What do you think was the best season of American Idol?

Season 2 was beyond better!

Season 2 baby

season 2 :)

speaking of season 1..... we never talk about it. but im sure there might be another thread about this somewhere hhere. Who were ur faves?

I liked Kelly of course, Taymra, RJ, Nikki (i dont know why everyone hated her. Just because she beat Tamyra isnt a reason to bash on her. Its pretty big to beat her. And personally on that week, i actually thought Justin was gonna go home, cuz it was Nikki's best week, and taymra... is just Taymra). ANYWAYS! I also liked Christina and Justin.

The other people were okay/bad. lol

Kelly, Justin, and Tamyra should have made the final 3 because they were the best ones. RJ had mostly mediocre performances. Christina was also good, but was eliminated too early. Jim and AJ were the only ones I really didn't like, I thought they were bad and didn't even deserve to make the top ten. EJay day is really good on the "Greatest Moments" CD, I liked him. I also enjoy listening to Nikki on the CD, but I think she made it a little to far in the competition. Instead of getting 3rd place, she probably should have gotten 5th. Ryan Starr was also one of my favorites because she's talented and sexy.

Originally posted by Cletus114
Kelly, Justin, and Tamyra should have made the final 3 because they were the best ones. RJ had mostly mediocre performances. Christina was also good, but was eliminated too early. Jim and AJ were the only ones I really didn't like, I thought they were bad and didn't even deserve to make the top ten. EJay day is really good on the "Greatest Moments" CD, I liked him. I also enjoy listening to Nikki on the CD, but I think she made it a little to far in the competition. Instead of getting 3rd place, she probably should have gotten 5th. Ryan Starr was also one of my favorites because she's talented and sexy. Beisdes kazaa, do u know where I can download Ryan's "You Really GOt Me".... I heard on other forums that its really bad. im just curious to how bad it was. But Ryan was pretty okay. lol. She kinda stumbled on her words a lot though

My favorite on season 1 was Tamyra.

Season 2 ..i was mad when Kim C. got kicked off though :(

Originally posted by PaulaAbdulFan
Season 2 ..i was mad when Kim C. got kicked off though :(
i was too!!!!!! I was raging mad!