Josh, Trenyce, Kimberly Locke, and especially Ruben gave great perfomances last night. I think that Clay has a wonderful voice, but he needs to sing something besides ballads all the time. Kimberly Caldwell and Rickey were just so-so, and Carmen was just terrible.

It was great seeing Lionel Ritchie last night. I have really been impressed with the celebrity judges that have been appearing on the show. I don't want to spoil anything for the people who have no clue about another special guest judge that will be making an appearance, but believe me - this person is a true American Idol.

Originally posted by Rob1
and Carman was just terrible.


oh please. hater hater hater. my friend who hates carmen and says she sings like a goat even thought she did good last night. AI judges are just bitches.