This is the way I think which people out of the seven Survivor shows(so far, seven with eight up the alley.) should be on the All-Star edition:

Survivor 1: Dirk, Jenna, Colleen, Gervase, Rudy(every show needs a bad guy. He is it!!)
Survivor 2: Rodger, Elisabeth, Jeff, Colby, Jerri(bad girl again!!)
Survivor 3: Kim J, Teresa(T-Bird), Ethan(like Rodger, Elisabeth, Dirk, Jenna, Colleen, Colby), Lex(the bad guy)
4. Survivor 4: Pascal, Nelah, Veecipia, John(the gay guy also the bad guy), Tammy(like Jerri, a witch!!)
Survivor 5: John the preacher(revenge for voting him out first), Helen, Ted, Jan, Brian(the bad guy)
Survivor 6: Jenna(the bad girl who stripped for Playboy), Daniel(diversity would help), Deana, and two others names that I don't know, both male and female.
Survivor 7: Andrew(aka Savage), Rupert, Lill, Burton, Darrah, Sandra(like Daniel, diversity is all-important!!!

thats a cool idea!!!:)

Mix in the good, neutral, and bad characters that would make an excellent edition!!

LOL, The winners for the 1st two seasons shouldn't be on the ALL STARS?

I think that the show should get a good guy, netural(bad or good), & bad guy or girl.

Ghandia, Tanya, Jan, & Helen need to come back! Also...Tina & Joanna

I know this is unlikely to happen but I would love to see a fun-for-all free-for-all punching contest.