a few days ago they showed the episode were they have a miss cast away constest on the island and i was wondoring if you were the judges who would win?. would it be the rich lovey howell, the bueatiful Ginger grant or the sweet and innocent mary ann summers?. i'm a girl so of course i wont be judging by the prettiest. so... who do you think should win?.

Yep

well so far its a tie between ginger and mary ann...gosh we need more people to vote on this poll...

All right...I voted for Mary Ann. I know I'm a girl, but she is quite beautiful and a good match for Gilligan. ;)

Originally posted by doorcountygirl
All right...I voted for Mary Ann. I know I'm a girl, but she is quite beautiful and a good match for Gilligan. ;)

i agree thats why i voted for her too. :)

I though Mary Anne was the hottest and prefect for Giligan. She was the hottest. Ever though Ginger was the movie star.

Mary Ann, because she's the one I identify with most, because I have dark hair and I like to cook

I would vote for Mary Ann. She's living proof that wholesome can be sexy!!

:wave: ;) :) All right...I voted for Mary Ann. I know I'm a girl, but she is quite beautiful and a good match for Gilligan. ;)
I agree

I want to point out something. Gilligan didn't want to be forced to choose, so he elected Gladys the chimp because she was a native of the island.

But the contest was called 'Miss Castaway', not 'Miss Island', and Gladys was not a castaway.

So Gilligan should have been forced to choose, and face the wrath of the two losers!

I'd definitely vote for Mary Ann.:D

But the contest was called 'Miss Castaway', not 'Miss Island', and Gladys was not a castaway.

So Gilligan should have been forced to choose, and face the wrath of the two losers!

Yes!

The safest choice out of the 3 would've been Lovey. I can't see Mary Ann and Ginger getting all up in a huff over her winning the way they would if one of them had gotten the nod.

Can you imagine how unbearable Thurston would have been if Lovey had won, lol!

Funny episode! How the men were trying to sabotage the ladies who they didn't want to win!! Kudos to Gilligan for voting for the ape, and not getting in trouble with with the other guys!

Funny episode! How the men were trying to sabotage the ladies who they didn't want to win!! Kudos to Gilligan for voting for the ape, and not getting in trouble with with the other guys!
Are we even serious here. Just one look at Ginger's spectacular, head turning song and dance number gives it to Ginger HANDS DOWN. This isn't a contest to determine who's the sweetest or whos the best girl for Gilligan..ITS A BEAUTY CONTEST. Ginger is by far the sexiest WOMAN, while Mary Ann is a girl. Just one question...could Mary Ann do what Ginger did in the talent portion? We know Ginger could do a simple soft shoe dance in her sleep.

I still go for Mary Ann.

Are we even serious here. Just one look at Ginger's spectacular, head turning song and dance number gives it to Ginger HANDS DOWN. This isn't a contest to determine who's the sweetest or whos the best girl for Gilligan..ITS A BEAUTY CONTEST. Ginger is by far the sexiest WOMAN, while Mary Ann is a girl. Just one question...could Mary Ann do what Ginger did in the talent portion? We know Ginger could do a simple soft shoe dance in her sleep.


:D :lol: If my memory serves me, didn't Mrs. Howell recite a poem for her talent portion? I remember it was a was a yawn fest! :rolleyes:

:D :lol: If my memory serves me, didn't Mrs. Howell recite a poem for her talent portion? I remember it was a was a yawn fest! :rolleyes:
Ginger was the sexiest. They would never send Mary Ann to try and seduce any male visitors or Gilligan. Just look at that body in the swimsuit competition. She is the emobiment of sexiness and glamor.

Ginger was the sexiest. They would never send Mary Ann to try and seduce any male visitors or Gilligan. Just look at that body in the swimsuit competition. She is the emobiment of sexiness and glamor.
obviously Gilligan couldn't have voted for anyone or absorb the wrath of the other two men so what he did was very socratic, and if he did vote for anyone it would probably be mary ann. but if we look at this objectively with an objective judge Ginger was the runaway winner, not even close. True her speech was stupid and repetitive but so were lovie's and maryann's. so we will cancel that out. but the swimsuit and talent competitions were showcases for the talent and sexiness of Ginger Grant.