Which Colleen did you like better?

#1 Erika Flores
#2 Jessica Bowman

I like Jessico Bowman better.

Jessica Bowman, IMO Erika Flores's Colleen was too whiny and too whimpy!

I like Erika Flores Colleen better.

Jessica because she was not only beautiful but more grown-up and mature!!

It is hard for me to choose because they were both good and special in different ways. Ericka will always be young Colleen to me but Jessica will always be the more mature one who got to grow up on DQMW. So I cannot choose, I love them both!

Ericka is the best I think. I have seen her in movies after leaving the show and interviews and she acts grown up and isn't a stuck up.

Erika since she was Colleen from the beginning. It´s always unfair to the actor who has to replace someone else, it takes some getting used to, which I did after a while. But anyway I felt that the "real" Colleen wasn´t there.

Definitely Jessica Bowman.

I always much preferred Jessica Bowman, although I will say Erika Flores has grown on me the more I watch the show.

Erika was my favorite Colleen. Jessica's Colleen just annoyed me.

Erika no question!!