Who? Dobie Gillis or Maynard G. Krebs?


I Think Maynard he's cool I mean he's a real protest cat man he's very far out and cute.

I think Maynard is cutest. I love him, and he is so cool. I love his Beat character, even if he is just a stereotype of the beat writers of that time. You can tell if people don't really understand the Beat generation if they call them Beatniks because Beatnik is a cut down.

Dobie is cuter,but Maynard is cooler.

------------------
Richard Ranke

Originally posted by Richard
Dobie is cuter,but Maynard is cooler.

------------------
Richard Ranke

agreed

I think Dobie is the cutest.

I never watch the show!:( But,just by looking at the picture I say...Maynard(bob Denver) is more my type and I find him cuter!I always thought that beatniks were really cool!:cool:

They were both cute (Dwayne only with BROWN,WAVY hair though, he looked cruddy with that blond fuzz). I especially think Maynard was both very cool AND very cute!!! He had such long eyelashes and such a cute little voice! (Of course this applies to Gilligan as well . . .actually now whenever I watch Gilligan I find myself thinking "He looks like Maynard" Well DUH!!!!)

Celine, you never watched "Dobie"!!! :( Awwwww, if you liked Bob as Gilligan, you will LOVE him as Maynard!!! On that show he really went all out, just pure, classic young, cute, handsome Bob Denver at his best.

Dobie definately http://www.candletech.com/forums/images/smilies/biggrin.gif

I thought Dobie was cuter. Maynard was funnier.

;)

I thought Dobie was cuter. Maynard was funnier.

;)

Me, too!

Andrea

if you liked Bob as Gilligan, you will LOVE him as Maynard!!! On that show he really went all out, just pure, classic young, cute, handsome Bob Denver at his best.

Agreed, GingerGilligan. 100%. Bob was a beautiful man.

I think I find Dobie to be cuter, in an all-American boy kind of way. It's cute how respectful he is to his parents (even if he does sometimes use it as a way to win a girl :) ) I think he looked the most handsome in the second season, when he had the lighter brown hair... (his bleached blonde hair in the first season looked so unnatural..)

I find Maynard more funny than cute, although I like how he has a way with animals... if the show had gone on longer, I wonder if he would be TV's first animal rights activist? lol

Its the beard thing, I guess:)

I think Dobie is definitely the cuter of the two.

Dobie, definitely. While I think Maynard is funny, I never thought he was cute.

Dobie, definitely. While I think Maynard is funny, I never thought he was cute.
Maynard is definitely the comic of the show.

I'll vote for Zelda!

How can you resist a face like this?


http://i.ebayimg.com/t/SCRANTON-TV-GUIDE-5-5-1962-DOBIE-GILLIS-SHEILA-JAMES-ABBY-DALTON-LAW-MR-JONES-/00/s/MTEyMFg3NDc=/$T2eC16N,!zcE9s4g0-ZUBQDuT6KVjw~~60_57.JPG

I have a guy friend who always says Zelda is cute. Sheila James always played the "plain Jane" type character. I never thought she was that bad looking...just kind of type-cast in that part. "Hardly a Femme Fatale"...kind of mean in my opinion. At least Zelda did have that giant brain!

Dobie cuter with the blond hair.

I replied to this a long, long time ago but I still say that Dobie is very handsome; especially in the later episodes with his dark hair. Maynard was never cute to me and surprisingly always looked the same thorough the whole series. Dobie changed quite a bit from the beginning but he is definitely better looking with the dark hair. Maynard is hilarious though so it you like a guy with a sense of humor...

Dobie is still cute but the darker hair is growing on me....

Maynard of course!

I like the Beatnik type. Maynard is hot.

Dobie is more handsome and the take home to the parents type of guy, but Maynard also has his qualities.

They are both so different, but both adorable.

I always preferred Dobie's looks over Maynard's although I liked Maynard's personality better.

Dobie is a looker and I think he deserves a girl that's dreamy. :)

I think I would like Maynard better because I think he would be more of a challenge. Dobie is the type of guy who is really forward and the fall all over the girl type right when he sees the girl. I am the play hard to get type and Maynard is the hard to get type. I think once he finds the right girl he knows it like the episode when he met Pearl and fell in love.

Maynard! I love the beatniks :cool::)

Replying again... I still say Dobie but Maynard had a better sense of humor.

I am more the Maynard type. I just don't go for the clean cut type of boy. I mean I don't go for a real bad boy but Maynard isn't actually a bad boy he is well Maynard.

Tuesday Weld, now she's my type!:D

This is a really difficult question because I like things about both Dobie and Maynard. Back when I was in high school a long time ago I would have definitely fell for the Dobie type. The guy who was clean cut, Letterman type. Now though I am sensitive to the free spirit type like Maynard as well.

Maynard for sure !! I'm diggin' him while watching the marathon today ! :cool: Like he looks really cute as a beatnik with the beard ! :)