Yeah. Title says all.

But ummm, I would like the 2 hour Top 12 week back. I didnt think the Top 11 week 2-hour performance round was really nessacary but I wouldnt mind for that to be back either.

And I want the halfway home special back (although during Season 3 it wasnt really a halfway home special). I liked those. It got us to really know the contestants well.

And during the auditions...SHOW MORE GOOD AUDITIONS DARN IT! They were better about it last year then in Season 3 I thought, in S3 half of the top 12's auditions didnt air and in S4, most did, but still, their funny, but too much of them for three straight weeks gets REALLLLLLY annoying.

Oh and yeah, could Paula NOT give a Standing O to every single performance? :lol:

Mmm.. Id like for the person I like to win.

Better Ford commercials! Season 2 had the best.

- Make top 12 week 2 hours. You can tell they rushed it, and it ended up being really crappy afterwards. We NEED to get to know the whole top 12 at this point not on top 6 night.

- Introduce each contestant in the beginning, like they did in Season 2. It's nice to see what each contestant is wearing before they perform.

- More choreographed group songs.

- After every performance, I liked it when they went over to Ryan on the side of the stage to talk and give out the numbers [they did this almost all the time season 1 & 2, rarely in season 3 & 4]

- Show more good auditions.

- Since they know who the top 24 are beforehand, they should make sure to feature each and every top 24 contestant at least once, for more than 30 seconds.

- Halfway Home Specials, definitely.

- No more "group A, group B" stuff.

Better Ford commercials! Season 2 had the best.

^ That too :nod:

Aww I liked this year's ford commericals :lol: Season 3's were ehh. I loved "Fame" though :rotflmao:

David, what do you mean by the "group A, group B" thing? Is that the old semi-final format (the top 32?)

- Since they know who the top 24 are beforehand, they should make sure to feature each and every top 24 contestant at least once, for more than 30 seconds.

I agree. Season 4 was pretty good about it but with Season 3, I noticed half of the top 32's auditions...never aired.

Aww I liked this year's ford commericals :lol: Season 3's were ehh. I loved "Fame" though :rotflmao:

David, what do you mean by the "group A, group B" thing? Is that the old semi-final format (the top 32?)

Yeah I LOVED LOVED LOVED "Fame". They should at least have the ford commercials to where you can SEE the contestants. [The "Love Machine" (top 9) and "Holiday Road" (top 7) commercials were horrible. You could barely tell who was who]

And the group A/B thing, I meant the bottom 3 thing, where they put 3 in group A, 3 in group B, etc. I find the original way more suspenseful :lol:

I agree. Season 4 was pretty good about it but with Season 3, I noticed half of the top 32's auditions...never aired.

Yeah, nobody knew who Jasmine or LaToya were until they performed. Kind of shocking when you think about it.

Yeah I LOVED LOVED LOVED "Fame". They should at least have the ford commercials to where you can SEE the contestants. [The "Love Machine" (top 9) and "Holiday Road" (top 7) commercials were horrible. You could barely tell who was who]

And the group A/B thing, I meant the bottom 3 thing, where they put 3 in group A, 3 in group B, etc. I find the original way more suspenseful :lol:
Oh :lol: lol. Yeah I agree.

I liked most of the AI4 commericals though. The rapping puppets one was HILARIOUS :rotflmao: Some of them were kinda...meh..though. I loved the Rudy one during Top 5 week :rofl: I think that one was my favorite

Yeah, nobody knew who Jasmine or LaToya were until they performed. Kind of shocking when you think about it.
:nod: Same with Bo this season. He was barely shown during the Hollywood rounds.

Diana's audition wasnt shown either, was it?

:nod: Same with Bo this season. He was barely shown during the Hollywood rounds.

Diana's audition wasnt shown either, was it?

Diana's was shown, but to be honest, I remember forgetting about her by the time the semi-finals came along, because she wasn't shown a lot during the Hollywood shows.

Diana's was shown, but to be honest, I remember forgetting about her by the time the semi-finals came along, because she wasn't shown a lot during the Hollywood shows.
Really? I thought she auditioned in Hawaii though and I dled the Hawaii auditions and I dont remember seeing her. Hmmm. Ill have to watch again.

But yeah. They should make an effort to give the top 24 all equal airtime. I mean, Celena Rae and Aloha Misheaux weren't shown ONCE during the Hollywood rounds. Jessica was barely shown either, or Bo. In the episode where they announced the Top 24, they said "Bo Bice" and I was like...WTF? who's he?

I agree with David.

Introduce them in the beginning! I miss that.

BETTER MEDLEYS!! I was extrememly disappointed with this years medleys. I hope it gets better this season.

- Introduce each contestant in the beginning, like they did in Season 2. It's nice to see what each contestant is wearing before they perform.


Yeahh they did that on top 12 and 11 week of AI3. Then they just...stopped. I liked that though; It got you to know what order the contestants were going in.

It'd be nice to see more guest judges during the top 12 rounds.

Better comemrcials yes


OH OH and I want BAAAAD thing sto hapen to all thee abd singers like, say this happens



Simon : What is your name?

Contestant : William Powell

Simon : What wil you sing?

William : I will sing "Total Eclipse of the Heart"

*singing in HIGH VOICE*AND I NEED YOU NOW TON9IIIIIIIIGHT AND I NEED YOU MORE THAN EVEREEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRRR....


Randy : That was completely horrible, I am disgusted

Paula : You have disgusted me you were horrible


Simon : You.... you BASTARD!!! HOW DARE YOU RUINA GREAT SONG??? I WANT TO SEE YOU FALL IN A VAT OF HOT BURNING FIRE NOW!!! THAT WAS HORRIBLE!!!


*William cries*

Simon : Go on , go on, cry like a freakin baby I reckon you take Estrogen? I dont even care

SECURITY TAKE THIS BAD SINGER OUT AND LITERALLY KICK HIM OUT THE DOOR!!!


Guard #1 : Come here you sissy bad singer!!


William : NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO



Guard #2 : Ill kick you where it hurts

*they literally kick and throw him out the door, cut back to Ryan, the guards and judges laughing the asses off evilyl with evil music playing*


THATS a moment for "The Soup"

Better comemrcials yes


OH OH and I want BAAAAD thing sto hapen to all thee abd singers like, say this happens



Simon : What is your name?

Contestant : William Powell

Simon : What wil you sing?

William : I will sing "Total Eclipse of the Heart"

*singing in HIGH VOICE*AND I NEED YOU NOW TON9IIIIIIIIGHT AND I NEED YOU MORE THAN EVEREEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRRR....


Randy : That was completely horrible, I am disgusted

Paula : You have disgusted me you were horrible


Simon : You.... you BASTARD!!! HOW DARE YOU RUINA GREAT SONG??? I WANT TO SEE YOU FALL IN A VAT OF HOT BURNING FIRE NOW!!! THAT WAS HORRIBLE!!!


*William cries*

Simon : Go on , go on, cry like a freakin baby I reckon you take Estrogen? I dont even care

SECURITY TAKE THIS BAD SINGER OUT AND LITERALLY KICK HIM OUT THE DOOR!!!


Guard #1 : Come here you sissy bad singer!!


William : NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO



Guard #2 : Ill kick you where it hurts

*they literally kick and throw him out the door, cut back to Ryan, the guards and judges laughing the asses off evilyl with evil music playing*


THATS a moment for "The Soup"
:lol:

:lol:
:D

Really? I thought she auditioned in Hawaii though and I dled the Hawaii auditions and I dont remember seeing her. Hmmm. Ill have to watch again.

But yeah. They should make an effort to give the top 24 all equal airtime. I mean, Celena Rae and Aloha Misheaux weren't shown ONCE during the Hollywood rounds. Jessica was barely shown either, or Bo. In the episode where they announced the Top 24, they said "Bo Bice" and I was like...WTF? who's he?

OH yeah, I remember now. Diana wasn't on the original Hawaii episode. There was a Monday episode the night before the first episode of the Hollywood rounds -- this particular audition show was to showcase more of the people that got through, and Diana was featured on this one. So was someone else that made it in the top 12, but I can't remember who O_o. I need to rewatch that.

Better comemrcials yes


OH OH and I want BAAAAD thing sto hapen to all thee abd singers like, say this happens



Simon : What is your name?

Contestant : William Powell

Simon : What wil you sing?

William : I will sing "Total Eclipse of the Heart"

*singing in HIGH VOICE*AND I NEED YOU NOW TON9IIIIIIIIGHT AND I NEED YOU MORE THAN EVEREEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRRR....


Randy : That was completely horrible, I am disgusted

Paula : You have disgusted me you were horrible


Simon : You.... you BASTARD!!! HOW DARE YOU RUINA GREAT SONG??? I WANT TO SEE YOU FALL IN A VAT OF HOT BURNING FIRE NOW!!! THAT WAS HORRIBLE!!!


*William cries*

Simon : Go on , go on, cry like a freakin baby I reckon you take Estrogen? I dont even care

SECURITY TAKE THIS BAD SINGER OUT AND LITERALLY KICK HIM OUT THE DOOR!!!


Guard #1 : Come here you sissy bad singer!!


William : NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO



Guard #2 : Ill kick you where it hurts

*they literally kick and throw him out the door, cut back to Ryan, the guards and judges laughing the asses off evilyl with evil music playing*


THATS a moment for "The Soup"
:lol:

Yeahh they did that on top 12 and 11 week of AI3. Then they just...stopped. I liked that though; It got you to know what order the contestants were going in.

Yeah, and it was nice seeing what they were wearing beforehand :lol: I do remember though that on top 12 week of AI3, they messed up the introduction thing, because George (I think) went ahead of time.

Sigh. I remember I used to :heart: Kimberly Caldwell's waves back in Season 2. Hahahaha.

It would've been great if they did it this season, Carrie and Bo would get massive applauses.

ALSOOOO. About the group song thing, I loved the fact that everyone usually received a solo in Season 4, but there was never any upbeat performance except for the Beach Boys Medley. When you think about it, we NEVER got to see Bo or Carrie doing any choreography (Islands in the Stream does NOT count).

:lol:
:D

Yeah, and it was nice seeing what they were wearing beforehand :lol: I do remember though that on top 12 week of AI3, they messed up the introduction thing, because George (I think) went ahead of time.

Sigh. I remember I used to :heart: Kimberly Caldwell's waves back in Season 2. Hahahaha.

It would've been great if they did it this season, Carrie and Bo would get massive applauses.

ALSOOOO. About the group song thing, I loved the fact that everyone usually received a solo in Season 4, but there was never any upbeat performance except for the Beach Boys Medley. When you think about it, we NEVER got to see Bo or Carrie doing any choreography (Islands in the Stream does NOT count).
Yeah :( The group songs were kinda ehh. Some were good. I loved "You Can Shine" though- the one with the instruments.

But "Emotions" or whatever song they sang on top 6 night...was AWFUL. It was all Scott's fault though. He tried to hit the high notes and it...didnt work out :lol:.

OH yeah, I remember now. Diana wasn't on the original Hawaii episode. There was a Monday episode the night before the first episode of the Hollywood rounds -- this particular audition show was to showcase more of the people that got through, and Diana was featured on this one. So was someone else that made it in the top 12, but I can't remember who O_o. I need to rewatch that.
Yeah...Season 3 was HORRIBLE with showing good auditions. They showed like...2 an episode. I guess they did the Monday special cause fans were complaing because there werent any good auditions (barely). I watched the S3 auditions and it was just...wow. There were like NO good auditoners. I guess by Season 4 they learned to make it a little more equal but there were still a LOT of bad auditioners.

OT but I saw another AI5 commerical today :D There was this guy singing (forgot which song he sang *-*) but he was really bad and Simon said "doesnt get much worse then that" and Ryan went "Ouch!!!". Yeah I was exicted cause im pathetic like that. You all should watch Fox...they show a lot of AI commericals.