Good or bad?

It think she was good.

------------------
~*~Allison~*~
---------------
Dixie Carter, Julia Duffy, and Lisa Whelchel rock!
---------------
Designing Women
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
JULIA: Please, if you really want to feel like crying try being one of those women who hold down a job, raise a family on the side, watch their legal rights erode year after year, and are still being told that women's liberation went to far. That ought to make you feel like crying. Hhhoooo!
---------------
Newhart
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
STEPHANIE: Don't call me, don't try to see me, and if you think you can get to me by sending me gifts, then I guess I can't stop you.
---------------
Facts of Life
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
BLAIR: If I'm not perfect, and that's a big if, it certainly wasn't his place to say.
JO: You'e right, it's mine!

I thought she was good too.

------------------
B.TELL IT TO THE FROG.
GO ON TELL IT TO HIS FACE. YOU CAN'T CAN YOU? YOU KNOW WHY? BECAUSE HE DOESN'T HAVE A FACE.

The Maggie episodes are my favorites (especially the Mary Ann Mobley episodes).
Drmnd 86

I loved Mary Anne Mobley too. I loved her accent and thought sge was great when she was grieving over Sam's kidnapping. Pearl messed up when she set an extra plate for Sam at the table forgetting for a minute that Sam wasn't even there.

I think she is very talented, especially at the end of the first part of Sam gets kidnapped when she says to please bring back her son with tears dripping down her face and they freeze with a quiet pause.

I liked Dixie Carter as Maggie. I really haven't seen any of the other ones.

------------------
~*~Allison~*~
---------------
Dixie Carter, Julia Duffy, and Lisa Whelchel rock!
---------------
Designing Women
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
JULIA: Please, if you really want to feel like crying try being one of those women who hold down a job, raise a family on the side, watch their legal rights erode year after year, and are still being told that women's liberation has gone too far. That ought to make you feel like crying. Hhhoooo!
---------------
Newhart
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
STEPHANIE: Don't call me, don't try to see me, and if you think you can get to me by sending me gifts, then I guess I can't stop you.
---------------
Facts of Life
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
BLAIR: If I'm not perfect, and that's a big if, it certainly wasn't his place to say.
JO: You're right, it's mine!

Well I just found out this morning that Dixie was fired. It turns out that Gary didn't like her. He fired her indirectly.

PPPPPPPPPPUUUUUUUURRRRRRRRFFFFFFFFEEEEEEEECCCCCCCCTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!! Atb least Dixie Carter was. I love Dixie Carter!!!:happyface

Dixie Carter just annoyed me, I thought Mar Ann was much prettier and did a better job. I think it was probably a good thing Gary got rid of Dixie.

Originally posted by JethroSimpson
Dixie Carter just annoyed me, I thought Mar Ann was much prettier and did a better job. I think it was probably a good thing Gary got rid of Dixie.

She annoyed you Jethro? I thought she was good. It's funny because I like Mary Ann Mobley also. Do you think Maggie #2 showed more warmth than Maggie #1? I thought both Actresses were good.

Originally posted by JethroSimpson
Dixie Carter just annoyed me, I thought Mar Ann was much prettier and did a better job. I think it was probably a good thing Gary got rid of Dixie. :mad: Get a life, and get your facts straight!!!

Got a life thanks Mary-Ann, I think it's you who needs to go and get one. By the way, what exactly do you mean by get your facts right?

I did think Mary Ann played the role of Maggie with a lot more love and effection and I just think she's gebnerally a better actress, she also seemed to make the part more believable.

I probably shouldn't have said that about Gary getting rid of Dixie being a good thing but for some reason she just really annoys me!

I think Maggie was alright. Sam was hilarious though! He was a great addition to the show.

Sam & Maggie ruined the show they just ANNOYED ME! Those accents! lol

:happyface DIXIE CARTER IS SO MUCH BETTER!!!!!! DUH!!!!!:cool:

As for my opinion....Dixie was MUCH better. She WAS Maggie, and I thought her and Sam got along great....I never cared for Arnold though....he was just MEAN to Sam.....I know Gary carried the show, but I just loved Dixie Carter in the role of Maggie!!! I just.....she WAS Maggie!

Originally posted by HALANDME
As for my opinion....Dixie was MUCH better. She WAS Maggie, and I thought her and Sam got along great....I never cared for Arnold though....he was just MEAN to Sam.....I know Gary carried the show, but I just loved Dixie Carter in the role of Maggie!!! I just.....she WAS Maggie!

:D :D :D I so totally agree:D :D :D

I agree, it was really out of order the way Arnold treated Sam and Willis (in the later episodes) The writers seemed to think they could get an easy laugh with Arnold making a joke at someone else's expence.

I agree with you tootiefan, I didn't like the addition of Maggie or Sam either, but if I had to choose which Maggie was better I would say Mary Ann, Dixie was alright but she is the reason I don't really like the character of Maggie.

Originally posted by danithang
I agree with you tootiefan, I didn't like the addition of Maggie or Sam either, but if I had to choose which Maggie was better I would say Mary Ann, Dixie was alright but she is the reason I don't really like the character of Maggie.

I guess Gary would agree with you. Not that I have an issue with her. I loved Dixie's accent. But I also like MaryAnn Mobley.

Originally posted by danithang
I agree with you tootiefan, I didn't like the addition of Maggie or Sam either, but if I had to choose which Maggie was better I would say Mary Ann, Dixie was alright but she is the reason I don't really like the character of Maggie.
:eek: I SO LIKE DISAGREE! DIXIE CARTER SO RULED:D IN THE ROLE OF MAGGIE MCKINNEY! MARYANN MOLDEY SUCKED!!!!:D

Mary Anne Mobley was just fine.

Mary Ann Mobley was good but Dixie Carter was better!:D

Mary Ann Mobley was so much better than Dixie Carter, i really thought she acted well in the "Sam's Missing" episodes, I can't imagine Dixie Carter acting in that way.

The one's without Dixie Carter were just not as good!:)