He's cute and a nice guy, but I don't think I'd consider a serious relationship with him. Too anal-retentive for my tastes.

Oh, God, YES!! Did you really have to ask?!! I can be pretty anal at times, so his anal-retentiveness would bother me much.

Everybody knows my answer...

I'd totally date Joe. He has a lot of the qualities that I look for in a guy... and as a bonus, he's gorgeous, too! lol.
Some people say he's too anal at times. Well, I can be the same way about certain things, so that wouldn't bother me at all.

I would love to date Joe.....repeatedly. ;)

of course, I would love to date Joe, Id date Brian, or even Antonio ... :D