Jack1000
12-07-2002, 02:19 PM
Guys,
I've always been interested in the TV and Movie industry ratings for many years. Sometimes though a theatrical movie gets a rating that I think is too high or too low. (I am speaking of the original uncut theatrical film.) Sometimes the Motion Picture Association of America will change a movie rating to attract a younger audience. For example, Midnight Cowboy, was the first film, originally rated "X" because it indirectly dealt with a homosexual relationship between Dustin Hoffman and John Voiet. This was a taboo topic in 1969. The film won the Acadamy Award for best picture in 1969 and was later changed to an "R" rating. Today, I would give the film a PG-13. There is like one sex scene in the film and some mild langage (by today's standards) but an X-rating was too much, even back in '69.
The Jerk, Steve Martin's Classic film got an R-rating in '79. Despite Navin's dog being called "****head" and some sexually-suggested dialogue with the "motercycle lady" this is another film that could have been PG-13. (They didn't have the PG-13 rating back in '79, so they had to go with the 'R")
Rain Main: Another great film, but why did this get an "R"? There is light profanity and that's it. That could have been a PG or at MOST a PG-13
AS FOR FILMS THAT GOT RATED TOO LOW:
Good Will Hunting: Rated "R" A very good film and a moving story, but every other word is F***. You could take out 75% of that and still have a good story. But the bad language is non-stop and strong enough for an NC-17. Did that film break the record for profanity in a movie? Somebody told me that Goodfellas holds the record. I have never seen Goodfellas for that reason, but if a film is going to have that much profanity in it....make it NC-17.
Jack
I've always been interested in the TV and Movie industry ratings for many years. Sometimes though a theatrical movie gets a rating that I think is too high or too low. (I am speaking of the original uncut theatrical film.) Sometimes the Motion Picture Association of America will change a movie rating to attract a younger audience. For example, Midnight Cowboy, was the first film, originally rated "X" because it indirectly dealt with a homosexual relationship between Dustin Hoffman and John Voiet. This was a taboo topic in 1969. The film won the Acadamy Award for best picture in 1969 and was later changed to an "R" rating. Today, I would give the film a PG-13. There is like one sex scene in the film and some mild langage (by today's standards) but an X-rating was too much, even back in '69.
The Jerk, Steve Martin's Classic film got an R-rating in '79. Despite Navin's dog being called "****head" and some sexually-suggested dialogue with the "motercycle lady" this is another film that could have been PG-13. (They didn't have the PG-13 rating back in '79, so they had to go with the 'R")
Rain Main: Another great film, but why did this get an "R"? There is light profanity and that's it. That could have been a PG or at MOST a PG-13
AS FOR FILMS THAT GOT RATED TOO LOW:
Good Will Hunting: Rated "R" A very good film and a moving story, but every other word is F***. You could take out 75% of that and still have a good story. But the bad language is non-stop and strong enough for an NC-17. Did that film break the record for profanity in a movie? Somebody told me that Goodfellas holds the record. I have never seen Goodfellas for that reason, but if a film is going to have that much profanity in it....make it NC-17.
Jack