View Full Version : Least Favorite Gueststar to visit the Island?


mrs.gingerhinkley
08-04-2007, 02:53 PM
yes, all of the people who visited the island, only to leave the poor castaways stranded were thoroughly annoying. But who was your least favorite?

I couldn't stand that butterfly catcher!!!!

:mad:

he was to wrapped up in his butterflys to even think about the others.

Ireneparalegal
08-04-2007, 03:29 PM
I am with you on that one. Eva Grubb comes in a close second. Those two were only thinking of themselves to even care abt 7 human beings!!!! Not only that, with the Howells being rescued, can you imagine what the old fuddy duddy butterfly man could have done with the help of the Howell's???? Or even Eva Grubb???? You know the Howell's would have rewarded them generously for getting them off the island.

caladon
08-04-2007, 05:53 PM
It would be Harold Hecuba. There was no need for the castaways to suck-up to that arrogant blowhard when they had several options.

1) They could just take the rubber raft with the outboard motor.

2) They could tell Hecuba that if he wanted food and water all he had to do was take them with him when he left.

3) Remind him that when his flunkies arrived, all they needed to do was let Mr. Howell bribe them into helping them off the island. Mr. Howell had more influence and resources than Hecuba.

In every option, Hecuba couldn't do anything about it.

Mikado
08-04-2007, 07:21 PM
That surfer guy

Zoneboy
08-04-2007, 07:30 PM
I couldn't stand that butterfly catcher!!!!
:mad:

he was to wrapped up in his butterflys to even think about the others.

That was John McGiver & I'd have to agree.

Céline
08-04-2007, 07:36 PM
Wiley,the kidnapper(Don Rickels)

Lord Beasley,the butterfly's hunter(John Mc Giver)

Johnathan Kidcaid,the hunter(Rory Calhound)

Georges Barkley,the contestant of Take a Dare(Strother Martin)

Erika Tiffany Smith(Zsa Zsa Gabor)

Eva Grubb(Tina Louise)

Zoneboy
08-04-2007, 07:52 PM
That surfer guy

Denny Miller who is currently the Gorton's Fisherman.
http://www.consumingambitions.com/consuming_ambitions/Gortons_Fisherman_tn.jpg

Mikado
08-04-2007, 08:15 PM
yeah I knew it was Denny something.....but, his last name drew a blank

mrs.gingerhinkley
08-04-2007, 11:24 PM
That surfer guy
He wasn't thaaaat bad... *Grin*
*Sighs*

wow, i was SOooo amazed to come back and see not one, but like SEVEN replies already!!!!! I almost screamed with joy!


Ireneparalegal,
I agree with u also on the Eva Grubb thing.
Wut she did was just low.
Everyone's nice to her, the girls give her a makeover. And wut does she do to thank them?

*shakes head in disbelief*

Ireneparalegal
08-05-2007, 04:13 PM
He wasn't thaaaat bad... *Grin*
*Sighs*

wow, i was SOooo amazed to come back and see not one, but like SEVEN replies already!!!!! I almost screamed with joy!


Ireneparalegal,
I agree with u also on the Eva Grubb thing.
Wut she did was just low.
Everyone's nice to her, the girls give her a makeover. And wut does she do to thank them?

*shakes head in disbelief*
Eva turned DIVA after that makeover. :crazy: I guess in reality I am annoyed with every guest star who could have saved the castaways and for whatever selfish reason, they didn't. The exception is the Eva Gabor character. She merely was dumb. :lol: The Professor should have supplied her with a map, directions and so forth, strap it to her waist or something so she didn't lose it. Also, why didn't Eva Gabor's character just state the names of the castaways? Did she forget their names that quick? Why not mention the MINNOW? Surely then the officials would know she had seen them alive? God, she was dumb, but the Professor screwed up big time by not putting that important info IN WRITING for her. :crazy:

AB
08-06-2007, 03:52 PM
My least favorite was the Japanese WWII soldier who took most of them captive.

mrs.gingerhinkley
08-06-2007, 07:55 PM
Eva turned DIVA after that makeover. :crazy: I guess in reality I am annoyed with every guest star who could have saved the castaways and for whatever selfish reason, they didn't. The exception is the Eva Gabor character. She merely was dumb. :lol: The Professor should have supplied her with a map, directions and so forth, strap it to her waist or something so she didn't lose it. Also, why didn't Eva Gabor's character just state the names of the castaways? Did she forget their names that quick? Why not mention the MINNOW? Surely then the officials would know she had seen them alive? God, she was dumb, but the Professor screwed up big time by not putting that important info IN WRITING for her. :crazy:
yeah, that was pretty dumb of her....

, but anyway. Wut you were saying about selvish reasons.
Some of the people to visit the island, you can almost understand that they're to selvish to rescue the castaways: example, Harold Heckubah.

However, if I was the castaways, Wrongway Feldman would have annoyed the HECK out of me!!!!!


Gosh, sometimes I wonder how the seven didn't crack and just kill any one of the jerks that landed on the island.

gilligan fanatic
08-15-2007, 11:45 AM
Wiley,the kidnapper(Don Rickels)

Lord Beasley,the butterfly's hunter(John Mc Giver)

Johnathan Kidcaid,the hunter(Rory Calhound)

Georges Barkley,the contestant of Take a Dare(Strother Martin)

Erika Tiffany Smith(Zsa Zsa Gabor)

Eva Grubb(Tina Louise)

Good list, I would say the contestant was the worst though. Can't stand watching his selfishness.

Ericka Tiffany Smith new the Howell's though so even if she didn't have the correct directions she could have said she saw the Howells and they were alive.

callensensei
02-27-2009, 10:00 PM
Hmmm. This would depend on the criteria. If we're basing "least favourite" on just plain hateful characters, my pics would be:

a) Johnathan Kinkaid, the hunter. Psycho and probably would-be serial killer. Get him off the island, and fast. Rory Calhoun did play him marvellously, though.

b) Harold Hecuba. Arrogant and insufferable.

c) Norbett Wiley. Takes advantage of the castaways' genuine kindness. And like Hecuba, he is never made to pay for his sins.

d) George Barkley. Oh, how we wanted to see him fail!

e) Pancho Rodriguez. I don't know why the castaways forgave him so quickly. That part where he is going to shoot Gilligan is pretty intense.

f) Jackson Farrell. He seems to be relatively reasonable, but when he takes Mary Ann hostage, he's scary. Second only to Johnathan Kinkaid as a truly dangerous villain.

g) The ghost. Tall, dark and Russian, and mighty scary.

If we're basing "least favourite" on performance, I would say:

a) Zsa Zsa Gabor as Erika Tiffany Smith. Zsa Zsa Gabor is Zsa Zsa Gabor in everything she's in. She has no versatility whatever. And my God, there's two of her! How many times can you listen to somebody saying "dahlink?"

b) John McGiver as Lord Beasley Waterford. I didn't find this character mean, just dull. I think he needed to be a little more over the top and mad.

And as far as favourite guests:

a) Vito Scotti as the Japanese Sailor and Boris Balinkoff. His ultimately inept villians are so over the top and lovable. You really never believe they could do anyone any harm.

b) The Wellingtons and Les Brown Jr. as the Mosquitoes. They rock!

c) Harold J. Stone as Duboff. That accent gets me every time.

d) Hans Conreid as Wrongway Feldman. I liked dear old Wrongway. He genuinely seemed very fond of the castaways, and I think he was right: they had found paradise.

e) Eddie Little Sky in three roles as natives. In all those appearances he only ever uttered one English word: girl, but he didn't need words to communicate. He brought fierceness and comedy to his roles: not an easy task!

f) technically not a guest but: Bob Denver as Gilligan's Russian double. I felt so sorry for the poor shmuck! He had a mean boss and absolutely no clue what was going on!

richieonline
02-27-2009, 11:06 PM
Definitely Johnathan Kinkaid, the hunter.

callensensei
02-27-2009, 11:26 PM
If you don't like Kinkaid, you might want to look at the AU ending of The Hunter I just posted on the fanfic board. It's called A Beast at Bay.

Steve Carras
03-05-2009, 02:10 AM
Oh..by the way...I don't have a least favorite and love these below but these could be potentially freightening to others.:

That darn scary "Ghost a Go Go" [Richard Keil, aka Jaws, and not the shark, in 1970s Bond films]

Johnathan Kincaid [Rory Calhoun], with his sinister hunting of humans. All he needed was to be a cannibal.

Speaking of which, most of the head hunters.

The Vito Scotti characters..and Zsa Zsa and Phil "Harold hecuba": Silvers and Tina Louise as Eva Grubb, the only perfomers gettig opening special guest star credit.

ph1l
03-05-2009, 04:27 AM
My least favourite was the Mosquitos. Even though Mary Ann and Gilligan liked them I sided with the adults on this one.