Who do you think was hot in the show. I though it was Donna Reed.

Paul Peterson

Shelley Fabares by a long shot. She aged gracefully. She was still a hottie on Coach.

Shelley Fabares by a long shot. She aged gracefully. She was still a hottie on Coach.
Shelley Fabares and you are right. She is still hot.

Shelley for sure. And Donna, too, without a doubt. Especially during the last season. I'd just turned 12 at that point in time. End of story!!

Donna Reed and Carl Betz were both extremely hot, IMO.

Dr. Alex Stone

Donna Reed ofcourse.
She was such a classic beauty. All the way back to It's a Wonderful Life. Yes She was the Hot one

As an old married lady, my vote goes to Alex for hotness. I think he was the best looking dad in TVLand. But Donna was glowingly beautiful. Looks-wise they were a great match.

Here's a great look at Donna from a magazine clipping (scanned from a family scrapbook):

http://i111.photobucket.com/albums/n127/star-hawkins/0000118.jpg

Very pretty.

Donna all the way, while Shelley was pretty her character was a spoiled brat, she really got on my nerves.

Paul Peterson gets my vote.

The WHOLE FAMILY was great--and this gave the show a nice balance. A tad bit unusual, though, as many shows have actors/characters who really stand out.

I always thought Donna was nice looking, but wouldnt call her hot. My sister used to call her needle nose.

Shelly Fabres was very pretty (and still was in Coach), as well as Donna Reed.

Andrea

Paul Peterson

There was something about Donna Reed that drove me wild.

Though I never cared much for Shelley Fabare's rather skinny frame or her pug nose, I thought she had very sexy eyes.

Donna and Shelley.

The Stones were quite possibly the best-looking family on television! As an added bonus the kids actually looked like they could belong to those parents, unlike many sitcoms where a group of actors are assembled as a family without a regard to how they look.