View Full Version : Some Cancelled Sitcoms that received Good Reviews by TV Guide


TVFactFan
09-26-2004, 03:27 PM
(Grady)-Sanford and Son spinoff that premeired in December of 1975 and was cancelled in March of 1976.

(That's My Mama)-Premired in Sept f 1974 and wa camcelled on Christmas Eve of 1975.

(Ropers)-Premeired in March of 1979 and was cancelled in May of 1980.



I had a chance to see all three shows and the worst of out the Three was the Ropers.

Drab Afterward
12-29-2004, 03:15 PM
...You are correct, "The Ropers" stunk worse than the other twobut had the distinction of starring the girl from "The Bad Seed" all grown up and married to the obnoxious Jeffrey Tambor. They also had a son who would sit around, whining about there not being any friends arounds to play with. He acted like the slow boiling psychopaths you see on A&E allthe time. "He was always such a lovely, quite child", I can hear a neighbor say after he has cut the ropers into pieces.:eek:

TVFactFan
12-29-2004, 07:02 PM
Originally posted by Drab Afterward
...You are correct, "The Ropers" stunk worse than the other twobut had the distinction of starring the girl from "The Bad Seed" all grown up and married to the obnoxious Jeffrey Tambor. They also had a son who would sit around, whining about there not being any friends arounds to play with. He acted like the slow boiling psychopaths you see on A&E allthe time. "He was always such a lovely, quite child", I can hear a neighbor say after he has cut the ropers into pieces.:eek:


His character was defintely not needed on the Ropers. It wasn't any kids on Three's Company so why would they add a kid character to the Ropers cast-LOL?

David
01-04-2005, 06:39 PM
The Ropers received good reviews? I had no idea.

TVFactFan
01-04-2005, 07:25 PM
The Ropers received good reviews? I had no idea.



I was surprised too-LOL

slackermonkey
01-04-2005, 10:32 PM
Didn't Freaks and Geeks, Popular and Andy Richter Controls the Universe get good reviews from them?

David
01-06-2005, 10:51 PM
Didn't Freaks and Geeks, Popular and Andy Richter Controls the Universe get good reviews from them?
I'm not sure about "Popular", but I remember the other 2 getting great reviews.

Caffeine King
01-06-2005, 11:43 PM
MSCL also got rave reviews from fans and critics...too bad the dumbasses at ABC cancelled it! :(

But I heard Claire Danes wouldn't have come back for a 2nd season anyways...too bad the show couldn't have been finalized....

jrb_wi
03-22-2005, 01:28 AM
One show I remember as getting VERY good reviews in the fall preview some years back was Fox's "Woops!" For those that have forgotten, that was the nuclear missile accident-leaving-six-people-alive-on-Earth sitcom (around 1991 or so). I strongly remember TVG saying that with this show, Fox could rule Sunday night.

...Woops!

Glampire
03-23-2005, 02:39 AM
I wanted to chime in here as soon as I saw "Woops!" mentioned. I used to watch that show way back when as a kid, and I recall it being very funny. I don't remember what the reviews on it were, but I don't think it was given a fair shake by Fox. They got rid of it pretty quickly if I recall correctly (which I may not since it was a decade ago, lol).

catlover79
09-20-2008, 01:16 AM
The Ropers received good reviews? I had no idea.
Ditto. :rofl:

Schmoopie
09-20-2008, 04:03 AM
MSCL also got rave reviews from fans and critics...too bad the dumbasses at ABC cancelled it! :(

But I heard Claire Danes wouldn't have come back for a 2nd season anyways...too bad the show couldn't have been finalized....

Yeah, I watched this a few times and it was really good. I can't imagine why they would cancel it. I found the DVD set the other day at Best Buy. It looks like a good set; since it's the entire series. Did they give it a proper send off or did they just end it?

Well, Claire Danes not returning for a 2nd season would have killed it anyway. I hadn't heard that she didn't want to do anymore.

Andrea

MikeLutton
12-18-2008, 09:21 PM
MSCL also got rave reviews from fans and critics...too bad the dumbasses at ABC cancelled it! :(

But I heard Claire Danes wouldn't have come back for a 2nd season anyways...too bad the show couldn't have been finalized....


what is mscl?

catlover79
12-18-2008, 09:48 PM
^ My So-Called Life, which aired on ABC from 1994-95.

jimpickens
12-20-2008, 01:49 AM
AKA Pablo 1984 got good reviews inspite that it stunk. Buffalo Bill 1983-1984 was well received by the viewers and got good reviews.

bencasey
12-20-2008, 04:45 AM
He and She got good reviews.

tmac81s
03-24-2011, 04:15 AM
...You are correct, "The Ropers" stunk worse than the other twobut had the distinction of starring the girl from "The Bad Seed" all grown up and married to the obnoxious Jeffrey Tambor. They also had a son who would sit around, whining about there not being any friends arounds to play with. He acted like the slow boiling psychopaths you see on A&E allthe time. "He was always such a lovely, quite child", I can hear a neighbor say after he has cut the ropers into pieces.:eek:


at least one good thing came from "The Ropers" series....it got them off of "Three's Company" :lol: :crazy:

I don't mean to be a hater. They did have their moments, but they were pretty much the same old joke(s). Helen is horny, Stanley doesn't want to....then Stanley makes some joke about Jack being gay (cut to a too-close up of Stanley's face). It all just got irritating after awhile. Don Knotts' Mr. Furley made me laugh a lot more (and more often).

Just my opinion...but maybe the opinion of the producers too? I remember seeing this thing on TV awhile back about "Three's Company." apparantly, Norman Fell was hesitant to leave the popular, established parent show to do a spin-off, so there was a clause in his contract that if the show was taken off the air within one year, then he could return to "Three's Company." But "The Ropers" was on a little more than that, so they didn't have to take him back. and since they didn't, I'm guessing that they didn't want him back. Of course, Don Knotts may have had a longer contract in place by then, so they didn't have room for both of them. I'm not sure about that part.

They might have figured, "if audiences don't want to watch the Ropers on their own show, maybe they don't want to see them on "Three's Company." :crazy: :lol:

bencasey
03-24-2011, 08:44 PM
He and She got good reviews.


Actually I was just looking through the TV Guides from that year and Cleveland Amory hated the show, putting it as his worst new sitcom of the year. However his taste wasn't too bad as he loved Occasional Wife, Run Buddy Run and Love on a Rooftop. All of which lasted a season or less.

factsoflife
09-02-2011, 09:55 PM
I'm not sure about "Popular", but I remember the other 2 getting great reviews.

Popular got mixed reviews; leaning towards the negative. Most critics praised the show for eventually finding a witty groove that set it apart from other teen drama's on the WB, but ultimately it was seen as lacking in substance and depth.