I like both shows but Newhart is much better. Ratings in their head-to-head showdown did not reflect that, though. ALF finished #12 and Newhart was down at #54, just 11 spots ahead of its fall leadout Coming of Age which was yanked after one month.

Newhart, but it's not a blowout.

Alf ate cats. Bob didn't (as far as we knew). So Alf wins.

Alf ate cats. Bob didn't (as far as we knew). So Alf wins.Valerie is disappointed in you being such a big cat hater. :nonono:

Valerie is disappointed in you being such a big cat hater. :nonono:

You know it. Promise not to tell.

I prefer Newhart

I voted for Newhart. And that's coming from someone who owns more than 4 dozen comic books from the Marvel Comics ALF series...! :)

Alf ate cats. Bob didn't (as far as we knew). So Alf wins.

In Bob Newhart's third TV series called " Bob" from the early 90's, there was a beautiful cat in the cast. Bob and his wife in the show had a lovely silver tabby cat. All cats are adorable , but this one was exceptionally beautiful! :)

ALF

I voted for Newhart. And that's coming from someone who owns more than 4 dozen comic books from the Marvel Comics ALF series...! :)

In Bob Newhart's third TV series called " Bob" from the early 90's, there was a beautiful cat in the cast. Bob and his wife in the show had a lovely silver tabby cat. All cats are adorable , but this one was exceptionally beautiful! :)

Besides the cat, Marvel Comics also came out of that third Newhart series

https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=84481

Newhart :)

Newhart

Newhart

Love both but I’d pick Newhart

Seems like we all like Newhart :)

As a kid, I would have said ALF. I loved that show. But as an adult, I still like ALF but I've come to really appreciate and love Newhart. It's become a favorite of mine. So, I went with Newhart.