the sports thread- this is my favorite season of sports.
Wreckless 04-19-2009, 02:23 AM I agree. Off topic a little, but I really need to come back to the sports thread- this is my favorite season of sports.
Yeah you do. My last week in sports has been dreadful.....
Big C 04-19-2009, 02:46 AM I really need to come back to the sports thread- this is my favorite season of sports.
Mariners are playing decent baseball and the Seahawks are a week away from drafting new players.
Wreckless 04-19-2009, 02:47 AM Mariners are playing decent baseball and the Seahawks are a week away from drafting new players.
lol shes a dodgers fan Chris, not a mariners fan....
littlebelle 04-19-2009, 03:00 AM Yeah, The M's cool though. I mean, I root for them too, but I don't follow their games. I'm just a dodgers fan, but if I'm going to watch another team, it'll be the mariner's. I'm happy Griffey came back, everyone was really excited. Did you guys see the Mariners/Dodgers game? lol.
littlebelle 04-19-2009, 03:01 AM Yeah you do. My last week in sports has been dreadful.....
Yeah, I'm really sorry about that Kyle :(. I'm actually a nba/mlb fan more then I am a nfl fan, if you didn't know.
Wreckless 04-19-2009, 03:02 AM You need to route for the M's all the way, miss Ramona lol. Idk, I don't like that you root for LA teams but that's just me lol. I know you have family out their.
Waterston_Fan 04-19-2009, 11:41 AM Yeah you do. My last week in sports has been dreadful.....
I'm sorry you have had a bad week in sports.
Waterston_Fan 04-19-2009, 11:42 AM Yeah, The M's cool though. I mean, I root for them too, but I don't follow their games. I'm just a dodgers fan, but if I'm going to watch another team, it'll be the mariner's. I'm happy Griffey came back, everyone was really excited. Did you guys see the Mariners/Dodgers game? lol.
Lose already will you, I want to take over the West. :lol:
:wave:
TVFactFan 04-19-2009, 01:44 PM NBA-Points per game
NFL-QB rating
littlebelle 04-19-2009, 01:51 PM You need to route for the M's all the way, miss Ramona lol. Idk, I don't like that you root for LA teams but that's just me lol. I know you have family out their.
My mom is from there so she always rooted fro LA teams. My dad usually only watches football, so there ya go.
Wreckless 04-19-2009, 05:08 PM NBA-Points per game
NFL-QB rating
I disagree, and agree on you here lol...
you have to be joking....PPG is the biggest stat, if you focus primarily on stats, in the NBA....but I agree, QB rating is way overrated and doesn't say if a QB is good or bad or not....
Wreckless 04-19-2009, 05:09 PM And thanks Ramona and WF, it's getting better. WF, your team is kicking our a$$ on this tough, emotional home stand lol. It's early on but kudos to your team.
Big C 04-19-2009, 05:46 PM QB rating is way overrated and doesn't say if a QB is good or bad or not....
Agreed.
The only QB stats that matter to most of us are touchdowns, passing yards, and interceptions.
Darren J. 04-19-2009, 06:05 PM I disagree, and agree on you here lol...
you have to be joking....PPG is the biggest stat, if you focus primarily on stats, in the NBA....but I agree, QB rating is way overrated and doesn't say if a QB is good or bad or not....
It's not that PPG is irrelevant, but it can easily overrate a player. With Allen Iverson, he averaged over 30 PPG on multiple occasions, yet barely shot 40% from the field. Then you take Shaq, who averaged 25-30 PPG and shot 55-60% from the field. It is relevant, but what is more relevant is FG%.
Wreckless 04-19-2009, 06:25 PM It's not that PPG is irrelevant, but it can easily overrate a player. With Allen Iverson, he averaged over 30 PPG on multiple occasions, yet barely shot 40% from the field. Then you take Shaq, who averaged 25-30 PPG and shot 55-60% from the field. It is relevant, but what is more relevant is FG%.
That is a good, true counter point. Iverson sucks anyway.
James 04-19-2009, 10:24 PM Baseball - saves. I blame that concept for the gigantic drop in complete games.
Darren J. 04-19-2009, 11:43 PM That is a good, true counter point. Iverson sucks anyway.
Iverson is a talented individual player. But, he's only good if he has the ball in his hands. He is not the guy you want leading your team. He got lucky in 2001 when the 76ers went to the Finals. If Philly never went to the Finals that year, he would be on the same level as Vince Carter and Dominique Wilkins.
TVFactFan 04-19-2009, 11:53 PM Iverson is a talented individual player. But, he's only good if he has the ball in his hands. He is not the guy you want leading your team. He got lucky in 2001 when the 76ers went to the Finals. If Philly never went to the Finals that year, he would be on the same level as Vince Carter and Dominique Wilkins.
I watched every 76ers playoff game in 2001 and luck had nothing to do with it, it was the talent and skills of AI who led the team by himself to the Finals. After that game 1 win over the Lakers, he had nothing left.
|