........Simon Cowell. He is such a cold ass hole. I've seen him tell lots of auditioners that they weren't good! These were people with great voices with potential and I thought they were very good. I am no judge, but I do see who can sing and who can't. I'll bet Simon can't get up on stage and do any better.

If Simon were to go, it would be a fatal mistake; AI's ratings would go down a lot. It would not be the same without him.

He hasn't been a record producer for a few years. He's been in the industry longer than that. Longer than I have been alive, or most people here for that matter. He's heard all kinds of voices and I think he knows a good voice when he hears one.

He doesn't tell people that they are bad just to be mean. He's just giving them a reality check. I think he has toned himself down considerably the past couple of seasons.

If Simon were to go, it would be a fatal mistake; AI's ratings would go down a lot. It would not be the same without him.

He hasn't been a record producer for a few years. He's been in the industry longer than that. Longer than I have been alive, or most people here for that matter. He's heard all kinds of voices and I think he knows a good voice when he hears one.

He doesn't tell people that they are bad just to be mean. He's just giving them a reality check. I think he has toned himself down considerably the past couple of seasons.
I'm sorry, I have to disagree with you. He is too cold. I don't care for him!

........Simon Cowell. He is such a cold ass hole. I've seen him tell lots of auditioners that they weren't good! These were people with great voices with potential and I thought they were very good. I am no judge, but I do see who can sing and who can't. I'll bet Simon can't get up on stage and do any better.


If Simon Left the Show would be A$$-LOL Simon is why I watch this show because he is not a sugar coater and tells it like it really is.

If Simon Left the Show would be A$$-LOL Simon is why I watch this show because he is not a sugar coater and tells it like it really is.
I see you posted below how you hated Paula Abdul. I like her. Simon is staight up ass! He turns away good talent. He also gives credit to not so good talent.

I see you posted below how you hated Paula Abdul. I like her. Simon is staight up ass! He turns away good talent. He also gives credit to not so good talent.


I hate Paula because she is afriad to tell the truth

I hate Paula because she is afriad to tell the truth

I agree with you. Well I mean I don't hate her, but she just gets on my nerves sometimes because she's just waaaayyyyy too nice. Plus a lot of the stuff she says is just so damn corny. "Fantasia, this is like the Olympics and you've just won your gold!" Oh man give me a break. But then again, sometimes I like her because she finds the good in even the worst of the worst performances.

And whoa no way... getting rid of Simon would KILL American Idol! Sure sometimes he's pretty mean, but he is so honest. He's not afraid to speak his mind. And he's definitely the most realistic. Like Paula and Randy could be kissing someone's ass when in reality, they did terrible.. and Simon let's them know the truth. I agree with Brian, he's toned down a lot over the past few seasons. Like yeah, he was really really reeeaaally mean in season 1, but now I don't even see him as mean. I just see him as honest. Brutally honest sometimes, but still honest.

haha I used to want Simon to leave but he's singing the praises for my favorites this year.

If Simon left, I'd jump off a bridge.

Sorry I started this thread for Simon fans. I still say he suxxxx!!!!!

People who don't like Simon should know that he doesn't care, probably likes it that tons of people don't like him. He's the only realistic judge on the show. Randy is cool and so Paula but their comments are so meaningless. No one cares what they say unless Simon agrees. Yeah Simon can be totally mean, but he's telling people the truth, always. I'm not some huge Simon fan, I just think he is super important to the show.

People who don't like Simon should know that he doesn't care, probably likes it that tons of people don't like him. He's the only realistic judge on the show. Randy is cool and so Paula but their comments are so meaningless. No one cares what they say unless Simon agrees. Yeah Simon can be totally mean, but he's telling people the truth, always. I'm not some huge Simon fan, I just think he is super important to the show.
I understand he's being real. But I'm pointing out that he passed up good talent at times. Paula and Randy they are trying to give people the benefit of the doubt before telling people they are not good.

Sorry I started this thread for Simon fans. I still say he suxxxx!!!!!


Just to let you know how popular Simon is, this morning when I woke up I turned to NBC and Guess who I saw? I saw Simon on the Today Show and he was being interviewed by Katie Couric. They were doing a special on SIMON-lol Guess where Randy was at? In his Living Room-LOL

Just to let you know how popular Simon is, this morning when I woke up I turned to NBC and Guess who I saw? I saw Simon on the Today Show and he was being interviewed by Katie Couric. They were doing a special on SIMON-lol Guess where Randy was at? In his Living Room-LOL
I saw that before I went to work this morning. So I turned to the Smurfs instead.

I saw that before I went to work this morning. So I turned to the Smurfs instead.


I'm surprised you don't know that RUDENESS=Entertainment. Lots of guys became famous for being RUDE

Simon
Howard Stern
Donald Trump
Dennis Rodman

I'm surprised you don't know that RUDENESS=Entertainment. Lots of guys became famous for being RUDE

Simon
Howard Stern
Donald Trump
Dennis Rodman
Is that a good thing or bad thing? Howard Stern is more obnoxious than rude.
Donald Trump is arrogant...in a good way. Dennis Rodman just wants attention.

Is that a good thing or bad thing? Howard Stern is more obnoxious than rude.
Donald Trump is arrogant...in a good way. Dennis Rodman just wants attention.


Stern, Simon, and Trump are VERY FUNNY because there intentions are not make anyone laugh-lol That's the best kind of comedy

Stern, Simon, and Trump are VERY FUNNY because there intentions are not make anyone laugh-lol That's the best kind of comedy
Simon ain't funny to me. Personally, I don't think two cents of him.

Simon ain't funny to me. Personally, I don't think two cents of him.
Yeah, we get it. You don't like Simon.

However, some of us DO.

So you can just shut the **** up.

Yeah, we get it. You don't like Simon.

However, some of us DO.

So you can just shut the **** up.
Won't you shut the F-ck up!!! If I hate Simon, then that's my business! I don't give a f-ck if you bash someone I like! Mine your own goddamn business and stay out of mine!

Simon is the show. The acts are would be Gong Show contestants in another generation.

Simon simply lets it hang out. and tells what he thinks.


BLUNT. I would want to know the honest truth.

Simon makes the show fun.

Won't you shut the F-ck up!!! If I hate Simon, then that's my business! I don't give a f-ck if you bash someone I like! Mine your own goddamn business and stay out of mine!
WELL YOU DON'T HAVE TO KEEP ****ING SAYING IT. WE GET IT.

This GARFIELD guy is a hopeless reactionary.

This GARFIELD guy is a hopeless reactionary.
So are you GeorgeWBushGOP, so are you!

WELL YOU DON'T HAVE TO KEEP ****ING SAYING IT. WE GET IT.
You started it! You didn't have to tell me to shut the f-uck up! I'm going to retaliate, you should have expexted that! Now end this thread Simon lovers!

So are you GeorgeWBushGOP, so are you!

No son. I am not George W Bush. Are you Garfield the cat?

No son. I am not George W Bush. Are you Garfield the cat?
I only went by what I see what's written in your basket. Garfield the cat is like myself because we are both "KOOL"

You have trouble keeping your "KOOL"

Alright, fighting over. :D

If you don't like someone, you don't have to repeat it 242x times. It does get a bit annoying.