Here are a few questions of which is better.

Dave and Lisa together or apart?

Dave and Lisa's relationship, secret or out in the open?

Catherine or no Catherine?

Early years Matthew or Later years Matthew?

This is kind of pointless asking, but:

Bill McNeal or Max Louis?

Dave and Lisa together or apart?

together

Dave and Lisa's relationship, secret or out in the open?

Out in the open. Secret was funny, but would have gotten old really quickly.

Catherine or no Catherine?

Catherine. She and Bill were real funny together.

Early years Matthew or Later years Matthew?

Early years Matthew. Later years Matthew weirded me out.

This is kind of pointless asking, but:

Bill McNeal or Max Louis?

Definitely pointless in asking :) Bill is by far much better.

Dave and Lisa together or apart?

together

Dave and Lisa's relationship, secret or out in the open?

Out in the open.

Catherine or no Catherine?

Catherine.

Early years Matthew or Later years Matthew?

They were both funny

This is kind of pointless asking, but:

Bill McNeal or Max Louis?

Bill, Max is just annoying

Dave and Lisa together or apart?
definelty TOGETHER!!!!!
Dave and Lisa's relationship, secret or out in the open?
i liked both, but open a bit more, i think...
Catherine or no Catherine?
Catherine *slaps*
Early years Matthew or Later years Matthew?
early years matthew
This is kind of pointless asking, but:

Bill McNeal or Max Louis?
bill, but max tried.

Dave and Lisa together or apart? Together

Dave and Lisa's relationship, secret or out in the open? Out

Catherine or no Catherine? No Catherine, I liked Catherine but there were so many characters vying for screen time & Catherine always was underused, plus season 4 has grown to be my favorite season edging out season 3.

Early years Matthew or Later years Matthew? Early Matthew, the later years Matthew grated on my nerves.

This is kind of pointless asking, but:

Bill McNeal or Max Louis? Bill, of course

Here's another one--How about Walt or no Walt?